The Heart Wants What it Wants - Penelope Grey - Wattpad

The Heart Wants What it Wants

Reads 8,867
Votes 313
Parts 22
Time 2h 35m

Reads 8,867
Votes 313
Parts 22
Time 2h 35m

Mature

bdsm damian damianpriest dominik dominikmysterio fanfic heart kink mysterio original originalcharacter polyamory priest rhea rhearipley ripley wwe wwelove

A new makeup artist and she starts at Wrestlemania 40.

Chelsea Thomas is WWE's newest makeup artist after one of the other artists left for a more remote job and to raise their family. What does she do to catch the eyes of  3/4's Judgment Day..?

Read to find out
TJD x OC

On hiatus as i'm not really sure where to go with any of this...

Co-Written With @MoshrOfJustice & LucyBloodyRipley.

Couldn't have the courage to do this with out them! &lt;3

Most rights to Ms.Jane!! I adopted Beyond the Ring and was told to make it my own. I hope it does enough justice to those who really wanted it to be continued.

@HJaneRipley original plot but tweaked for my own writing style.All Rights Reserved

bdsm damian damianpriest dominik dominikmysterio fanfic heart kink mysterio original originalcharacter polyamory priest rhea rhearipley ripley wwe wwelove

22 parts

Sign up to add The Heart Wants What it Wants to your library and receive updates

or

Content Guidelines

You may also like

Rainy Day | Rhea Ripley by ilovewhenwomen_

Alex is caught in a spiral of trying to work as a videographer for the judgment day with a less than cooperative Rhea Ripley as her boss and trying to keep a secret from everyone. How long will it take until everything comes crashing down on her? #1 on rhearipley | January 2025

Absolute Smokeshow by SpinShows

You meet the famous Rhea Ripley over a joint and she confides in you about her relationship issues. What starts as one night getting baked together turns into a series of stoner adventures as the two of you grow closer. First through seventh section originally posted to my tumblr.

Riptide | Rhea Ripley | Enemies to Lovers | Possessive and Spicy by HJaneRipley

*You can't escape your judgment day* What happens when Rhea Ripley comes back from a 6 month drought, and into your life as the new and upcoming star of WWE? This is a spicy, F x F romance story with tension and angst. Including a possessive Rhea Ripley. For the lovers of WWE, enemies to lovers and all things Rhea Ripley ❤️

Be Mine Forever? (Rhea Ripley x Reader) by ur_mother28

A Valentine's Day story (femxfem) Rhea Ripley x reader just a short story about love I hope you enjoy ❤️

(Un)Break me - Rhea Ripley x reader by larrychild

Your head has always been a weird place to live in, and it all leads to this point in which you don't care if you're falling in a trap anymore: the pain and the misery are addicting. With that, after starting working with the Judgement Day, you kinda already expected Rhea Ripley to break your heart. It didn't really matter that much, you had nothing to lose. What you didn't expect, though, is that she wouldn't do it, even when you kinda wish she would. Not intentionally, at least. She's good like that. But you, you are not. And maybe that's all it takes. //// This story is also on on ao3 as well, same name and same user if you wanna check it out (the story is more advanced there as I started posting there before) //// This story brings up sensitive topics that can be triggering to people so read at your own risk. (depression, anxiety, suicidal ideation, low self talk, mentions of death, the list goes on) P.s. don't come at me for the timeline! It's for the sake of the plot :)

I'll Cover You || Rhea Ripley by lazarusros3

"𝐰𝐡𝐞𝐧 𝐲𝐨𝐮 𝐚𝐫𝐞 𝐜𝐨𝐥𝐝 𝐚𝐧𝐝 𝐥𝐨𝐧𝐞𝐥𝐲, 𝐢𝐥𝐥 𝐜𝐨𝐯𝐞𝐫 𝐲𝐨𝐮 𝐰𝐢𝐭𝐡 𝐚 𝐭𝐡𝐨𝐮𝐬𝐚𝐧𝐝 𝐬𝐰𝐞𝐞𝐭 𝐤𝐢𝐬𝐬𝐞𝐬" 𝐖𝐡𝐞𝐧 Taylor's contract with All Elite Wrestling comes to an end and she's waiting to be signed and ultimately chooses the offer made to her from WWE having to adjust to the new environment and meeting new people while also seeing familiar faces was obviously going to be a part of the deal. Before walking into those doors and under the lights she made a decision to follow a plan she had in place. But when she meets one person how can she adapt to the changes she has to make to accommodate this new found reality? this is a female x female story. This story will also include -smut -violence -language -slow burn -mature themes -grief including some others not listed. not everything included in this story will be accurate to reality. this is simply a work of fiction. dear reader, In this story there will be topics that may not be suitable for all readers. as this is just a work of fiction not everything will be accurate to the real thing. (most things will not be accurate) DISCLAIMER!! i mean no disrespect to any real couples in reality but again this is a work of fiction and it is an au. I am using Julia Hart as the face claim for the main character so for the purpose of this story Julia Hart does not exist.

Ruffle | A Rhea Ripley Story | By A.Magpie by PossessedMagpie

In this story, Popstar Marilyn Blake must navigate her life while on a break from the spotlight, all while juggling the writing of her new album about heartbreak with her own new love story. Will Marnie be able to heal her broken heart? Or will her new biggest fan break it again? ~ "As someone who grew up watching wrestling, the scariest part is not the fighting, or violence, or even the scary costumes. The scariest part of pro-wrestling is all the women being too attractive for their own good" I haven't watched wrestling in a good 15 years though. Thanks to my career I desperately had to find a new roommate. Who also had to be a girl, cooked, cleaned, was polite, had human decency, didn't mind my singing, and had a job that keeps them out of the house. So I could record...obviously. So a peppy pro-wrestler would be perfect, right? I totally won't fall for her or any of her coworkers, right?" ~~ This is a Rhea Ripley and OC romance! I will try my best I promise! Love, A.Magpie/but you can call me Maggie ;)

Death Of Peace Of Mind || Dominik Mysterio by livmysterio

highest rating #2 in #wweraw || She was his. Whether she knew it or not, whether she wanted to except it or not, she was entirely his. He would have her one way or another, no matter the cost, no matter the consequences. or the one where Dominik Mysterio because overtly obsessed with one Delaney Bennett.

Lover's Pentagon by ybrrtjd0425

Kathrine Victoria. Her talents in acting, singing, songwriting, and dancing were discovered when she was only 14. After 4 years of fame, she decides to go for the dream she's had since she was a little kid of becoming a professional wrestler for the WWE! Making her debut at 18 and taking a break for a year and a half at 21, she decides to come back to her dream! She expected chaos when she returned. What she didn't expect was four members of the most dominant faction in the WWE to start hitting on her! Hoping she'd join them, not only to dominate the WWE but join them in their romantic endeavors! Will her love life get in the way of her career or will her career be the reason she never finds true love? Poly!judgement day x original character This story is exclusively on Wattpad only

Mami's Wolf and Angel (Rhea Ripley X Male X Female OC) by jokerpumpkin

Set back at the start of The Judgment Day, what will happen when two of Rhea Ripley's best friends are included in the new dominant faction? Most importantly, what will happen when the three friends start to develop feelings that could possibly lead to more than just friendship? Mine and Ben's OC are both in a poly relationship with Demi Bennett, aka Rhea Bloody Ripley. DISCLAIMER: We do not own nor are we associated with WWE or the wrestlers portrayed in this story. This is purely for fun, no profit. This story is rated Mature for language, mature themes, and sexual content.

You may also like

Slide 1 of 10

Rainy Day | Rhea Ripley cover

Absolute Smokeshow cover

Riptide | Rhea Ripley | Enemies to Lovers | Possessive and Spicy cover

Be Mine Forever? (Rhea Ripley x Reader) cover

(Un)Break me - Rhea Ripley x reader cover

I'll Cover You || Rhea Ripley cover

Ruffle | A Rhea Ripley Story | By A.Magpie cover

Death Of Peace Of Mind || Dominik Mysterio cover

Lover's Pentagon cover

Mami's Wolf and Angel (Rhea Ripley X Male X Female OC) cover

Rainy Day | Rhea Ripley

Alex is caught in a spiral of trying to work as a videographer for the judgment day with a less than cooperative Rhea Ripley as her boss and trying to keep a secret from everyone. How long will it take until everything comes crashing down on her? #1 on rhearipley | January 2025