What Lies UnderNeath
  • Reads 712
  • Votes 17
  • Parts 16
  • Time 2h 57m
  • Reads 712
  • Votes 17
  • Parts 16
  • Time 2h 57m
Ongoing, First published Feb 27, 2024
Mature
○•SEQUEL TO "Secret Desire"•○



Everything isn't how it seems. 

This world is cold, full of cruel people, and the supernatural. 

Murders, Thieves, Rapist, Witches, Demons, Angels. 

Luna & Toby fall into that category. 

As do Iris & Hoodie

Added with Taylor & Masky. 

Things are fairly normal between the top trio proxies. Going on missions, succeeding without fail, then continue to live their lives within the mansion. But things become unusual the moment Toby is assigned to take down one of Zalgo's top workers, The Blue Witch- Luna. 

Unfortunately, Toby fails- miserably. 

But after encountering her once, Toby can't seem to erase her from his mind. After some time he goes to see her, try to attack her again- but fails. 

A year later, Slenderman request for Toby to try again- this time involving Masky & Hoodie. 

They still fail, and have many casualties. 

Unfortunately, all worlds are turned upside down thanks to these faithful Encounters. Better for some, but worse for others. 


"Do you believe in Red string soulmates? People that are tied together for all of eternity?" 

"No. a fate like that s-seems to sound." 

She smiles, looking at him with glowing blue eyes. "That's why you can't forget about me Toby, and that's why I can't forget you either. We're tied together, for all of eternity. I'm sorry the world decided to fate me with you.....unfortunately things are going to get worse from here." 

"what do you m-mean?" 

"You'll see. Magic has no limitations."





🔞= smut chapters. 

WARNING: this book is HIGHLY TRIGGERING! This book contains themes such as ra*e, SA, drug use, drug abuse, mental- physical- emotional- verbal abuse, gore, self harm, extreme violence. VIEWERS DISCRETION IS ADVISED!!!!!


- I do not own any pictures used in this book nor the characters(only Iris, Taylor, Luna, & Eboni)
All Rights Reserved
Sign up to add What Lies UnderNeath to your library and receive updates
or
Content Guidelines
You may also like
Our Prince (Creepypasta × Male! Reader) by SquishySmithIII
22 parts Complete Mature
All the stories are true. All of the sightings, the myths, the legends, the encounters. Deep inside the darkest forest, is a mansion full of killers who feast on the blood of the innocent and not so innocent. There really is a man with long arms and hands, whose face is as blank as death. This band of misfits truly considers themselves the last family that have left. Until they met you. Slenderman saw great potential in you when, even on your last beats of strength, managed to take down his Proxies and Jeff the Killer. Slowly, but surely, the Pastas nursed you back to health and sharpened your abilities to their maximum. This was it, you finally had a group of friends you could call family. All was good. Well, in your life, at least. The truth is, you're being hunted. By none other than the most powerful demon that could ever roam this earth, Zalgo, Lord of the Underealm. And, to your uncomfort, your father. Ever since you had fought him and fled his kingdom, he has done everything in his power to torment you into returning home. You vowed to Slenderman that you would never leave and betray the Creeps. You couldn't. After all they had done for you? But how long can your promise last? Will Zalgo manage to break you? And who will be strong enough to stay by your side? Warning: major swearing *cough cough* Jeffrey Woods *cough cough* This is also a Male!Reader × Jane the Killer story. Even though, yes, I know she's lesbian but let a guy dream (even though I'm not a guy)!
For All Of Eternity (A Sally Creepypasta Fanfiction) by ForevermoreSoul
47 parts Complete
《1st Place in Sally category - Fall Awards 2016 | Admin's Choice - CreepyPasta_Awards》 "You can't leave the horror behind; it's a part of you." Sally Williams was a young, bright girl until she met a cruel fate by the hands of a man with cruel desires. Ever since she died, the horror comes back to her, over and over again, like a reoccurring nightmare. This child, scarred by her past, is engulfed by a powerfully wicked anger and an urge that she doesn't yet understand. In her search for answers, she only comes across more questions. Crossing paths with killers doesn't seem to make her situation any easier, despite the help some of them offer. Plagued with immortality, little Sally will be met with decisions that may forever haunt her. With eternity in sight, what can a young girl do? What does she most desire, and what will it take to get it? ~*~*~*~*~Praise for For All of Eternity~*~*~*~*~ "Can't stop the tears...This is so real, that's why it hurts so much...Bittersweet and beautiful. And oh so much sorrow..." ~LokisPuppet "Thank you so much for writing this. Honestly, not a lot of stories--much less, fanfiction--give me a new perspective on the world..." ~pastel-feels "Rereading this because it's one of the few creepypasta fan fiction that doesn't give into the stereotypes. You portray each character as if they were your own, honestly. I've never seen someone get their personalities so down pat." ~Anonymous "Omg!!! Literally all I can say is oh my gosh!...this was such a beautifully written story. I can't even put into words how good it was." ~lizthecraze
You may also like
Slide 1 of 10
Our Prince (Creepypasta × Male! Reader) cover
Praying for a sinner || Ticci Toby x Reader cover
Trapped (A Ticci Toby Story) cover
Our New Addition - A CreepyPasta Fanfiction. [DISCONTINUED] cover
The Girl in the Attic | Creepypasta x Reader cover
For All Of Eternity (A Sally Creepypasta Fanfiction) cover
Masky x reader: Behind the Mask [DISCONTINUED] cover
Sounds So Sweet - Ticci Toby X Reader cover
LIGHTS OUT cover
creepypasta boyfriend series cover

Our Prince (Creepypasta × Male! Reader)

22 parts Complete Mature

All the stories are true. All of the sightings, the myths, the legends, the encounters. Deep inside the darkest forest, is a mansion full of killers who feast on the blood of the innocent and not so innocent. There really is a man with long arms and hands, whose face is as blank as death. This band of misfits truly considers themselves the last family that have left. Until they met you. Slenderman saw great potential in you when, even on your last beats of strength, managed to take down his Proxies and Jeff the Killer. Slowly, but surely, the Pastas nursed you back to health and sharpened your abilities to their maximum. This was it, you finally had a group of friends you could call family. All was good. Well, in your life, at least. The truth is, you're being hunted. By none other than the most powerful demon that could ever roam this earth, Zalgo, Lord of the Underealm. And, to your uncomfort, your father. Ever since you had fought him and fled his kingdom, he has done everything in his power to torment you into returning home. You vowed to Slenderman that you would never leave and betray the Creeps. You couldn't. After all they had done for you? But how long can your promise last? Will Zalgo manage to break you? And who will be strong enough to stay by your side? Warning: major swearing *cough cough* Jeffrey Woods *cough cough* This is also a Male!Reader × Jane the Killer story. Even though, yes, I know she's lesbian but let a guy dream (even though I'm not a guy)!