That Night

James has never been right in his head. In fact, he's even a quite bit insane.
Nikki is quiet. She's shy, a perfect role model, and only lets loose for her two best friends.
Taylor is a jock. He's loud, outgoing, and doesn't care what anybody thinks of him.

But these three opposites have been best friends ever since they can remember.

Both Taylor and James are in love with Nikki, but of course being a cliche she has no idea.

On a spontaneous camping trip one night, Taylor spills his feelings. But what they don't know was that James was watching, and he snaps. He takes out a knife and carves a J on Nikki's hand, and says to both that if they didn't participate in his certain, dangerous game, then he will kill them both.

If James wins: Nikki and Taylor die.
If Taylor and Nikki win: They will be forced to kill James...