Natalie is a book worm with a fierce love for cats. So when she finds a fluffy stray cat, she can't resist falling in love with it. But then Riley, the golden child of all her classes claims her cat is missing, and it's the exact cat Natalie has been taking care of. Natalie knows it's wrong, worse than wrong actually. But she can't resist keeping the cat a secret and bonding more and more with it. But now Riley and Natalie are getting closer and keeping her new stolen pet a secret is proving more difficult than it's worth. How can she maintain both a friendship and a catship without revealing her dreadful secret?