Choose Only One - LiterallyArticulate - Wattpad

Story cover for Choose Only One by twogayprinces

Choose Only One

Reads 354
Votes 16
Parts 3
Time 8m

Reads 354
Votes 16
Parts 3
Time 8m

blackbutler cielphantomhive fanfiction grellsutcliff phantomhive sebaciel sebastianmichealis sebbygrell sebbyxciel trancy

Hey guys! And welcome to my first fanfiction! Please no hate. I am a writer as I write in journals. I write around 181 pages in my journals so I'm excited to see what this turns out to be.
------------------------
Sebastian has been serving Ciel for a long time now but what he doesn't know that his master has feelings for him. At the same time, Grell Sutcliff is in love with Sebastian as well. This demon butler cares for them both a lot and would be lucky to have both. He is confused on what to do. Who will Sebastian pick? Remember: He can only choose one of the boys that he loves. 
Which one is he willing to lose?All Rights Reserved

blackbutler cielphantomhive fanfiction grellsutcliff phantomhive sebaciel sebastianmichealis sebbygrell sebbyxciel trancy

Table of contents

3 parts

Sign up to add Choose Only One to your library and receive updates

or

#239cielphantomhive

Content Guidelines

You may also like

Black and White; A Forbidden Love by Scarletanimeriver

This is a Sebastian x Reader story and this is taken place in all of Black Butler. Also I do not own most of the characters or some of the plot they go to there respective owners. So since that's out of the way enjoy. You are an immortal who has a set of interesting powers and a horrible past. Also you are a secret agent for the Queen who nicknamed you the Queen's Moonlight. You were escaping a really drunked man when a man in a butler outfit and a noble looking boy saves you when you really don't need it but you were injured in the shoulder and knee so you were grateful that they saved you. After that they saved you they introduced themsves as Sebastion Michaelis and Ciel Phantomhive and offered a job as a maid at the Phantomhive mansion. You accept that positioin and knew that your immortal life won't be the same again. As you start your journey in the Phantomhive estate you will have meet unexpected event and secrets will be revealed between you and the rest of the Phantomhive household, and what happens if you fall in love with a certain demon butler? If you want to find out then start reading!!!!!!!! Also if you like this book please follow me, vote on this book, or place a comment below that will help me alot. Thank you! Update/Warning (2022): This was written by my middle school self, so there are many things that my current self would like to change. However due to so many people reading this, it will remain the way it is now.

A Hell-Like Love • Sebastian Michaelis x Reader by krystallic

Would you be willing to go through Hell to get your happily ever after? --- "Sebastian, do not come any closer to me," I whispered. He ignored my plea and walked toward me slowly, like a predator stalking its prey. I leaned against the wall. "Why should I?" He said while leaning an arm against the wall above me. I turned my head away, not wanting to look Sebastian in the eye. "Because I am a monster. I manipulate and kill for survival." Sebastian put a finger on my chin and tilted my head up, forcing me to look into his crimson eyes. His lips were just centimeters away from mine. "Kitten, aren't we both?" "W-what?" It all came together in that moment. Sebastian's eyes began glowing fuchsia. --- Y/n Phantomhive is the sister of Ciel Phantomhive. After the great fire that burnt down their manor and killed their parents, she was starting to believe that he too fell victim to the flames. But all that changes when she hears rumors that Ciel is back and he was rebuilding the manor. She decides to see for herself. So when she does see that the rumors are true and Ciel is alive, she's ecstatic. But what she didn't count on was him coming back with a strange butler by the name of Sebastian Michaelis. --- #1 in Phantomhive #2 in Michaelis

The Master and His Demon (black butler yaoi) by Inactive_panda

A Black Butler fanfiction (yaoi) Ciel Phantomhive is afraid to reveal his true feelings for his butler Sebastian Michaelis, fearing that Sebastian does not love him the same way. Little does he know Sebastian has some feelings for the young master as well. How will the two handle things when it all gets a bit out of control 😉 ⚠️ warning ⚠️ Mature content including: Sexual themes Strong Language Mpreg Violence This is BoyxBoy if you don't like, then don't read.

Lovers' Fate (SebastianXCiel) by CielNikki

This is the second book in this series! The first is Old Friend, New butler. Now there will be some smut or yaoi sorry if it isn't good or anything like that. Okay, Sebastian and Ciel confessed they loved each other. But this may get a little confusing, okay well I'm putting Ciel is a demon now and demons have animal forms and then demon forms besides their human form. Any questions just comment or PM me and I will respond! There will be a couple OC's and Sebastian's siblings are Mira and Dominic but I'm leaving Dominic out of this one! Hope you enjoy , tata! Note: I don't own black butler or it's characters.

Grell's Student (A CielxReader) by CielxAloisxBooty

A new group of soon-to-be reapers entered the headquarters this morning. Each high-ranked reaper was assigned a student to teach about collecting souls. And with your luck, they stuck you will the red head known as Grell Sutcliffe . All he did was fool around and go on about this "Bassy", whoever that was. But on one faithful day you finally run into Grell's Sebastian, and his master Ciel Phantomhive. You manage to get to know Ciel little by little, and soon the two of you became good friends. You each told eachother about your past, and shared secrets that no one else knew. But will this friendship over time become something more?

Sebaciel- The Whisper by JoleneKramer

Ciel has feelings for his butler, Sebastian, who has feelings for Ciel as well. will they ever tell each other? or will their feelings stay shrouded in darkness?

Lost Precious of Mine (Black Butler Fanfic) [Demonic Editing Ongoing] by Bakamono_dearu

Ciel Phantomhive had already faced hell at a young age. His parent died. His sister disappeared. His mansion burned to ashes. He had no one and no place to return to. Facing these hell made him summon a spawn from hell itself, Sebastian Michaelis. He has two goals to fulfill; to cast his revenge for those who have wronged him and to look for his beloved younger sister either dead or alive. He firmly believes that seeing his sister alive will give him the immense happiness his life could offer. But would finding her even mean returning things the way they are? A love story that may be forbidden. Will they ever sought true love in this living hell? ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ I do not own Black Butler. Real story is slightly altered to fit the setting of this fan fiction. This book is currently undergoing major demonic editing. Editing is slow since I'm a bit busy in real life. Read the cringy chapters at your own risk.

The Story (SebastianXCiel) by 0nehell0fabutler

This smutty fanfic is all thanks to Mystichanlin from Tumblr; she's amazing at prompts, and has inspired this story. Sebastian and Ciel are trying to explain to Elizabeth about how they first met - who's version of the story is correct is up for debate. This story is more of a romance/comedy/drama, and I think you'll find it extremely enjoyable, and is SLIGHTLY different from the following prompt: "An AU in which Ciel meets Sebastian in a supermarket. Ciel was trying to reach for something on the top shelf when suddenly someone comes from behind and grabs it for him. Said male turns around and gaps at the person who helped him wanting to thank him but got tongue tied because…. DAMN THE MAN WAS TALL. So instead he keeps staring until Sebastian quirks an eyebrow and tells him to close his mouth if he doesn’t want to “eat” bugs. Ciel blushes and closes his mouth then says, “Thank God for your height- HELP! I mean help… Haha…” And Sebastian just chuckles and calls Ciel funny AND CIEL SMILES OH SO HAPPILY AND BLUSHY!" -Remember, it IS rated M for a reason. And before you ask, no. Elizabeth has nothing to do with anything - she's just sitting there and listening. She does not participate in ANYTHING. . . .

The Phantom Phantomhive | Yaoi | Sebastian x Ciel by Fujoshi_Panda

Black Butler, Sebastian x Ciel fanfic. (I don't own this manga/anime, only my own fantasies about it) -THIS BOOK IS TO BE READ FIRST BEFORE THE CAGED PHANTOMHIVE- After Hannah stole Ciel's soul and left him sinking to the bottom of the ocean he wakes up to find his life continuing as usual. Except that now he is a demon. And Sebastian is experiencing emotions for the first time in centuries. What will happen to the young Phantomhive as his feelings, his life, his world, is turned upside down?

That Butler: Caring? by Azruphel

A Sebaciel fanfiction. After Ciel is kidnapped and harmed yet again, Sebastian's attitude towards his master finally begins to change. What is this strange feeling he is beginning to experience, and what could it possibly lead to? (I do not own Black Butler nor any of the characters within it. Any and all rights are with their rightful owner, Yana Toboso.) Special thanks to @lillybarker2016 for proofreading this story and supporting me in my work. ^u^

You may also like

Slide 1 of 10

Black and White; A Forbidden Love cover

A Hell-Like Love • Sebastian Michaelis x Reader cover

The Master and His Demon (black butler yaoi) cover

Lovers' Fate (SebastianXCiel) cover

Grell's Student (A CielxReader) cover

Sebaciel- The Whisper cover

Lost Precious of Mine (Black Butler Fanfic) [Demonic Editing Ongoing] cover

The Story (SebastianXCiel) cover

The Phantom Phantomhive | Yaoi | Sebastian x Ciel cover

That Butler: Caring? cover

Black and White; A Forbidden Love

This is a Sebastian x Reader story and this is taken place in all of Black Butler. Also I do not own most of the characters or some of the plot they go to there respective owners. So since that's out of the way enjoy. You are an immortal who has a set of interesting powers and a horrible past. Also you are a secret agent for the Queen who nicknamed you the Queen's Moonlight. You were escaping a really drunked man when a man in a butler outfit and a noble looking boy saves you when you really don't need it but you were injured in the shoulder and knee so you were grateful that they saved you. After that they saved you they introduced themsves as Sebastion Michaelis and Ciel Phantomhive and offered a job as a maid at the Phantomhive mansion. You accept that positioin and knew that your immortal life won't be the same again. As you start your journey in the Phantomhive estate you will have meet unexpected event and secrets will be revealed between you and the rest of the Phantomhive household, and what happens if you fall in love with a certain demon butler? If you want to find out then start reading!!!!!!!! Also if you like this book please follow me, vote on this book, or place a comment below that will help me alot. Thank you! Update/Warning (2022): This was written by my middle school self, so there are many things that my current self would like to change. However due to so many people reading this, it will remain the way it is now.