"Everything in the Dark" follows Nataleah Marina, a young woman navigating her first year at NYU after moving back from California. Reconnecting with her sister in New York, Nataleah faces personal struggles, unexpected romances, and hidden family secrets. Amidst the challenges of university life and complicated relationships, she uncovers the truth about her mother's past, all while dealing with the complicated feelings she has for this one boy who won't even look her way.