Penny for your Thoughts : A Yellowstone inspired story
- Reads 287,780
- Votes 4,687
- Parts 109
Ongoing18h 30m
Last published Sun, Feb 1, 2026
In the rugged landscapes of Montana, the Dutton legacy endures, not just in the sprawling ranches and vast plains but in the fiery spirit of Beth Dutton and her daughter, Spencer Hope, but everyone affectionately calls her "Penny". As Beth imparts the traditions of the Dutton family to her fiercely determined and capable daughter, they navigate the challenges of life, love, and the unbreakable bond that ties them to the land. Join them on their journey as they uncover the layers of strength, vulnerability, and love that define the indomitable Dutton spirit.
In "Legacy Beneath the Big Sky," explore some untold stories as well as some storylines from the original TV series.
I do not own the Yellowstone characters, this is all inspired by the TV show Yellowstone and other Yellowstone Fanfics. The only original character is Spencer Hope "Penny"Dutton Wheeler.
All Rights Reserved
#25
ripwheeler
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
Beneath the Montana sky
In the wake of tragedy, John Dutton struggles to keep his fractured family together after the sudden death of his wife, Evelyn. His children, each dealing with their own grief, grow distant, leaving John to face the emptiness of the ranch alone. But when Lucille "Lucy" Pierce arrives, a strong-willed woman with a work ethic to rival the toughest cowboys, she begins to heal more than just the land. Over the years, Lucy becomes a steady presence, offering support to John's children, and her bond with them deepens. John's feelings for Lucy grow as well, torn between the love he still holds for Evelyn and the undeniable connection he shares with Lucy. On Lucy's 34th birthday, John brings home a troubled teenager named Rip, a boy who's lost everything and needs a place to belong. As Lucy takes Rip in, their bond as a family strengthens, but John's unspoken love for Lucy hangs in the air, unacknowledged yet ever present. In the unforgiving Montana wilderness, they find healing, love, and the courage to move forward-together.
"black bird" a Yellowstone fanfiction
she spent her whole life being told she was the reason her and her siblings grew up without a mother, therefore she grew up alone. She was much younger than the rest, the last baby always gets the short stick. her daddy had become much too busy on their ranch to focus on her. He had put all his devotion and power into his eldest children. she flew under his radar.. Behind her daddies back she may have found love, love that could soon disappoint. Although she was young, it didn't mean she was weak. she learned to grow up fast in a world that was crumbling around her.
Shadows of the Past
Beth Dutton's life has been shaped by secrets, but none greater than the one about her daughter. Years ago, she gave birth to Emily, her child with Rip Wheeler, only for her father, John Dutton, to raise the girl as his own to protect the family's reputation. Emily grew up believing she was John's youngest daughter, unaware of her true parentage. But when Jamie Dutton, bitter over his own adoption revelation, spitefully exposes the truth, it shatters the family. Rip learns he's a father, Emily questions her identity, and Beth must face her past. Can the Duttons survive this betrayal? Inspired by events of Yellowstone with my own twistComplete
Lassoed (Yellowstone)
Caroline Dutton, the youngest of the Dutton family and vying for the spot as heir to the ranching throne, has always held firm love of the Yellowstone ranch. It was her home. She would do anything to protect it. With more and more problems arising, fear of losing the ranch creeps in. She never really put much effort into anything other than the ranch. She had no desire to. Nothing else came close in importance. Until she begins spending more time with a cowboy working on the ranch. Sure, she had known Ryan vaguely but never really spoke to him. The more time the two spend together, the more their bond grows and something neither expected begins to blossom. A/N: I do not own Yellowstone or its characters, only Caroline and her plotlines. All rights go to Taylor Sheridan.
New beginnings | Yellowstone
Juliet Dutton has run out of chances. After three years behind bars, she's sent to the Yellowstone Ranch-a place where hard work is law, and weakness gets crushed beneath it. She's a Dutton by name, but her past mistakes make her an outsider in her own family's world. Life on the ranch is harsher than anything she faced in prison, and Juliet quickly learns that survival isn't just about moving cattle or fixing fences-it's about proving she belongs in a place that doesn't forgive failure. Haunted by regret, fueled by stubborn fire, and tested by the land and the people who work it, Juliet has one last chance to turn her life around. But redemption never comes easy... and out here, nothing does.
Ride Beside Me | ᴋ. ᴅᴜᴛᴛᴏɴ
She doesn't chase love. She runs with it. Aspen Hayes never needed a man to steady her hand or soften her world. Raised on dust, hard lessons, and the back of a blue-roan mare, she built a life where grit beats luck and loyalty means everything. She isn't here to be admired. She isn't here to be chosen. She's here to win - and stay free doing it. But winning in this world means more than clean runs and fast turns. It means land. Legacy. Bloodlines and boundaries. And when a quiet-jawed cowboy with eyes full of trouble steps into her arena, Aspen feels the earth shift under her boots harder than any horse ever has. He rides like he's outrunning ghosts. He looks at her like he's finally found home. And he stands between her and the one thing she's sworn to protect - control. To love him, she'd have to ride beside him. Never behind. Never second. And Aspen Hayes has never followed anyone. Some cowgirls were born to lead. Some hearts were built to run. And some love stories ride in at a full gallop - daring you to hold on. Kayce Dutton x OC _______ #1 in Yellowstone 11.07.2025 #1 in KayceDutton 11.07.2025 #1 in BethDutton 11.07.2025Complete
Yellowstone: Ashes in Her Blood
Sixteen-year-old Sawyer Lane didn't come to the Yellowstone Dutton Ranch looking for redemption - she came to survive. Scarred, stubborn, and carrying more ghosts than years, she's the daughter of a ranch hand who blames her for everything that ever went wrong. She used to ride rodeo, used to break colts, used to believe in something like freedom. But when Rip and Lloyd see past her sharp edges, and a quiet cowboy named Rowan starts pushing her buttons - and protecting her heart - Sawyer is pulled into a world of grit, loyalty, and bloodlines that don't have to be by birth. She's not here to be saved. She's here to fight her way back. Even if that means fire. Even if that means the brand. And when her past comes hunting, Sawyer doesn't run. She rides straight into it.Complete
Yellowstone: brand of the broken
She came to the Dutton Ranch carrying scars no one could see-and a few they could. This is the story of a girl who survived the worst and walked back into the fire, daring it to burn her again. Under John Dutton's roof, there are rules. Under Rip Wheeler's watch, there's order. And under Lloyd's quiet eyes, there's a chance at healing-if she can just let someone in. But ranch life doesn't stop for pain. And the only way out is through. ⚠️ Trigger Warning: This story contains themes of trauma, abuse, self-harm, and recovery. Reader discretion is strongly advised.Complete
Yellowstone: Ashes of the Wind
Fifteen-year-old Ash Dutton was born into the wilds of Montana and the complicated legacy of the Dutton family - but she's never truly felt like she belonged. A child of silence and shame, she carries the weight of being unwanted by her own parents, the forgotten daughter in a family that only sees what they want to. On the surface, she's a quiet ranch girl with wild hair, a love for horses, and a gift for barrel racing. But underneath is a fire burning - a spirit that refuses to be broken. When Ash disappears one night, the Duttons are shaken awake by the reality of their silence. Days later, she's found beaten, broken, and bloodied - barely alive. But survival is only the beginning. Through trauma, nightmares, and the slow, painful process of healing, Ash finds unexpected family in the bunkhouse boys, strength in the love of a quiet cowboy's son, and comfort in the silence of the only people who understand - Rip, Lloyd, and Beth. This is the story of a girl who was never supposed to make it - and the legacy she builds when she decides to rise anyway. Raw, emotional, and unflinchingly honest - Ashes of the Wind is a story of survival, healing, first love, and found family in the heart of Yellowstone. I don't own any of the characters from Yellowstone. I only own Sam lily Jackosn and Ash and their parent and Colton and masonComplete
Sunshine
~sequel to Darling~ There was peace in Spencer's life at last. With a wedding to be planned, a home to decorate, and a ranch to run, everything was finally beginning to fall into place. But when the world outside Bozeman closes in once again, she must face newer and stronger enemies than before. Surprises await each morning, and sleepless nights grow longer. Will enemies from the past be able to make amends and save Yellowstone? Or will the ranch crumble beneath Spencer's feet? ~follows seasons 3 through 5 of yellowstone~ best ratings: #7 loveletters #22 ocbookComplete
Yellowstone: The Silence Between Screams
Cassidy was a ghost before the Duttons found her-barely seventeen, all scars and silence, with no record of her existence before age five. She doesn't speak of where she came from. But when Rip Wheeler stumbles across her on the edge of the ranch, bleeding and half-conscious, he brings her back-against every instinct but one: protect her. What begins as a reluctant act of mercy turns into something deeper as the Duttons start unraveling the truth. Cassidy's file, pulled by Jamie, reveals a history soaked in horror-sealed hospital records, sterilization at thirteen, SA reports, forced silence by the system, and a father among her abusers. She was supposed to disappear. She didn't. Now, the Dutton Ranch becomes more than just a place to heal. It becomes a battleground for Cassidy's survival, and maybe... her redemption. But healing isn't quiet. It's angry. It's raw. And it's coming for everyone who ever hurt her. ⚠️ Trigger Warnings: This fanfiction contains graphic references to childhood sexual abuse, trafficking, rape, self-harm, forced sterilization, eating disorders, PTSD, mental health struggles, violence, and systemic failure. While not all scenes are shown in graphic detail, the themes are intense, realistic, and emotionally heavy throughout. Reader discretion is strongly advised.Complete
Yellowstone: Eight Seconds to Freedom
Sixteen-year-old Sadie Dutton, daughter of Lee Dutton, was born with rebellion in her veins. For generations, John Dutton has forbidden his family from stepping into the rodeo arena - too dangerous, too reckless, too costly. But Sadie refuses to be caged by her grandfather's rules. Trading cattle drives for bronc rides, Sadie sneaks into the PRCA circuit, determined to carve out a legacy of her own. With Lloyd as her quiet mentor, Jimmy as her unlikely ally, and Rip as her unwilling protector, Sadie's double life becomes harder to hide. Family loyalty, bruised pride, and the relentless eight-second clock collide in a story of grit, defiance, and what it really means to carry the Dutton name.Complete
Yellowstone: I'm Still Here
"They didn't even know she was gone." Emma Dutton, thirteen years old and forgotten by the world, was found in a ditch with scars on her body and fire still in her eyes. Branded. Silenced. Changed. When Lee and the ranch hands find her, the entire Dutton Ranch is thrown into something far deeper than cattle and land wars - a quiet battle for one girl's survival, healing, and revenge. As the days stretch on, Emma must learn to trust again - her grandfather John, the quiet strength of Rip, the steady hands of Lloyd, and the unlikely warmth of the bunkhouse crew. But when her abuser comes too close to the land that once made her feel safe, Emma doesn't just survive - she learns how to fight back. A gritty, emotional, and powerful Yellowstone story about trauma, healing, and what it really means to be Dutton tough.Complete
Yellowstone: Blood and Barbed Wire
When the Duttons rescue Tate from the neo-Nazi militia, they discover another child in the darkness-a six-year-old girl named Sadie. Hurt, abandoned, and carrying scars too deep for words, Sadie doesn't trust anyone. But Tate refuses to leave her behind. Brought to the Yellowstone ranch, she finds herself surrounded by a family she never knew could exist-one full of fierce love, sharp tempers, and unbreakable loyalty. As John, Kayce, Monica, Beth, and Rip each step in to protect her, Sadie must learn how to live in a world where safety is real and love doesn't hurt. But shadows don't fade easily... and the past has a way of following. A gritty, emotional Yellowstone fanfiction about healing, family, and the strength it takes to belong.Complete
Mrs. Dutton (Yellowstone) (Kayce Dutton)
You enjoy a comfortable life. Money is no issue, nor is happiness. You live on a beautiful ranch with your handsome, loving husband Kayce who would never let anything hurt you. But will his past come back to haunt you? Find out in "Mrs. Dutton". Please comment and/or vote so I know if you like it or not!Complete
Yellowstone: Ash in Her Veins
Sixteen-year-old Spencer is used to being invisible - the outcast girl with stitched-up arms, a skull-crowned black hat, and scars no one wants to talk about. After being left behind on her grandfather's neighboring ranch and blamed for the violent death of her parents, Spencer has learned to keep her head down, trust no one, and survive alone. But everything begins to shift when the Dutton crew arrives for branding season. Rip, Lloyd, Walker, and the rest of the Yellowstone ranch hands slowly unravel the walls she's built, one hard-earned moment at a time. As the truth of her past begins to surface - including a devastating betrayal by her brother - Spencer must face the pain she's buried, the fear she's lived with, and the question she's never dared to ask: What if she's worth saving after all? ⚠️ Trigger Warning: This story contains themes of childhood trauma, sexual assault, self-harm, PTSD, suicidal ideation, and emotional abuse. Reader discretion is strongly advised. The story is written with sensitivity and care, and focuses on healing, chosen family, and survival.Complete
Whiskey
What if Kayce had another child before Tate? What if he didn't know about it? See that's the thing Haley didn't want kayce her best friend to know about it the night before he left for the navy.. Haley had some ups and down living with the duttons after her parents passed in middle.... How will Kayce reacted when he find out after not seeing her for years? How will he react when finds out who helped her keep it a secret... Takes place before and after the attack on the ranchComplete
Yellowstone: The Littlest Dutton Hand
When Lloyd Pierce's five-year-old granddaughter Harper is left on the steps of the Yellowstone, he finds himself facing a world he never thought he'd know-raising a child. Bruised, wary, and nearly silent, Harper carries the weight of neglect and fear. But on the ranch, among horses and cowboys, she begins to find her voice. With Beth's sharp protection, Rip's quiet watch, and John's steady hand, Harper slowly carves out a place in a rough world. And Lloyd-an old cowboy who never thought he'd have a legacy-realizes that sometimes, family comes when you least expect it. Grit, family, loyalty, and second chances-the Yellowstone way.Complete
In the wake of tragedy, John Dutton struggles to keep his fractured family together after the sudden death of his wife, Evelyn. His children, each dealing with their own grief, grow distant, leaving John to face the emptiness of the ranch alone. But when Lucille "Lucy" Pierce arrives, a strong-willed woman with a work ethic to rival the toughest cowboys, she begins to heal more than just the land. Over the years, Lucy becomes a steady presence, offering support to John's children, and her bond with them deepens. John's feelings for Lucy grow as well, torn between the love he still holds for Evelyn and the undeniable connection he shares with Lucy. On Lucy's 34th birthday, John brings home a troubled teenager named Rip, a boy who's lost everything and needs a place to belong. As Lucy takes Rip in, their bond as a family strengthens, but John's unspoken love for Lucy hangs in the air, unacknowledged yet ever present. In the unforgiving Montana wilderness, they find healing, love, and the courage to move forward-together.
More detailsContent Guidelines