SUGAR | Eyeless Jack x Reader
- Reads 6,878
- Votes 277
- Parts 37
MatureOngoing6h 15m
Last published Mon, Jun 22, 2026
"Sugar, I've developed a taste for you now."
The appearance of a deranged serial killer has everyone in your town on edge. After staying out at work too late, you stumble upon the killer's most recent scene. You report it to the authorities and go on with your life, but in the days that follow, you notice an uncomfortable presence that seems to accompany you wherever you go. When work keeps you late again, your stalker takes advantage, abducting you. Will you escape? Or will you give in to the curious fascination that's steadily growing for your captor?
All Rights Reserved
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
Waiting for the Dark (Slenderman fic)
You didn't mean to fall for him. He was supposed to be a monster. He didn't mean to fall for you. You wear supposed to be another weak and silly human. But strange things happen. And maybe it won't be so bad?Complete![ππππ πππ ππππ’? [β] {Jeff the Killer x Gender Neutral Reader}](https://img.wattpad.com/cover/348557389-256-k183530.jpg)
ππππ πππ ππππ’? [β] {Jeff the Killer x Gender Neutral Reader}
In order to save your life, Slenderman does what he swore he'd never do - he makes you his proxy. Little did you know how much it would change your life... - - - The reader is kept gender-neutral throughout the whole story and smut chapters always have two versions (one for male and one for female anatomy). Tldr; this is a creepypasta x reader fanfic, let's not take it *too* seriously. Characters here are probably very OOC, I shaped them as I wish to create a fun story ;3Complete
ππ’πππ’ ππ¨ππ² π± ππππππ«: ππ²ππ¬ ππ πππππ’π
"I told you the night you tried to kill me; he's not your God." Sequel to An Eye For An Eye. Years after The Subordinate is closed, Y/N attempts to rebuild her life and recover from her short-lived romance with Toby. He's a changed man since becoming a proxy, with memory loss and lust for murder. Her heart still longs for him even years later. Will their relationship ever be repaired? The Slenderman is keeping an eye on them. TW: Mature themes!Complete
Killer couple ( Jeff the killer x reader)
Your kidnapped by a man who claims to be called Jeff the killer. You don't want to be here and he claims you as his own. You try to escape on so many attempts but you don't succeed . This will take you on all sorts of twisted adventures this will start to change you into someone else .Will you stay or leave this toxic romance? If you do then why did you?Complete
Rose Petals - Eyeless Jack x Reader
You always wanted a way out of town and away from the trauma of your every day life, but who knew it would come to you in a blue mask? Your life was certainly troubled. You had no parents- they were stripped away from you by a faceless thing in the woods one night when you were a small child. You had a troubled friend group. You had a stressful, mind-numbing minimum wage job. You had a broken home, completed by the drunken, careless uncle who had once promised to take care of you and your siblings. It made you want to disappear. The grey man dressed in black was a surprise to you after a chaotic night at home, and it was just his luck you even found him. However, what you thought to be a strange new friend was lethal and full of old horrors, and you soon come to find that he wants to be much more than just friends. (Cover art belongs to me!) Started: 8/26/2022 First Published: 10/15/2022 Finished: [Pending]Complete
My Killer Of A lover (eyeless x reader)
you're a new rookie killer, and slender takes notice of you right away. You get ready to kill the news reporter that was talking shit about you, but someone beat you to it. the one and only Jeff the killer. Jeff tries to kill you but fails. this really got Slender's attention. suddenly your taken hostage by the creepypasta group, and slender keeps talking about you secret.will you tell him? You meet EJ and for some reason you don't feel afraid when you're with him. He is basically your babysitter now. You start having feeling for him and he acts really sexual towards you. What?Complete
Reminiscence (Eyeless Jack X Reader)
(Y/n) (m/n) (l/n), an orphan, is a student in a medical college. Her friends and her love, Jack helped her with any problem, being nothing but plain kind to her. She had a normal college life, just like most of the people.... Until something drastic happened to her. Unfortunately, she witnesses her love die in front of her. The incident causes a deep sorrow to embed itself in her heart, however, she hid it, for the sake of her precious family, her mother and brother, even though they are not related. As she continues on with life, new things take place, she discovers things that she never thought existed, and these things are not human, or anything friendly. She is pulled away from her normal life, and thrown into a world of living nightmares, with a constant threat looming over her and her family. What will she do? Will she find her love? Will she be able to pull him from his insanity? Will she survive this madness? ~Read to find out~ Warning: profanity is present, mentions of blood, gore and maybe violence (what do expect, this is a creepypasta story.)Complete
Hoodie x Reader - Met you at a restaurant
(im sorry if this story's cringy, i made it 3 years ago lmao) You were eating in a restaurant with a few of your mates. You make eye contact with one of the people eating at the restaurant, he makes eye contact with you. as you looked into his eyes you saw kindness, gentleness, your heart even began to swell a bit. little did you know he was out to get you..Complete
You didn't mean to fall for him. He was supposed to be a monster. He didn't mean to fall for you. You wear supposed to be another weak and silly human. But strange things happen. And maybe it won't be so bad?
More detailsContent Guidelines