the Missing Piece (Jemily x Reader) - _healingmyself_ - Wattpad

Story cover for the Missing Piece (Jemily x Reader) by _healingmyself_

the Missing Piece (Jemily x Reader)

_healingmyself_

Reads 55,420
Votes 1,516
Parts 27
Time 5h 50m

Reads 55,420
Votes 1,516
Parts 27
Time 5h 50m

_healingmyself_

Mature

Jemily x Reader Story

Emily Prentiss and Jennifer Jareau have been dating for a year. After working together for years, one night after a difficult case finally brought the two women together.
Now they live in an apartment together and try to make friends with the nice couple next door.
The shy Y/N in particular caught the attention of the two FBI agents. 
They would like to know more about the Woman next door. 
Why is she always so quiet and almost seems scared? 
Why is it so rare to see her without her girlfriend? 
Why is she so secretive when it comes to her private life?

Can they lure the shy woman out of her shell?
And what will come of it, friendship or something more?
And why does Emily have such a strange gut feeling about the girlfriend?


I'm writing this story from the first person perspective. I use the pronouns she/her for Y/N, if you would like something different, let me know.

English is not my first language, so please be gracious.

This story covers typical case-based topics such as murder (not clearly described), domestic abuse, violence. Also mental health problems such as depression, anxiety, eating disorders, self-harm and suicide attempt/thoughts. 
Please don't read this story if it triggers you.  
If you want to know exactly what TW each chapter has, feel free to message me.

There will be Smut, smut- chapters will be marked with a (*) in the title.

I don't own any of the characters!

Have fun and let me know what you think🫶All Rights Reserved

Table of contents

27 parts

Sign up to add the Missing Piece (Jemily x Reader) to your library and receive updates

or

Content Guidelines

You may also like

Jemily - Inferno Hearts by fluffymcdragon

Criminal Minds Fanfiction Jemily JJ and Emily live next to each other, they work alongside each other. What happens when Emily is forced to leave to ensure her daughter's safety, but things go south and the wrong person can get hurt? Or when JJ gets abducted by an unsub, and has very serious things to deal with after the fact? Side Note: For some reason some of my chapters aren't in the correct order. I have tried to fix it but the app on the phone and the website on my computer won't let. So chapters 29, 30, and 31 might be mixed up. Because of the fact that I can't figure out how to fix it I'm just hoping that you guys can fix it up on your end while you're reading, the numbers are in my chapter titles so you can just make sure you're reading them in the right order. Thx, hope you enjoy the story!!

falling for you | emily prentiss x reader by ssaprentisswife

y/n starts to fall for her coworker emily prentiss but she knows she could never feel the same way so she made a promise to herself to keep her feelings hidden at all costs. this description is shitty but you'll just have to read the book to find out I guess 😽 (This book is kids free) ❗️I do not own any of these characters and TW's will be included if necessary and smut will be included ❗️ [ please check out my new one-shot book about Emily that I'm currently writing on the side of this one:) ]

Mean Something (Jemily) by UntoldLGBTstories

"JJ this isn't forever, I promise I'll be back." JJ nodded letting off a small sniffle "I know Em, it just sucks." I reached over and grabbed her hand "Listen, not even oceans can keep us apart. If you need me- I'm back. Just say the word and I'll be here before you know it blackbird." -- Authors Notes: There will be mentions of mental health, self harm, infidelity, death, and overall some situations that may make certain readers uncomfortable, so please tread with caution. Your health is much more important than a view on my chapter. I'll put warnings on more intense chapters, but know some issues may be mentioned casually throughout the story. I also tried to write this as if we were witnessing JJ and Emily's relationship grow on the show, I wanted it to be realistic so sorry in advance if It's long, I'll update as much as possible. If you're enjoying the story please leave a like or a comment, it's my first time ever publishing my work and any feed back is greatly appreciated.

Everything Happens for a Reason - Jemily by agentcjprentiss

ANNOUNCEMENT: I wrote this in middle school. It is bad, and I know that. I am so sorry to those of you that read it (I can't even bare to read it myself) 😭. If you do read it, I hope the cringe is...entertaining? It is not technically "complete" and I have no intention of ever rounding the story out, for that I am sorry. Thank you (as of June 2025)! JJ and Emily have always had their secrets, and even though they are best friends, they have some from each other. When they are called to New Orleans to assist with a series of hate crimes, JJ has to face the detective who will never stop hitting on her. In an effort to deflect him, she had to pretend to love someone else, and that person was Emily. After Hotch orders Emily and JJ to go undercover to help catch the unsub, they both start to wonder if their pretend actions were more than pretend, and if their relationship is more that just a friendship. disclaimer: most of this is from criminal minds; including characters, some quotes, and some elements of plot, cases, & setting

Behind the Mask | Emily Prentiss x Reader [18+] by prentissmultiverse

In the world of Washington D.C.'s elite, masks hide more than just faces. At a high-profile masquerade ball, you find yourself captivated by a mysterious woman whose charm and allure are impossible to ignore. As the night unfolds, her flirtatious gaze becomes an invitation you can't refuse. But when the masks come off, the real surprise awaits. The woman you shared an unforgettable night with is none other than Emily Prentiss, the Section Chief of the FBI's Behavioral Analysis Unit. And as fate would have it, your dream internship at the BAU places you right under her watchful eye. This story is a slow-burn romance filled with tension and the intoxicating mix of professional ambition and forbidden desire. ⚠️ chapters containing smut are marked with * 🔔 regular updates! Genre: Romance, Mystery, Drama, Crime Themes: Identity, Attraction, Power Dynamics, Self-Discovery, LGBTQ+ Pairing: Emily Prentiss x female Reader general tw: age gap relationship, smut, violance, murder, blood...all the typical criminal minds stuff

always been mine - emily prentiss x reader by salemxminds

In which you are madly in love with SSA Emily Prentiss, and she with you. guys i promise the story is actually better than this description i'm sorry for that lmfao i just dk how to write synopses (cisfem reader, uses she/her pronouns) BLANKET TW: mentions of sexual assault, childhood traumas, religious issues; criminal minds case-type material (violence, murders, etc., stuff you'd see as the case in an episode); smut chapters with smut marked with an asterisk in front ex.: "*chapter five // shower" as opposed to "chapter thirty // stonebrook" date started: march 23, 2021 date completed: june 12, 2021

Crush by whore4prentiss

Emily has spent her entire life moving from country to country. No friends, no personal life, and not a care in the world. Her days are spent hotboxing the bathroom and disappointing her mother. The only thing keeping her on the somewhat "straight" and narrow is her crush. JJ is George Washington High's IT girl. Captain of the girl's soccer team, jock boyfriend, and straight A's. Both girls are well known throughout their school. One for being the hot, new girl, the other for being a perfect princess. What does highschool hold for Jemily? This story follows Emily Prentiss (who no one knows much about other than rumors spread by classmates) and Jennifer (JJ) Jareau (the cute, cool girl with who everyone wants to be friends) as they find their way through high school and adolescence. That makes it sound serious... it's not... it's just Jemily in high school. This is a continuation of 'Meet Me in the Bathroom', a chapter from my 'Jemily One Shots', so if you haven't read that yet you should. Both are written like Emily is telling a story. It will include smut (but I don't get graphic), cursing, and will not be a super continuous story (more broken up but still connected).

Catch me Blackbird (Jemily) by SSABlackbird

These two loved each other with every ounce of their being and all they wanted was to be together. But... neither one of them knew so they continued working together not knowing whether the other girl loved them or not. After leaving for the last time, Emily goes to live where she once hid, Paris. But she did it to save herself from falling even deeper in love with JJ because if she didn't , she wouldn't be able to control her feelings anymore. JJ had loved Emily from the first time they locked eyes after the Tobias Hankel case. But she kept it a secret forever until it was too late. But maybe in another life they would find each other again and finally tell each other how they felt. Maybe another life, maybe another town, just... maybe. *completed*

My Protector [Jennifer Jareau x Reader] by greys_cm_addict13

Y/N has been with the BAU for two years and has always had a secret crush on JJ. Who knew that the feeling was mutual. Jennifer Jareau x female reader I do not own the rights to the Criminal Minds characters But the rest of the story line is my own. If I use dialogue or story lines from the show I will credit it at the bottom of the chapter. Best Ranks #1 jjxreader 1/24/23 #1 ajcook 5/26/23 #1 ellegreenaway 2/11/23 #2 jemily 4/15/23 #3 jenniferjareau 5/14/23 #10 emilyprentiss 3/8/23

The Moment I met you by iluvmilfs05

When Emily Prentiss's mother Elizabeth announce that she's getting married again, 15 years after her divorce from Emily's father, no one is happier than Emily. When she meets the daughter of her mother's fiance, Jennifer Jareau, there's an instant attraction from Emily's side but Jennifer is engaged to Nathan. As the two women slowly get to know each other they gradually grow closer and eventually it develops into something more. Something that's stronger than either of them but it also causes a complete chaos. How will they handle their strong feelings for each other when there's so much at stake and other people is involved?

You may also like

Slide 1 of 10

Jemily - Inferno Hearts cover

falling for you | emily prentiss x reader cover

Mean Something (Jemily) cover

Everything Happens for a Reason - Jemily cover

Behind the Mask | Emily Prentiss x Reader [18+] cover

always been mine - emily prentiss x reader cover

Catch me Blackbird (Jemily) cover

My Protector [Jennifer Jareau x Reader] cover

The Moment I met you cover

Jemily - Inferno Hearts

Criminal Minds Fanfiction Jemily JJ and Emily live next to each other, they work alongside each other. What happens when Emily is forced to leave to ensure her daughter's safety, but things go south and the wrong person can get hurt? Or when JJ gets abducted by an unsub, and has very serious things to deal with after the fact? Side Note: For some reason some of my chapters aren't in the correct order. I have tried to fix it but the app on the phone and the website on my computer won't let. So chapters 29, 30, and 31 might be mixed up. Because of the fact that I can't figure out how to fix it I'm just hoping that you guys can fix it up on your end while you're reading, the numbers are in my chapter titles so you can just make sure you're reading them in the right order. Thx, hope you enjoy the story!!