Cardigans and Converse // Spencer Reid
- Reads 381,776
- Votes 9,305
- Parts 102
MatureOngoing39h 13m
Last published Thu, Jul 2, 2026
Sunday Finnegan is the definition of chaotically detailed. She is powered by coffee thanks to her addiction of reading smutty books till 3am, cheerfully goofy and optimistic to a fault.
She's fresh out of Quantico and already has her first big girl job with the BAU. Of course when your mom was one of the best profilers and your dad turned out to be a serial killer, your automatically recruited.
Spencer Reid has never met anyone like Sunny. She was the epitome of enthusiastically energetic. With a serious coffee addiction. Most of all he just likes how she makes him feel like the most important person in the world. She listens to him....really listens. He's never felt truly comfortable with anyone until her.....she made him feel at home in her presences.
All Rights Reserved
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
Smart is the New Sexy
From the office window of the BAU, four seasoned agents found themselves distracted-not by a case, but by the scene unfolding just outside their building. Aaron Hotchner, JJ, Derek Morgan, and David Rossi stood side by side, silently observing as Dr. Spencer Reid-resident genius and awkward sweetheart-stood beneath the mid-morning sun talking to a woman none of them recognized. She was beautiful-striking, confident, with a radiant smile that seemed to pull Spencer in like gravity. Her skin glowed under the light, her laugh melodic, her eyes locked on Spencer like he was the only one in the world. And to their collective shock, Reid wasn't stumbling over his words or nervously adjusting his satchel. He was laughing. Openly. Warmly. He looked... happy. Just then, Penelope Garcia walked up to the pair with her usual burst of energy and color. The woman turned to her with familiarity, and the two embraced in a hug that made it very clear-this wasn't a new connection. This was someone who already belonged. When Garcia disappeared into the building, Spencer and the woman lingered. They shared a look-intimate, soft-and then a kiss. Not shy, not rushed. Just real. Moments later, Reid walked inside carrying a brown paper bag, completely unaware of the stunned expressions and raised eyebrows waiting for him upstairs. Looks like the BAU's boy genius had a secret... and it was very, very sexyComplete
Criminal Minds Rewrite: Season Six
You thought being in prison was your rock bottom and that you could only go up from there. However, someone from your past wants you to know that no matter what you do or where you go, you'll never truly be free from them. You're trying to move on and even take the next step in your relationship, but you're constantly looking over your shoulder. As you navigate different cases, you have to remind yourself that no one is out to get you and that the family you call the BAU team will always be by your side... Right?Complete
Criminal Minds Series Rewrite: Season Seven
When your entire world comes crashing down around you, you have to fight back to the surface. You might lose yourself in the process... You might even lose those you love the most. You forget who you are, and the healing process is a slow one. Meanwhile, Emily is back, but she's not fully there. She realizes that what used to be important isn't so anymore. The team faces new challenges, challenges that can only be overcome if everyone does it together, but no one, not even you, sees what's in store.Complete
✓ | 𝒔𝒑𝒆𝒂𝒌 𝒏𝒐𝒘, spencer reid
𓏲 ࣪₊♡𓂃. 𝐈𝐍 𝐖𝐇𝐈𝐂𝐇, penelope garcia's best friend, lyla fairchild, a nonverbal forensic photographer, moves from london to quantico to join the BAU, but struggles to communicate with her new team. when dr. spencer reid, a brilliant yet awkward FBI profiler, reaches out to help her feel at home, an unexpected bond forms. spencer reid x nonverbal oc trope: friends to lovers / found family published: 23rd november 2024 finished: 8th february 2025 #1 - penelopegarcia #1 - aaronhotchner #1 - emilyprentiss #1 - davidrossi #1 - derekmorgan #1 - jasongideon #1 - fbiComplete
Stars | Aaron Hotchner
"Why didn't you wait for backup?" He yelled. "I didn't want him to get away." I said, walking further into the room. "You disobeyed my direct order." He said, still yelling. "Would you have rather me let him get away?" I said, getting louder. Not quite as loud as him. "You could have been shot." He said, still yelling. He took a step closer to me. "I know." "You could have been killed." He said, softer. "I know." I said, almost a whisper. "Your insubordination could have ended in death Catherine." He yelled inches away from my face. "I know." I said, getting louder. "I don't know how you could be so careless." He said, continuing to yell. "I'm sorry." "You're sorry?" He said, yelling. He put his thumb and middle finger on the bridge of his nose. "Hotch, I-" his lips came crashing onto mine.Complete![La La Lost You [ spencer reid x reader ]](https://img.wattpad.com/cover/355379381-256-k966141.jpg)
La La Lost You [ spencer reid x reader ]
You don't believe in ghosts. To you, when a person is gone, you understand the depth of loss and the pain of longing. They're already long gone. But why is it that you're seeing one? ⚠︎ tw: story may contain depictions of violence and/or other mature themes. ______________________________ [s9 spencer reid]Complete
Trace
When David Rossi's goddaughter joins the BAU as a forensic consultant, she brings a razor-sharp mind for poisons, decomposition, and crime scene secrets-along with a black-cat streak that unsettles even seasoned profilers. But while her genius earns the team's respect, it's Spencer Reid who sees past the dark humor and eccentric habits to the survivor beneath. Between crime scenes, lectures, and Rossi's ever-watchful eye, an unexpected bond grows-equal parts intellect, banter, and the kind of vulnerability that terrifies them both. In a world where death always leaves a trace, can two broken prodigies risk finding love in the evidence? Spencer Reid x reader fanfiction
The Story of Us
What if the Spencer Reid that the team knew wasn't the real Spencer Reid? What if there was a Spencer that nobody would even imagine when they looked at him, a Spencer that only came out around one girl? Spencer Reid was a child prodigy who had been bullied his whole life, but what would you expect when you started high school at 8 and graduate at 12. When he got to Caltech he hoped that everything would be better and he had no idea how right he was. His first day of school he met her. The most beautiful girl he had ever seen. The most beautiful girl anyone had ever seen. They quickly become friends and she unlocks a side of him he never would have guessed existed. A side that scared him but exhilarated him all at once and the best part is that she's just as smart as him, maybe even smarter. Spencer can't believe his luck...until it all fell apart. 6 years later he is going on his second year of working for the BAU and had almost forgotten his old friend. Or at least he had convinced himself he had until she waltzes in as the newest member of the BAU on his 24 birthday. Now, Spencer has no idea how to handle seeing the person he had once cared about more than anything who had abandoned him. How will he react? Why did she leave? What exactly happened between the two? And the Story of Us looks a lot like a tragedy now- Taylor Swift This story will begin in Season one and will feature some plot line and cases from the show. It is a slow burn Spencer Reid fic that will be part of a series. This story also will contain some Smut so read at your own discretion.Complete
HOUSE OF CARDS | Spencer Reid
'𝘤𝘢𝘯'𝘵 𝘧𝘪𝘯𝘥 𝘺𝘰𝘶𝘳𝘴𝘦𝘭𝘧, 𝘭𝘰𝘴𝘵 𝘪𝘯 𝘺𝘰𝘶𝘳 𝘭𝘪𝘦.' Spencer prides himself on his ability to detect lies, to spot the tiniest inconsistencies in a person's story - it's the one thing he's always been able to rely on. Which is why he feels such a disdain for the BAU's newest member. Unlike the rest of the team, he isn't fooled by her veneer of normalcy. There's something off about her; a lack of warmth in her smiles, a lack of light behind her eyes... She's hiding something, he knows she is. He just needs to prove it, and her 𝗵𝗼𝘂𝘀𝗲 𝗼𝗳 𝗰𝗮𝗿𝗱𝘀 will come crashing down. [ A Spencer Reid x Reader ]
Criminal Minds Series Rewrite: Season Four
Your past comes a-knocking when you visit your family for the first time in what seems like years. Things aren't what you thought they were, but you have a hard time believing that your parents are involved in anything nefarious. Trying to juggle your personal life with your work life isn't easy, but you have an amazing team to help you through it. Will the truth come out or stay buried?Complete
From the office window of the BAU, four seasoned agents found themselves distracted-not by a case, but by the scene unfolding just outside their building. Aaron Hotchner, JJ, Derek Morgan, and David Rossi stood side by side, silently observing as Dr. Spencer Reid-resident genius and awkward sweetheart-stood beneath the mid-morning sun talking to a woman none of them recognized. She was beautiful-striking, confident, with a radiant smile that seemed to pull Spencer in like gravity. Her skin glowed under the light, her laugh melodic, her eyes locked on Spencer like he was the only one in the world. And to their collective shock, Reid wasn't stumbling over his words or nervously adjusting his satchel. He was laughing. Openly. Warmly. He looked... happy. Just then, Penelope Garcia walked up to the pair with her usual burst of energy and color. The woman turned to her with familiarity, and the two embraced in a hug that made it very clear-this wasn't a new connection. This was someone who already belonged. When Garcia disappeared into the building, Spencer and the woman lingered. They shared a look-intimate, soft-and then a kiss. Not shy, not rushed. Just real. Moments later, Reid walked inside carrying a brown paper bag, completely unaware of the stunned expressions and raised eyebrows waiting for him upstairs. Looks like the BAU's boy genius had a secret... and it was very, very sexy
More detailsContent Guidelines