The Lost Girl (ouat Peter Pan x Reader)
Myfroststory
  • Reads 354,405
  • Votes 8,937
  • Parts 32
  • Time 2h 0m
  • Reads 354,405
  • Votes 8,937
  • Parts 32
  • Time 2h 0m
Myfroststory
Complete, First published Apr 03, 2015
fanfictionouatpeterpanromancetexttospeechxreader
After spending most of your life in foster and your brother leaving you, you start to lose all hope. Until one night a shadow appears at your window and takes you to Neverland where you meet Peter Pan. While at Neverland you discover your own secrets and find something new that you had never experienced. See how Peter was turned into the monster he is today. Discover who really made others "protect" magic. 
The real question is: do villains get happy endings?
All Rights Reserved
fanfictionouatpeterpanromancetexttospeechxreader
Table of contents

32 parts

Sign up to add The Lost Girl (ouat Peter Pan x Reader) to your library and receive updates
or
#164ouat
Content Guidelines
You may also like
Peter Pan x Reader by xDarkness28x
50 parts Complete Mature
Leaving your cruel world and live with Peter Pan in NeverLand and no matter how stubborn he is you end up falling in love with him. You also go though tough times with him but you both will always be together, even through the adventures you have together. Let me know if you do like it I'll think of making more Warning- a little bit of Smut
OUAT: Never Happy, Ever After - Peter Pan and Wendy Darling by BlueSilhouette
14 parts Complete
The sixteen year old Wendy Darling lives a decent life in London with her parents and her two little brothers. Everything seems to be normal, but in the night the Darling children are visited by a mysterious shadow that takes Wendy to a magical island - Neverland. There she meets the Lost Boys and Peter Pan: a boy who never wants to grow up. In the mornings she arrives back home as if none of this happened. Only when the Darling's welcome the orphan boy Baelfire to live in the children's room, he and Wendy can figure out why the shadow keeps coming back: He wants one of Wendy's little brothers. The Peter Pan and Wendy Darling story from Once Upon A Time retold from Wendy's perspective. The context is changed a bit. Are Peter and Wendy going to have their well deserved happy ending?
Romance with the Devil (Peter Pan x Reader OUAT) by missmawii
11 parts Complete Mature
You're just a girl living in Storybrooke. Your best friend is Henry Mills. He tells you how everyone in town is from a fairytale and you're the only one who believe's him. One day the curse is broken and suddenly you get taken away by a shadow! Find out what happens when YOU'RE in Neverland. READ THIS: Hey guys! So I legit made this story when I was 12 and OBSESSED with OUAT, so I am so sorry for the terrible grammar I had. I originally published this on quotev but decided to move this story on here. I hope you guys still enjoy the cheesy plot & characters! :)
A New Beginning by DiamondAura
23 parts Complete
(Book 4 - Peter Pan x Reader) On a quest in the underworld to save her brother (Y\N) found herself in a situation in selling her life in order to save her brother or maybe not. However on the other side of the world Peter waits for his love to return.... ~~~2017-2022~~~
gladers in neverland by gladersinneverland
26 parts Complete
"the saddest thing about betrayal is that it never comes from your enemies. it comes from your friends and loved ones" ----------------------------- Rose had been in the maze for over a year. She was once very happy there until a certain British boy made her life a living hell and turned everyone against her. One day she decided to fight back but there were consequences. Because most of the glade hated her they decided to banish her. When she was about to be killed by a griever, a shadow came and rescued her by taking her to neverland. She had been in neverland for a year now. She has become stronger, faster and powerful and has made many new friends who she calls family. But thats about to change as some people she despises come to neverland. This is roses story!
The Dea → Peter Pan ✔ by abouttoexpplode
10 parts Complete
In which a boy who thinks he controls everything meets the girl who actually does. --- Peter Pan is king of Neverland, a mystical island of his own creation. His Lost Boys serve as his troops and have been his only company for the last millennium. Until his shadow brought a girl to Neverland, by the name of Wendy Darling. But she's not the one this story's about. Why? It's simple. Because she's dead. She broke Peter's heart, so he killed her. Only he and the Lost Boys know what happened the night Wendy disappeared, and Peter means to take the secret to his grave, assuming he ever dies, of course. If the Lost Boys know what's good for them, they will too. None of the other creatures on the island have any idea of what became of the one girl who had ever set foot on Neverland. However, what at first seems to be a siren with a know-it-all attitude threatens to change all that. She knows exactly why Peter's heart is shattered. But what she wants to do with that information is, for the very first time, is absolutely unclear to Peter. That doesn't sit well with the Ruler of Neverland. And whatever doesn't sit well with Peter, he either figures it out or kills it. The problem is, he can't seem to manage to do the first option, and for some reason, can't bring himself to do the second. --- Dea: Goddess [Latin]
Peter Pans Kidnapped Love (Book #1 Completed) by DarkDragonRider
21 parts Complete Mature
"No! Please Peter don't do this!" I cried as I continue to try to free myself from the ropes that are tied to the bed pole. "I can't hold it anymore Rose. I love you so much and I want to show you that love." He said as he continued to take off his clothes. Rose was a normal girl with a happy life. That was until one night when she was walking home and she caught the eyes of the one and only Peter Pan who was collecting boys from her town to take back to Neverland. But instead he kidnaps Rose. And he's never going to let her go. Because she is his kidnapped love. (This is my very first book to write, I really hope you enjoy it????) ⚠Mature and sexual contact (Book series Written and completed in 2016-)
Eye of the Tiger | Peter Pan x OC by Kaseyo11
20 parts Complete
(OUAT Universe) When Henry's family had deduced that it was Neverland he had been taken to, Lily volunteered herself to come and save him. She volunteered to go back to Neverland even though she swore she never would. Even though she swore she would never see Pan again. But now she's back and all aspects of her past keep catching up with her as she tries to save the sweet boy she used to babysit. Pan is messing with her mind and she doesn't know which way is up. Will she and the Charming gang be able to save Henry? Or will she get caught in another of Pan's games? (Definitely a darker romance ie: manipulation, etc. but nothing too graphic)
𝐓𝐡𝐞 𝐆𝐮𝐚𝐫𝐝𝐢𝐚𝐧 𝐎𝐟 𝐓𝐡𝐞 𝐄𝐥𝐞𝐦𝐞𝐧𝐭𝐬 || peter p. ouat fanfiction by A-Dreamer-2
23 parts Complete
"Do you really think you're more powerful than me?" "I am Peter Pan! You are not powerful." "Oh, believe me, you don't know what I'm capable of!" One person will arrive in Neverland and that same person will be able to change the rules of the game. But what happens when this person falls under the spell of the master of the island? "Admit that you feel something for me!" "I haven't loved anyone in years, I'll never fall in love with you, Peter." "I think the opposite." What both of you don't know is that a much bigger threat is coming. Fanfiction from the series Once Upon A Time. //! // The characters in the series do not belong to me, only the main character and some characters belong to me. //!//
|| Youth Is Yours || Peter Pan by KlunkyRinny
32 parts Complete
[Peter Pan x Reader] "Cold hands, warm heart." His son in exchange of Youth. That was the original story. But what if...It was changed? Wonder what will happen if, "My son in return of you" -He said, holding his son tight in his grasp. The shadow laughed. Laughed. Was it a joke? If only the shadow had a living figure, would it be better? Would it be better if the shadow was a beautiful woman? "No can do, kid. I'm off limits-" It laughed, holding on to his son who was squirming and calling for help. "-But I'll give you a chance." He smirked in return as the shadow granted him eternal youth with a chance to Fall for her.
Peter Pan's Wife by gogglesistaken
22 parts Complete Mature
Peter Pan Ouat fan fiction. THIS IS VERY OLD, MY WRITING SUCKED. BE WARNED. - "Why do you look at me like I see you as the villain in this story?" - A young 17 year old girl got caught in the waves of Neverland and later fell in love with the lost boys leader Peter Pan, they got married 2 years later but what felt like months to them was longer then they thought and the evil queen had a plan to put a curse over the enchanted forest. But rumplestiltskin also had a cruel plan against his father. He took his wife and now she was trapped in the curse. She forgot every last memory of the man she loved until.. the curse broke. She remembered him but she never left Storybrooke, fear always boiled inside her when she thought one day..he might come back. This is the story of Peter Pan's Wife, Alexis Pan. She mostly goes by Alex though, (If you listened to majority of Melanie Martinez's songs. It would explain this well) - Btw Pan was never Malcom but was the father of Rumplestiltskin just Pan didn't look like Malcom because a lot of reasons ty. - TW, Mature. - Imagine being told you're love for someone isn't true, because others saw that person as a villain when you didn't. - 14K READS?! THATS INSANE TY!
His Impossible Lost Girl [ Peter Pan X Reader ] B2 by girl8890
18 parts Complete Mature
Book #2 of the From The Beginning, Series There will be smut, action, violence, adventure, fluff, mystery, and romance. I picked the genre of this book as romance because it's mainly about Peter Pan X Reader content. It's a what if there was another character (you) in the series. I pulled a lot of the plot from OUAT to create this book, but because there's another character (you) a lot has changed like the overall plot and relationships between some characters. This is not a One Shot/Images book, it will have a storyline. It's going right off from where I ended the first book, From The Beginning. I have fully re-edited this book to make it better for you guys. If you see any mistakes, please comment on it respectfully. Always think positively and be positive in the comment section. Enjoy! Y/n-your name Y/e/c- your eye color Y/h/c- your hair color MATURE CONTENT IN SOME CHAPTERS! •Read first part listed as, 'Disclaimer' for more info on mature content.
Innocence (OUAT/Peter Pan) by kay_writes_dragons
51 parts Complete
A girl doomed before her own birth to be violently wanted by every person in her entire world, and then imprisoned for her entire life starting at age 5, of course wants nothing more than to escape. His Shadow is called to her, and takes her to Neverland, where she gets her freedom. And when you give an evil boy an innocent girl, opposites attract. I love the TV series, but I think Peter Pan should get to love somebody, so here's who and here's how they fell in love, as I believe it should go. Sorry for the bad summary, I promise the story is better! *Rating cautious, may change for some chapters TBA **I do not own the Once Upon a Time TV series, nor do I own their characters. I do own this story, and my main female character. ***Copyright***
Peter Pan X Reader // OUAT by Leecat0_0
11 parts Ongoing
"Your brother and his heart belong to me. If you want to see him again, you'll belong to me aswell." I glared at him in anger. That boy was a demon. Obviously demons could be beautiful and with the most comforting voice to be ever heard. Even if that didn't change anything. "Fine. But only if you stop staring at me like I'm a hunter's prey." I demanded, making him chuckle. "Well you are my prey now." <3 You adoptive brother, Henry, got kidnapped. As you try to rescue him on your own, ignoring the commands from your family, you get caught by the one and only Peter Pan. In order to see Henry again, you make an agreement with him. One that turned out to cause a lot more trouble than you thought. Most likely, with your heart.
Lost Boy, Stolen Memories by quixotic-rubbish
31 parts Complete Mature
Peter Pan wakes up in the real world without his memories, magic, or lost boys. He meets a girl that he falls in love with, oblivious to who he really is. What will happen to her if he get's his memories back? Will the monster unleashed scare away their love, or will it grow? Basically the only characters I own are Erin, her family, and friends. The rest belong to the lovely writers of Once Upon a Time.
The Same Two Kinds (Peter Pan OUAT Fanfiction) *Completed* by loverunning19
31 parts Complete
When Maxine, the Evil Queens daughter, turns 18 all she wants to do is get away from the enchanted forest, but what happens when Peter Pan's shadow comes to take her to Neverland Peter was told that this new Lost Boy would bring him great victory, but when he finds out that this Lost Boy is actually a Lost Girl he is confused and angry. When these two worlds collide their lives will change forever, but they aren't completely sure that it's either a good thing or a bad one. What happens when they both think that they could be in love. Could Peter Pan actually have a heart? Could Max ever feel cared about?
Lost & Alone by dreamshadexx
39 parts Complete
Abigail is a lonely girl who lived in a small town called Storybrooke. She was living among the most famous and infamous fairy tale characters that ever lived. Abigail however was a human adopted by her fairy tale family to live in Storybrooke forever. She had no friends, was constantly teased for not having magic, and was almost 18 years old. One day she finally had enough of the verbal abuse she received and decided to run away. She wakes up in a strange land surrounded by teenage boys with one in particular who takes an unwanted interest in her. His name was Peter Pan. The most gruesome villain in the land. Abigail believes that there is good in Peter Pan but when she can't leave Neverland until she admits to herself who she really is. Peter Pan and Abigail spend time together both good with some laughs and bad with a lot of screaming and tears while she attempts to get off of the island without any help from Peter or the lost boys. Will Abigail make it off the island? Will Peter give up his villain ways to be with Abigail? Does Abigail stay in Neverland forever and not age? Or does she take Peter and the lost boys back to Storybrooke with her? Only I know the ending and if you want to also give this book a read and vote!! *All these questions will be answered throughout the book....this will be a slowly updated book because I have classes*
Militant (Sequel to Warrior) by wintergirl08
52 parts Complete
I guess you can say that I am unlucky. At least that is what I call myself. The one guy I ever liked has me friend zoned, my family thinks that I am somehow mentally challenged and I have the unlucky spot to be placed into a military family where everyone can do amazing things except for me. I wish I could say that is the worst, but if I did I would be lying. To add the cherry ontop, I also happen to end up returning to the one place my mother had always tried to hide me from. Neverland. Not only will I be placed in an evil fairytales prison island, but I will also be at the mercy of the boy who hates my mother so much that when she came here, he tried to kill her. What happens when Peter Pan, the most powerful and evil fairytale character in Once Upon a Time history, finds out that he has another version of Alex on his island?
The Untold Past of Pan by weasleypan5
14 parts Complete
A very long time ago, you fell in love with a boy named Malcolm, and he blessed you with a son. Only problem? You're Hecate, goddess of magic, and you were forced to abandon them to complete your godly duties. But now, years later, Pan has captured your great-grandson Henry and is holding him captive on Neverland, a place you created. But will your resurfacing love for Pan prevent you from doing what needs to be done? Killing him? *I do not own any of the characters in this story* **Not entirely accurate to the plot of OUAT** ***Thank you Robbie Kay for being hot*** ****Small smut warning****
Falling In (Peter Pan FanFic) by vanillarabella
33 parts Complete
COMPLETED (Note: this story is based on the show Once Upon a Time. I will be changing a few thing, also there may be spoilers. :)) I'm sure a lot of you know the story of Peter Pan. Most of you have heard of multiple different stories, movies, TV shows. But what if I told you that those were just rumors of what really happened? My name is Bailey Parker. Peter and I have been friends for as long as I can remember. When I was 14, a new law came out, saying all women had to be married to their parent's choice of a suitor. I had no parents, Peter's were drunk when they had him, so he was abandoned. Since I had no suitor, the law said that I would have to either be sent off to some other town for a suitor, or, if I was, and I quote, "lucky enough," I could marry the prince. After 3 years of pretending to be a couple, someone figures out that Peter and I aren't a thing. Peter starts hiding secrets from me, then, once I'm in danger, he disappears. Find out what happens as Peter goes to Neverland, becomes Pan, and much more. Falling In
You may also like
Slide 1 of 20
Peter Pan x Reader cover
OUAT: Never Happy, Ever After - Peter Pan and Wendy Darling cover
Romance with the Devil (Peter Pan x Reader OUAT) cover
A New Beginning cover
gladers in neverland cover
The Dea → Peter Pan ✔ cover
Peter Pans Kidnapped Love (Book #1 Completed) cover
Eye of the Tiger | Peter Pan x OC cover
𝐓𝐡𝐞 𝐆𝐮𝐚𝐫𝐝𝐢𝐚𝐧 𝐎𝐟 𝐓𝐡𝐞 𝐄𝐥𝐞𝐦𝐞𝐧𝐭𝐬 || peter p. ouat fanfiction cover
|| Youth Is Yours || Peter Pan cover
Peter Pan's Wife cover
His Impossible Lost Girl [ Peter Pan X Reader ] B2 cover
Innocence (OUAT/Peter Pan) cover
Peter Pan X Reader // OUAT cover
Lost Boy, Stolen Memories cover
The Same Two Kinds (Peter Pan OUAT Fanfiction) *Completed* cover
Lost & Alone cover
Militant (Sequel to Warrior) cover
The Untold Past of Pan cover
Falling In (Peter Pan FanFic) cover

Peter Pan x Reader

50 parts Complete Mature

Leaving your cruel world and live with Peter Pan in NeverLand and no matter how stubborn he is you end up falling in love with him. You also go though tough times with him but you both will always be together, even through the adventures you have together. Let me know if you do like it I'll think of making more Warning- a little bit of Smut

More details