What Lies UnderNeath
  • Reads 626
  • Votes 17
  • Parts 16
  • Time 2h 57m
  • Reads 626
  • Votes 17
  • Parts 16
  • Time 2h 57m
Ongoing, First published Feb 27, 2024
Mature
○•SEQUEL TO "Secret Desire"•○



Everything isn't how it seems. 

This world is cold, full of cruel people, and the supernatural. 

Murders, Thieves, Rapist, Witches, Demons, Angels. 

Luna & Toby fall into that category. 

As do Iris & Hoodie

Added with Taylor & Masky. 

Things are fairly normal between the top trio proxies. Going on missions, succeeding without fail, then continue to live their lives within the mansion. But things become unusual the moment Toby is assigned to take down one of Zalgo's top workers, The Blue Witch- Luna. 

Unfortunately, Toby fails- miserably. 

But after encountering her once, Toby can't seem to erase her from his mind. After some time he goes to see her, try to attack her again- but fails. 

A year later, Slenderman request for Toby to try again- this time involving Masky & Hoodie. 

They still fail, and have many casualties. 

Unfortunately, all worlds are turned upside down thanks to these faithful Encounters. Better for some, but worse for others. 


"Do you believe in Red string soulmates? People that are tied together for all of eternity?" 

"No. a fate like that s-seems to sound." 

She smiles, looking at him with glowing blue eyes. "That's why you can't forget about me Toby, and that's why I can't forget you either. We're tied together, for all of eternity. I'm sorry the world decided to fate me with you.....unfortunately things are going to get worse from here." 

"what do you m-mean?" 

"You'll see. Magic has no limitations."





🔞= smut chapters. 

WARNING: this book is HIGHLY TRIGGERING! This book contains themes such as ra*e, SA, drug use, drug abuse, mental- physical- emotional- verbal abuse, gore, self harm, extreme violence. VIEWERS DISCRETION IS ADVISED!!!!!


- I do not own any pictures used in this book nor the characters(only Iris, Taylor, Luna, & Eboni)
All Rights Reserved
Sign up to add What Lies UnderNeath to your library and receive updates
or
Content Guidelines
You may also like
Camp Creepypasta {Ticci Toby x Reader} [BOOK 1] by deepinecstasy
26 parts Complete
Basically, you're 18. You were homeschooled your entire life but you were fine with that, you preferred to be alone. Your parents never cared to spend time with you and they neglected you which was part of the reason you were so used to being alone. You loved creepypastas and read them whenever your parents would neglect you. One night, when you snuck out of the house and towards the lake to go clear your mind, some girls pushed you in and you almost drowned but you were saved by who you thought was a fictional character. Then, you receive a letter, telling you about a camp that was perfect for you. You went and even made some friends, but more and more happens and everything keeps getting worse. You need to try and fix things before things spiral beyond your control, There has to be a way to stop this, right? Read the story to find out what happens! -------- « Book Status: COMPLETE » completed on 03/11/2020 This is a series of books, this book is the first thus why it says 'BOOK 1' in the title. The second book and the rest of them will be on my profile. - BOOKS OUT SO FAR: 2/7 [ also, this is a Marble Hornets and Creepypasta crossover, so expect some Marble Hornets related chapters :) ] [ cover art by Lynnarty ] (!) [TW/CW: strong language, self-harm, suicide, drugs, described gore, long mf chapters lmao] (!) All your support truly means a lot to me! -------- Rankings: hoodieandmasky - #1 ! [wOW] hoodieandmasky - #4 😔 Creepypasta - #595 ouch :,( hoodieandmasky- #3 👀 Creepypasta - #820 seriously- hoodieandmasky- #3 👁-👁 hoodieandmasky - #2 ! Toby - #148 hoodieandmasky - #326 (HOW THE FU-) Toby - #114 :D ticcitobyxreader - #5 ! proxy - #1 ! proxies - #1 !✨ creepypasta - #279 sally williams - #1 (why tho lmao she's like not mentioned once i don't think) creepypasta - #592 toby - #23 :)
Secret Desire {Jeff The Killer Story} by Princesspastel8
86 parts Complete Mature
se·cret /ˈsēkrət/ adjective not known or seen or not meant to be known or seen by others. noun something that is kept or meant to be kept unknown or unseen by others. de·sire /dəˈzī(ə)r/ noun a strong feeling of wanting to have something or wishing for something to happen. verb strongly wish for or want (something). ▪︎ ▪︎ ▪︎ ▪︎ "You know if slender finds out about you, he'll gut you like a fish." "Doesn't that make this more exciting? Besides, who's to say he doesnt already know-" "Heh, you crazy bitch." ¤ ¤ ¤ ¤ Eboni. A girl cheated out of her childhood. A girl bullied for her skin condition and scaring on her face. A girl in and out of foster care, having to face abuse that made her into the teen she is today- a very troubled and stubborn woman. Eboni, a girl who caught the attention of one of the most notorious serial killers- in one of the most unnatural of ways. 《? = nsfw chapters 《 Fair warning this story will be highly triggering to some viewers. It also may contain topics that may triggers some readers. YOU'VE BEEN WARNED!!!!!! 《 I do not own ANY of the pictures nor characters that will be used in this story, only Eboni. Most of the creepypasta's and other side characters are based on a youtuber known as 'David Near'. Be a dear and check out his channel and his takes on the creepypasta's and his version on them! #1 in maskyandhoodie - 03/06/24 #1 in creepypastaxreader - 08/16/24 #1 in #jeffthekillerfanfiction - 09/13/23 #1 in #bwwm -09/10/23 #1 in jeffthekiller -09/13/23 #1 in ticcitoby -09/13/23 #1 in jtk -09/22/23 #1 in eyelessjack -10/8/23 #1 in creepypasta -03/25/24 #5 in jeff -11/05/23 #1 in Masky -01/17/24 #6 in ninathekiller -01/04/24 #2 in bendrowned -01/19/24 #1 in eyelessjack -02/14/24
For All Of Eternity (A Sally Creepypasta Fanfiction) by ForevermoreSoul
47 parts Complete
《1st Place in Sally category - Fall Awards 2016 | Admin's Choice - CreepyPasta_Awards》 "You can't leave the horror behind; it's a part of you." Sally Williams was a young, bright girl until she met a cruel fate by the hands of a man with cruel desires. Ever since she died, the horror comes back to her, over and over again, like a reoccurring nightmare. This child, scarred by her past, is engulfed by a powerfully wicked anger and an urge that she doesn't yet understand. In her search for answers, she only comes across more questions. Crossing paths with killers doesn't seem to make her situation any easier, despite the help some of them offer. Plagued with immortality, little Sally will be met with decisions that may forever haunt her. With eternity in sight, what can a young girl do? What does she most desire, and what will it take to get it? ~*~*~*~*~Praise for For All of Eternity~*~*~*~*~ "Can't stop the tears...This is so real, that's why it hurts so much...Bittersweet and beautiful. And oh so much sorrow..." ~LokisPuppet "Thank you so much for writing this. Honestly, not a lot of stories--much less, fanfiction--give me a new perspective on the world..." ~pastel-feels "Rereading this because it's one of the few creepypasta fan fiction that doesn't give into the stereotypes. You portray each character as if they were your own, honestly. I've never seen someone get their personalities so down pat." ~Anonymous "Omg!!! Literally all I can say is oh my gosh!...this was such a beautifully written story. I can't even put into words how good it was." ~lizthecraze
You may also like
Slide 1 of 10
Camp Creepypasta {Ticci Toby x Reader} [BOOK 1] cover
Masky X Reader X Hoodie  cover
Creepypasta x Reader One shots cover
Your Insanity cover
Secret Desire {Jeff The Killer Story} cover
A Dance With The Devil (Ticci Toby X Reader) cover
Jake The Lumberjack: He Comes cover
The Devil's Demon [Ticci Toby X Reader] cover
For All Of Eternity (A Sally Creepypasta Fanfiction) cover
Truth With Light cover

Camp Creepypasta {Ticci Toby x Reader} [BOOK 1]

26 parts Complete

Basically, you're 18. You were homeschooled your entire life but you were fine with that, you preferred to be alone. Your parents never cared to spend time with you and they neglected you which was part of the reason you were so used to being alone. You loved creepypastas and read them whenever your parents would neglect you. One night, when you snuck out of the house and towards the lake to go clear your mind, some girls pushed you in and you almost drowned but you were saved by who you thought was a fictional character. Then, you receive a letter, telling you about a camp that was perfect for you. You went and even made some friends, but more and more happens and everything keeps getting worse. You need to try and fix things before things spiral beyond your control, There has to be a way to stop this, right? Read the story to find out what happens! -------- « Book Status: COMPLETE » completed on 03/11/2020 This is a series of books, this book is the first thus why it says 'BOOK 1' in the title. The second book and the rest of them will be on my profile. - BOOKS OUT SO FAR: 2/7 [ also, this is a Marble Hornets and Creepypasta crossover, so expect some Marble Hornets related chapters :) ] [ cover art by Lynnarty ] (!) [TW/CW: strong language, self-harm, suicide, drugs, described gore, long mf chapters lmao] (!) All your support truly means a lot to me! -------- Rankings: hoodieandmasky - #1 ! [wOW] hoodieandmasky - #4 😔 Creepypasta - #595 ouch :,( hoodieandmasky- #3 👀 Creepypasta - #820 seriously- hoodieandmasky- #3 👁-👁 hoodieandmasky - #2 ! Toby - #148 hoodieandmasky - #326 (HOW THE FU-) Toby - #114 :D ticcitobyxreader - #5 ! proxy - #1 ! proxies - #1 !✨ creepypasta - #279 sally williams - #1 (why tho lmao she's like not mentioned once i don't think) creepypasta - #592 toby - #23 :)