i wish you stayed (mattheo riddle x reader)
- Reads 108
- Votes 0
- Parts 4
Ongoing24m
Last published Fri, Dec 19, 2025
two lifelong bestfriends, madison diggory (reader) and mattheo riddle, both attending their 6th year at hogwarts start discovering deeper into their feelings for each another, until it all goes downhill when mattheo gets involved in a bad influenced friendgroup and completely changes him, changing everything for both of them.
This book is inspired by the films 'eternal sunshine of the spotless mind' and 'soul', i'll use some quotes from eternal sunshine but the rest is by me :)
All Rights Reserved
#33
sadfanfic
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
Riddles | Y/N x Mattheo Riddle
Y/N (female) x Mattheo Y/N has started her 4th year at Hogwarts. Despite it being her 4th year, she has made a new acquaintance, Mattheo Riddle. Against her better judgment, she finds herself drawn to this mysterious Slytherin boy. Y/N and Mattheo butt heads at first, but they can't deny their attraction to each other. They form a strange relationship, one full of struggles and secrets, some that could come between them... SMUT • 18+ (Preferably) ⚠️TRIGGER WARNING: RAPE, ATTEMPTED MURDER, SELF-HARM, PTSD ⚠️ Updates whenever I want to, sorry, but I have a life.
Sins of the Serpent *The Riddle Brothers*
Born under the shadow of madness and magic, Selena Lestrange has spent her life trying to outlive her family's name - the daughter of Bellatrix and Rudolphus, raised by the Malfoys and feared by the rest of Hogwarts. But as her fifth year begins, a new darkness arrives in the form of Mattheo Riddle, the fiery younger brother of the cold and calculation Tom Riddle, the one person who understands her best... and the one who can destroy her. Torn between loyalty, desire, and danger, Selena finds herself caught in a web of forbidden emotions and power plays where every secret bleeds, and every choice could be her undoing Because in the House of Slytherin, love isn't a fairytale - it's a weapon
Fulfillment's. (Book 2)
Dahlia must decide what to do about her prophecy after Mattheo betrays her, Something she never saw coming. Lost, confused, hurt, she must now navigate life without him. Or will she? Enemies or soul ties?Complete
𝐇𝐢𝐬 𝐋𝐢𝐭𝐭𝐥𝐞 𝐖𝐢𝐭𝐜𝐡 | 𝐌.𝐑 |
"𝑴𝒂𝒕𝒕𝒉𝒆𝒐?" "𝒀𝒆𝒔, 𝒅𝒐𝒍𝒍?" ⋆ ˚｡⋆୨୧˚˚୨୧⋆｡˚ ⋆⋆ ˚｡⋆୨୧˚˚୨୧⋆｡⋆ ˚｡⋆୨୧˚˚୨୧⋆｡˚ ⋆ A friendgroup full of witches and wizards growing old together...well excluding Angelina Martinez and Mattheo Riddle who are enemies. They despise each other to the core. Ever since year 1 these couple always argued at any given chance. But what happens when new feelings arise.... ☆Read to find out!☆ #1 groupchat {7/01/24} #1 instagram 5/06/24} #4 mattheo {18/02/24} #1 social media {09/09/25} #1 funny {17/05/25} All credits go to J.K Rowling for the characters except my ocs.Complete
All My Tomorrows (Mattheo Riddle)
"I was adored without asking for it. He was feared without trying. Everyone saw the darkness in Mattheo Riddle - except me. Everyone saw the light in me - except him." Mattheo Riddle x Own Character 🔮 Content Advisory This story contains mature themes and situations that may not be suitable for all readers, including: depictions of war and its aftermath, grief and emotional trauma, themes of family legacy and abandonment, unplanned pregnancy, childbirth, explicit sexual content, strong language, and occasional use of alcohol. Reader discretion is advised.Complete
y/n potter
your a Slytherin, you accept Draco's offer and become best of friends with him, your relationship with Harry is mostly negative (your his twin) and mattheo is slowly warming up to youComplete
Betrayal - Mattheo Riddle
"Mattheo. You've got to understand that this has gone too far. We're enemies. We always were, and nothing can change that." "Please don't say it's over," I've had relationships in the past where things never worked out, but this felt different. The forbidden love. But I felt my heart breaking. I lent in closer, giving him a soft kiss on the lips, knowing full well that would be the last time. "Goodbye, Matty." You are the younger sister of the famous Harry Potter but not that many people know about you.. Y/N is very different from all of her family members. She is very cunning and has a dark streak running through her blood. With that in mind, you come across some questionable choices along your journey, but will you choose your heart or your head.. ⚠️Warnings so far smut, smoking, drinking and death ⚠️ I have no rights to any characters No less an 800 words per chapter, so get ready for a proper in-depth story Please leave comments. I want to know what you guys are thinking. Started on the 22/02/2024 Finished on the 09/06/2024Complete
A Riddle's Love // Mattheo x Fem!Reader
Y/n starts her 6th year of witchcraft at Hogwarts and makes a new friend. Drama between her and her best friend occurs, but her new soulmate stands beside her through it all. Even when you would think they split up because of family loyalties. Nothing can break this endgame couple apart. Nothing. Will not be writing smutComplete
Falling For The Bad Boy (Mattheo Riddle)
Y/n is the girl everyone admires-charismatic and effortlessly charming-while Mattheo Riddle is the brooding heartthrob, always surrounded by admirers but equally dismissive of their attention. Their paths have crossed since first year, sparking an unending cycle of playful jabs and fierce arguments that only seem to escalate with time. When their best friends' relationship forces them into closer proximity, the lines between animosity and attraction begin to blur. Amidst misunderstandings and jealousy, both must confront their preconceived notions about each other and navigate the complexities of school drama.Complete
TORMENT
ˏˋ°•*⁀➷ TORMENT | mattheo riddle ɪɴ ᴡʜɪᴄʜ clover diggory joins hogwarts and falls in love with the wrong boy. or maybe he fell for her first. © orphicbooks, 2020 credits: yasmineamaroComplete
Y/N (female) x Mattheo Y/N has started her 4th year at Hogwarts. Despite it being her 4th year, she has made a new acquaintance, Mattheo Riddle. Against her better judgment, she finds herself drawn to this mysterious Slytherin boy. Y/N and Mattheo butt heads at first, but they can't deny their attraction to each other. They form a strange relationship, one full of struggles and secrets, some that could come between them... SMUT • 18+ (Preferably) ⚠️TRIGGER WARNING: RAPE, ATTEMPTED MURDER, SELF-HARM, PTSD ⚠️ Updates whenever I want to, sorry, but I have a life.
More detailsContent Guidelines