Remember me, My Dear (Possessive! Stalker! Ticci Toby X Reader)
- Reads 40,713
- Votes 987
- Parts 23
Ongoing6h 55m
Last published Sun, Jan 25, 2026
No matter where you tried to run, hide- no matter where you turned- that boy was there. From the familiar T shirts to the hoodies- to the manic grin across his face as his hatchets glared in the moon light- and the tall shadowy figure with no face loomed over you two. Reaching beckoning tendrils out to you- reaching for you- telling you to come home with it and the boy, and to join his side. Another thing about him though- was the fact that remembering who he was, hurt and felt impossible. His face and name evading you the same way you ran from him. But you grow tired, and like a rabbit running out of steam, you're eventually going to run out of energy to keep escaping him, and he- is relentless. Just like the creature that trails him- he wont give up till he has you.
(Reader has amnesia, so does Toby- but they know they know each other, somehow- and he wants you back, -lots of obsessive stalking- lots of gore- you have been warned)
All Rights Reserved
#587
creepypastaboyfriendscenarios
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
Blank Face (Ticci Toby x Reader)
My emotions are trapped inside of me. I try to express them freely. I've tried for years, but I always fail. The kids in my school call me Blank Face. They sing and mock me. They think that I don't care. They think that I am an empty vessel rather than a person, but they are wrong. I am empty only on the outside. They don't understand. They never will. ---- I've watched her walk around in the woods with her friends many times. Emptyness. That's all I see in her face. Plain. That's all I hear in her voice. At first, my intension was to kill her. But then something happened that changed everything. *Strong language* This is my first X Reader fan fiction. So I don't have any experience in this kind of thing. But it will be good to try something new. (I know that Toby twitches/ticks, I'm just too lazy to put in every twitch he makes. He ticks throughout the whole story, it's just not in writing.) Key: Y/N- your name E/C- eye color H/C- hair color F/C- favorite color F/B- favorite book ________- time skipComplete
Special girl (Creepypasta x Reader)
___ was a special girl how had the power of water and blood manipulation. Threw her friends form her childhood days she meets slender and late became a pasta. Threw all this ____ gains love and trust between the pastas. Which Creepypasta while become ____'s lover? That's your choice to find out Just a note this is my first fabric so I hope I did the characters justice. Please ignore any mistakes, I'm not very good at spelling.Complete
We Make Each Other Worse (Ticci Toby X Reader)
You had to be perfect in everything you did. It was the only way to survive, and you knew it would guarantee you a solid future. You did nothing wrong, yet you were accused of a murder you didn't commit by a grandmother who had never really cared about you. One thousand, three hundred, and seventy-two days you spent behind bars, embracing your tarnished name and reputation. When a chance for escape presented itself to you, you took it without hesitation. Who wouldn't? It led you to see the face of the boy-now man-who had shed light on your situation and showed you what life was truly meant to be. He had handed you the key to freedom, even though he didn't know it. Maybe, with him around, you would finally get the revenge you craved. (this is a work of fiction. Ticci Toby belongs to his original creator. he is not real, nor am i saying that he is. the only thing i own is the plot and any OCs. please do not re-write my work.)
Sounds So Sweet - Ticci Toby X Reader
The goggles blinding your view sends fear tickling down your spine. The mouth guard mimics a smile worth a thousand words. This threat is here to kill you. Although you want to welcome it with open arms, the one in front of you still scares you. More neck turns, although now it sounds like it's the cracking of a neck rather than swift head turns. Each click makes you push further back into the arm gripping your side.... DISCLAIMERS : -Toby is not dialogued in accordance to his ticks, but stutters and stumbling over words are mentioned! It's just a lot to put in and I want my readers to be focused on the plot rather than his Tourette's. -if you aren't comfortable with many scenarios that involve injury or sensitive thoughts or cursing, please read at your own risk. the point is for fun, and I don't want to trigger anything for my readers :( -I drew the cover :) but it was when I had my old username and i'm definitely not redrawing that LOLComplete
River of Blood (Ticci Toby x trans masc reader)
Ticci Toby x trans masc reader. They both be freaks. .. Lifeless eyes from the figure stare out into the forest surrounding the river. Head lulled to the side like a standing corpse. Vacantly staring into the abyss of darkness casted by the evergreen trees, eyes just barely able to pick out the glint of orange deep within the maze of wilderness. Gloved hands flex as they tighten their grip around the splintered handle of a dull hatchet. The popping of the joints in their neck rings out into the crisp air, as it twitches and tics every so often. The figure bathed in moonlight shifts, head held up straighter as they inhaled the clean air of the wild. They sway before taking a step down stream, breaking their gaze from the man in the woods as they follow where the river leads them. The moon is full in the sky, illuminating the tops of evergreen trees like snow. The moon grants its grace of light down onto the river, leaving those within the woods consumed by the night. .. I will try my best to accurately represent disorders and stuff like that, just bare with me lol Cross posted to my ao3, my user over there is VikCacao. This wattpad account is very old .. that's my art as the cover lol
You're A Dream ⋆ Toby Rogers X Reader ⋆ Sequel
A lot changed after the fire. You never forgot about Toby. Toby on the other hand was a different story. He moved in with a girl, and changed his life, for, what seems, the better. Will Toby be able to remember you, and his true feelings? ⋆ You're A Nightmare Part 2 ⋆ Toby Rogers X Reader
Touch; Ticci Toby X Reader
[Completed] Y/N is a 17-year-old girl who has been isolated in a Mental Institution for 3 years now, every passing hour becoming a blur. Days are long, but nights are even longer. She's trapped in her small room, in her head. There is no escape. The closest she can ever get to the outside world is by looking out the small window by her bed, the glass is too thick to break. An old notebook is her only belonging, in which she writes her thoughts in very often. It was the same routine every single day, nothing different happened. Until she saw him. A man, maybe a bit older than her, watching her through her small window. Her little dark world is opened to so many possibilities she is nearly overwhelmed. As time goes on, however, things kinda get out of hand. ➸Disclaimers inside ( i ) ➸Cover Art: Ashiva-K-I on DeviantartComplete
Ashes on My Hands: A Ticci Toby x Reader
The closer you get to the truth, the closer He gets to you. A sickness is spreading inside them. A faceless shadow won't stop hunting. And the only people they can trust are breaking apart. Pulled into a nightmare that twists memory and reality, [Name] is caught between two survivors-Tim, careful and guarded, and Toby, reckless but fiercely loyal. Both want to protect them. Both are unraveling under the weight of what follows. But Slender Man is patient. He waits. He takes. And He never lets go. (THE ART IS NOT MINE- I DO NOT OWN ANY OF THE CHARACTERS IN THIS BOOK)Complete
Childhood (Ticci Toby x Reader)
A little girl. No older than 3. Abandoned in the forest and left to die by her parents. The only thing she had was her family scrapbook and a stuffed animal. Befriended the beast called The Rake that day. She ate some poisonous berries by accident and almost died. Her new friend hollered to the being known as Slenderman. They saved her life and brought to their mansion, where she met more funny, weird, and creepy friends called "creepypastas." 13 years later, a new creepypasta comes by and they become the best of friends. His name is Toby Rogers. Otherwise known as Ticci Toby. Together, Toby helps find her find birth parents to get payback. After that, she starts developing a crush on the twitching boy. Why is this all so important to you? You are that girl.Complete
Forgotten (Toby x Reader)
Let her go. She's scared of me She wasn't ever suppose to meet me. Okay... If it makes her life better...I'll let her go. But...At the back of my head One small tiny voice whispered these words... "She needs you. You can't leave her alone" ----------- He was a monster He killed for fun. A sadistic murderer Yet every part of my body still desired him. He was a drug to me. Everytime he touched me I would want more and more. I felt like I would go insane without him. On a cold stormy night, Y/N had gotten lost in the forest. After walking around, she finally met face to face with a infamous killer Ticci Toby. They both felt a connection with each other when their eyes had met each other. Who knew this day would change both of their lives forever? #1 in Creepypasta August 3rd 2018 WARNING MATURE CONTENT IN THIS STORY Part of the Dead Creepypasta series. Each book can be read alone :) the cover of this book doesn't belong to me. I don't know the artist I just randomly googled Toby and grabbed a random photo Yes me 10/10 author B) SECOND BOOK Jesus freaking Christ. This book is going to use female pronouns for the readerComplete
My emotions are trapped inside of me. I try to express them freely. I've tried for years, but I always fail. The kids in my school call me Blank Face. They sing and mock me. They think that I don't care. They think that I am an empty vessel rather than a person, but they are wrong. I am empty only on the outside. They don't understand. They never will. ---- I've watched her walk around in the woods with her friends many times. Emptyness. That's all I see in her face. Plain. That's all I hear in her voice. At first, my intension was to kill her. But then something happened that changed everything. *Strong language* This is my first X Reader fan fiction. So I don't have any experience in this kind of thing. But it will be good to try something new. (I know that Toby twitches/ticks, I'm just too lazy to put in every twitch he makes. He ticks throughout the whole story, it's just not in writing.) Key: Y/N- your name E/C- eye color H/C- hair color F/C- favorite color F/B- favorite book ________- time skip
More detailsContent Guidelines