Fatima, now an advocate for foster care and criminal justice in NYC, returns to her small hometown nearly 15 years after her parents' tragic deaths, still seeking the closure that has eluded her since her early adulthood. As she revisits old memories, fragments of that fateful night begin to resurface-she was the sole witness to their murder, but at the time, she couldn't recall any details. Now, the truth slowly comes to light. Just as she and her fiancé are preparing for their upcoming wedding, her ex-high school sweetheart reappears, complicating her life further. As Fatima uncovers who killed her parents and why, she realizes the killer is someone she never would have suspected. And the motive behind it is even more shocking.