More Than I Should... (Fp x OC)
- Reads 175,696
- Votes 4,188
- Parts 65
MatureOngoing4h 12m
Last published Tue, Apr 22, 2025
"Juggie, I'm your fucking girlfriend! Betty's my fucking sister! How could you do something like this?" I asked him throwing every ounce of betrayal I felt into the words I said. Jughead looks to the ground, obviously guilty but not enough to spare my feelings.
"I think I love her, Lyn." I couldn't believe my ears.
"You love her? You love her?! Then what the fuck was I Jughead? What were the eleven fucking months that I've been at your beck-and-call, letting you fucking sleep in my bed when it was too cold at the Drive In, comforting you when you cried, BEING FUCKING THERE FOR YOU!" I was screaming, there were tears streaming down my face, it took everything that I had to keep my knees from giving out. I had given him eleven months of my time, of my energy, and he threw it in the trash...like it was nothing...like I was nothing.
"I'm sorry Lyn, I never meant for it to happen this way."
"Then how the hell did you mean for it to happen? Did you think I'd be okay with you breaking up with me for my twin sister?!" he didn't even answer, just stood there looking at me like he didn't know what to say, "Get out, get the fuck out, don't ever fucking talk to me again." He hesitated for a moment before quickly leaving my room, I stood there quietly until I heard the front door close downstairs, and then I collapsed...
WARNING!
Major age gap! Self harm! Drinking! Smoking! Smut!
Read at your own risk!!!
All Rights Reserved
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
complicated love
you could call him her stalker, or her kidnapper, or even her soulmate, because technically he was all three. Betty was an average girl to the public eye. But really she covered herself in makeup everyday trying to get rid of her bruises and cuts from the previous night. The truth was her dad abused her. Her mother knew, but knew if the truth got out their reputation would be ruined, so she kept quiet. Betty's siblings moved out as soon as they could so she was all alone in that nightmare house. Yes she did have friends. Friends that had no idea about her life at home. Friends that betty was so insanely jealous of living a decent life. As of jughead Jones. He'd knew what was happening as well. Jughead was a business man. A very, very rich one too. Betty of course had no idea who he was or that he even existed to her lack of technology, But eventually he was going to change that. TW⚠️ -abuse -self harm -slightly mature content😏 Achievements: #2 bughead 5/13 #1 bughead 5/14!!!!!!Complete
Riverdale soulmates
"Juggy?!" I said "Bel" He said Jughead ran to her and picked her up. She hugged him tightly. We all watched. They stared at each other for a long time. "Why are they standing there so long? There can't be that much to talk about" Betty said getting annoyed "Hey, I'm Isobel" She said The girls were glaring at her. "How do you know Jug?" I said "We grew up together" She said "We told you to stay away from Archie and now you are going after Jughead" Cheryl said angrily "He's my soulmate and so is Archie. I think the rest of you are my soul mates, I came here to tell you that. I accidentally made the bond with Archie yesterday. I didn't with Betty and Veronica because I said I wanted to bond slowly not to overwhelm myself" She said "I think, I'll go home for today" She said "It was nice meeting you guys" She said and walked off (JugheadxBettyxArchiexOCxVeronicaxReggiexCherylxSwetpea)
(Jughead x Reader) The Floorboards Underneath
"I'm not homeless, and I'm not a murderer. The street is my home and I'm just a little bit homicidal." He joked. "Not everything is a joke Jughead." You replied. "That's all life is, one big joke. If it wasn't, Jason would still be alive, babies wouldn't die, and my dad wouldn't be rotting in prison for a crime he didn't commit." "He hurts you." You reminded him, staring at the deep scars that sat on his biceps. "Everyone does eventually." He said, smiling softly. ********************************************** A story in which you and Jughead connect, after you find out his dad abuses him (DON"T READ IF YOU LIKE FP)Complete
Kjmila
I am shocked. I ran over to her so quick. I slammed the door. I see all the marks. I see her crying. I slowly bring myself up to her. I use my finger and slowly and carefully tilt her head up. she hugs me tight. I can see the bloods all the way threw the jacket. I slowly take of the Hoodie. She is just wearing a bra now and my sweat pants. The sweat pants have blood from the whips. I slowly look at her, asking for permission, and she nods. I slowly bring down her sweatpants and bruises . So many bruises. I pick her up like a baby and I bring her over to my bed. I place her on her stomach and I go and get a wet towel and ice to dab her scars. I walk over to her. She's asleep. I sigh. Slowly I put the ice and towel on her back. I go and lay down opposite of her. I kiss her forehead and whisper "baby, it's gonna be ok."Complete
Broken & Unbroken || Bughead
~ DISCONTINUED ~ JUST KEEP READING THE CHAPTERS GET BETTER I SWEAR! ~ Betty Cooper: Your perfect, blonde, beautiful, smart girl-next-door. Little do you know what is hidden beneath the makeup and collared shirts and sweaters. A longing. Jughead Jones. Your emo, shady, beanie-wearing-cad from the wrong side of the tracks. But what hides beneath his walls and the drug ridden reputation of the Southside. A longing. Longing what exactly? That's what we're all asking, aren't we? Guess you'll just have to read. (This is my first story on this platform. Well, my first fanfic AND published story tbh. Hope you enjoy!)Complete
Flatline ((Jughead Jones)) 3
When he put me down, we were both a little out of breath, still happy and in love, but slowly realising what was ahead of us. Whatever events would come next, we would be ready for and we would face it together. "Yeah, we're damaged." I stated, looking down at my leg, knowing the scars lying under my clothing. "Badly damaged." Jughead replied, lifting my head up, my lips closer. "But your love's too good to lose." We stated to each other. I knew I would be with Jughead for the rest of my life. There was no one else I would rather be with and there was no one else that would come close to treating me as well as Jughead.Complete
My Light ✔️
This is a Barchie story will include fictional scenarios after the events that occurred in 5x08. I know the ending of this episode was so disappointing so I am here to try to mend broken hearts like mine. Here is the Barchie storyline that we all deserve. We've patiently waited for far too long and since the writers can't give us the content we barchies deserve, I'll try my best to give it to you all. (book written March 2021-Nov 2021) (p.s: I wrote this story right after the premiere of the 8th episode, so this story is very different from the second half of the season, since at the time I was developing this story, Riverdale was on a three month hiatus and season five did not end until October). •••••••• "Betty. I'm gonna ask you something but I don't want to make you uncomfortable" Archie told me and I nodded hesitantly. "Are your nightmares connected to the Trash Bag Killer?" He asked as I stared at him dumbfounded by his question. I did not expect this at all. "Wh-what?" I stuttered staring at him in shock. "Betty. I may not be an FBI agent but I know what PTSD looks like" He pointed and I unconsciously fisted my hands. "don't do that" He begged in a whisper while reaching for my hands to keep me from digging my nails into my skin. He scanned my hands in concerned and ran his fingertips through the palms in a gentle manner. •••• Happy readings! ♥️Complete
A New Start (Jughead Fanfiction)
"It is hard for me to be anyone else, because I don't know how to be anyone else." I say with a tired sigh. I take a bite of my burger and a drink from my shake. "Well that is me too. Archie was my only friend for a long time, then the others started to hang out with Archie and me as well. We became friends, but I am not as close to them. Then you came along, walking behind the group, shy as anyone could be. But you were there, your cheeks were pink, you had bright silver eyes underneath your glasses that framed them perfectly. And a little smile that I couldn't stop thinking about." Jughead explained. "You are an amazing person, amazing listener, you have a good taste in books and movies and interior design. And I know someone who would love to ask you on a date," I scoff. "Who? Another football player? I think I am through with them." This is my first fanfiction that I am publishing and Just so you all know, I don't have a specific schedule for when I update this, one day I might add 10 chapters, some days I might only have half of one written. It all depends on how my day to day schedule is. I hope you all enjoy it. Just so you all know, I don't have a specific schedule for when I update this, one day I might add 10 chapters, some days I might only have half of one written. It all depends on how my day to day schedule is.Complete
you could call him her stalker, or her kidnapper, or even her soulmate, because technically he was all three. Betty was an average girl to the public eye. But really she covered herself in makeup everyday trying to get rid of her bruises and cuts from the previous night. The truth was her dad abused her. Her mother knew, but knew if the truth got out their reputation would be ruined, so she kept quiet. Betty's siblings moved out as soon as they could so she was all alone in that nightmare house. Yes she did have friends. Friends that had no idea about her life at home. Friends that betty was so insanely jealous of living a decent life. As of jughead Jones. He'd knew what was happening as well. Jughead was a business man. A very, very rich one too. Betty of course had no idea who he was or that he even existed to her lack of technology, But eventually he was going to change that. TW⚠️ -abuse -self harm -slightly mature content😏 Achievements: #2 bughead 5/13 #1 bughead 5/14!!!!!!
More detailsContent Guidelines