WRONG CHOICE
- Reads 2,291
- Votes 45
- Parts 32
Ongoing3h 22m
Last published Sat, Jun 6, 2026
Tom Riddle and Aura Nightlock have never gotten along, but when they are chosen as head boy and girl of Slytherin, they are forced to spend more and more time together.
Tom frequently disappears, not showing up for meals and skipping lessons, and one day Aura follows him, uncovering his dark, shocking secret.
Aura agrees to aid him in his plans for Hogwarts, and they grow closer, trying-and failing-not to acknowledge their obvious lust for one other.
Will Aura truly be able to help Tom, or will his constant lies and selfish obsession with self-preservation ruin everything?
Find out in 'Wrong Choice'
All Rights Reserved
#362
narcissablack
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
My Dark Lady (Tom riddle X Reader)
Y/n Malfoy's family decided to make an arranged marriage between Lord Voldemort's oldest son Tom Riddle and their daughter Y/n. Its Y/n's last year in Hogwarts and once she graduates she has to get married. Y/n has hated Tom since their first days at Hogwarts and Tom wasn't dying for her either. The things were going to get complicated but at least they were going to be safe, right? Would Y/n's anger go away over time? Would Tom be able to love her or at least have some sympathy? !! In this fanfiction Voldemort and Bellatrix are parents of Tom and Mattheo Riddle!! TW! This book includes smut, uncensored words, eating disorder, depression, suicidal thoughts, self harm, drug addiction and alcoholism.Complete
I Can See You - ᴛʜᴇᴏ ɴᴏᴛᴛ x ꜰᴇᴍ ᴏᴄ
𝑾𝒉𝒆𝒏 𝒘𝒂𝒓 𝒃𝒓𝒆𝒂𝒌𝒔 𝒕𝒉𝒆 𝒘𝒐𝒓𝒍𝒅, 𝒘𝒉𝒐 𝒅𝒐 𝒚𝒐𝒖 𝒃𝒆𝒄𝒐𝒎𝒆? Seren Thorne never wanted to be a hero. She just wanted to survive Hogwarts - to keep her head down while shadows lengthened across the wizarding world. But when the Dark Lord's grip tightens, secrets unravel, loyalties fracture, and Seren finds herself caught between the boy she can't trust, the boy she can't forget, and the war that will claim them all. Friendship, love, and betrayal collide as Seren is forced to choose: fight for the light, or be consumed by the darkness chasing herComplete
𝐓𝐡𝐞 𝐄𝐢𝐠𝐡𝐭𝐡 𝐇𝐨𝐫𝐜𝐫𝐮𝐱 » 𝐭.𝐦.𝐫
"You're absolutely infuriating." He breathed out, pressing her body against the bookshelf with his own. His dark eyes brewed with irritation, and another emotion she couldn't quite decipher. "Trust me." She said, her chest heaving with every breath as her lips centimetres from his. "The feeling is mutual." Updates are every Monday Highest rankings 5 in #wizard 1 in #tom 9 in #wizardingworld 9 in #wizardsandwitches 6 in #lordvoldemort 8 in #muggle 6 in #ravenclawComplete
The Madness We Make (Tom riddle x reader)
Tom Riddle didn't want a queen; he wanted an equal. He found her in [Y/N] Nott, Theodore's sharp-witted sister, whose ambition burned as brightly as his own. Their relationship wasn't a romance-it was a merger. A pact between two cunning, power-hungry souls who recognized the same beautiful darkness in each other. While Theo stood by his friend, he grew increasingly terrified of the woman his sister was becoming. Together, Tom and [Y/N] were not just dating; they were a dual storm, encouraging each other's most violent and grandiose fantasies. They didn't just want to rule the world. They wanted to break it and rebuild it in their twisted image. Love is a weapon. Power is the prize. And sanity is the first casualty.Complete
Fractured Devotion
Elara Vale never intended to fall in love with Tom Riddle. Quiet, observant, and fiercely intelligent, she thought her years at Hogwarts would be defined by books, ambition, and the occasional whispered mystery in the dark. But everything changes when she crosses paths with the brilliant and magnetic Tom-handsome, impossibly composed, and harboring secrets far deeper than anyone dares to imagine. As their bond deepens from academic curiosity to something far more dangerous, Elara is drawn into Tom's ever-expanding circle of influence-a group of charismatic students with chilling loyalties and whispered ambitions. Together, they navigate exams, ancient magic, and growing unrest within the wizarding world. But what begins as infatuation slowly spirals into something else: a love that entangles her, a power that isolates her, and a darkness that demands more than she ever meant to give. Torn between the promise of belonging and the instincts urging her to run, Elara must decide how far she's willing to follow the boy who would become a legend-and what pieces of herself she's willing to sacrifice in the name of love. A slow-burn descent into obsession, manipulation, and twisted devotion, this is not a fairytale romance. It's the beginning of something far more dangerous.
No room for romance (Draco Malfoy x Reader)
"I've robbed so many of loved ones Draco; it's not fair that that I get what I stole from them." Y/n Riddle is a young girl with immense power that is very hard to control, she has always been destined to rule the wizarding world with her father and fiancé, Draco Malfoy, at her side. The young Riddle has a cold heart a heart that was moulded by her father. The Malfoy boy is the only thing that can make her heart flutter but he can also break it. Voldemort takes and takes every person that she love until she can't stand it anymore. The Future Dark Lady needs to decide wether she cares for her father or her fiancé and friends more. This is a love story between Draco Malfoy and Y/n Riddle, but it isn't all about love. This story also showcases the grief and pains that Y/n has been through as a character. And her recovery to become the person she is today. ⚠️Warning ⚠️ Contains: Smut Harsh language Violence Drugs Mentions of Suicide Mentions of rapeComplete
Dawn
Dawn Rosier/ Tom Riddle No soul beyond the Dark Lord's inner circle has ever laid eyes upon his sons. They exist as specters, whispers in the shadows, their names nothing more than echoes of something unseen. Yet, as all empires seek longevity, so does their ruler. The Dark Lord has decreed it-his bloodline will not fade into obscurity. It will endure. It will multiply. It will be bound by legacy, sealed in blood. Mattheo Riddle, the youngest, is a creature of indulgence, a man who plays with fate as if it were nothing more than a game of cards. A gambler. A wasted heir. There is no use binding him to a wife. But Tom... Tom is different. The firstborn. The one forged not in vice, but in duty. A blade honed by silence, sharpened by obedience. He does not falter. He does not waver. And now, he must wed. Not for love. Not for want. But because his father commands it. Because he must be the start to an unending stream of bloodshed and violence. It all should start with him. But the task would soon evolve into something neither he nor Dawn Rosier thought it could be. Yearning, Despair, Wrath and Crumbling. A story of sense and sensation, Past and Present as eternal enemies of every day. This is the story of Dawn Rosier. Tropes: Forced marriage Slow burn Age gap Gothic I own Dawn Rosier's character.Complete
My Dear Dark Lord
Tom, as much as he hates to admit it, wants to fit in the wizarding world. Make a name. Probably kill Dumbledore. (And wants a family *it's a secret*). Harry wanted to change the world. Rule it. Become great. (And wants someone who will love him *again a secret*) Tom is the Mudblood of Slytherin. The outcast. Hogwarts most intelligent student. The most distrusted. (And he is great) Harry is the Star Pupil of Ilvermorny. Lord Peverell. The most intelligent wizard ever known. The most trusted. (And he is great) What will happen when they crash?Complete
destruction | tom riddle
― "You are my ruin - and my salvation." ― Lilith Vale was born different - too sharp, too cold, and far too powerful for someone so young. Raised on dark magic and haunted by her father's death, she's spent her life searching for the spell that destroyed him... and nearly took her with it. Now in her final year at Hogwarts, she wears the badge of Head Girl like a mask. To the rest of the school, she's brilliant, distant, untouchable. But underneath, Lilith is spiraling - unraveling under the weight of secrets, survivor's guilt, and a hunger for knowledge that no book seems able to satisfy. Then comes him.. Tom Riddle - charming, calculated, and dangerously intelligent. He's the only one who sees her as more than a quiet storm. And the only one whose mind she can't seem to read. He wants to know what she's hiding. She wants to know why he's watching. Their connection is a game of power and proximity. A cold war wrapped in stolen glances and veiled threats. But something dark is stirring at Hogwarts - students are disappearing, ancient symbols are resurfacing, and Lilith is getting too close to the truth. To the truth about her father. To the truth about Tom. And to the truth about herself. Because some magic isn't meant to be studied. Some obsessions aren't meant to be survived. And some love stories are written only to end in destruction. ☽｡⋆Complete
Burning Obsessions : Tom Riddle
"You're very charming. Not just charming, but beautiful in the sense that the world could almost pardon you for your sins." Victoria Locke and Tom Riddle are practically strangers. Despite her objections, secrets entangle them together. Theodore Nott involves himself into her life when a spark of obsession fabricates deep desires, pulling her to Riddle and Nott. But one can't be pulled in two different directions without being torn apart. no.1 #tomriddleComplete
Y/n Malfoy's family decided to make an arranged marriage between Lord Voldemort's oldest son Tom Riddle and their daughter Y/n. Its Y/n's last year in Hogwarts and once she graduates she has to get married. Y/n has hated Tom since their first days at Hogwarts and Tom wasn't dying for her either. The things were going to get complicated but at least they were going to be safe, right? Would Y/n's anger go away over time? Would Tom be able to love her or at least have some sympathy? !! In this fanfiction Voldemort and Bellatrix are parents of Tom and Mattheo Riddle!! TW! This book includes smut, uncensored words, eating disorder, depression, suicidal thoughts, self harm, drug addiction and alcoholism.
More detailsContent Guidelines