Given An Unwanted Second Chance
- Reads 68,511
- Votes 4,575
- Parts 63
Ongoing17h 38m
Last published Sat, Apr 11, 2026
(TW: unaliving thoughts and memories at the beginning. It gets better over time, don't worry! Trauma is difficult to overcome...)
You didn't want a second chance.
You didn't want to survive.
You wanted the sweet release of death.
But it seemed like the universe was far too cruel to allow you even that.
It took away your memories, your free will to choose whether you live or die...hell, it took the one thing in life you owned! Your own name!
And now it seemed like you had to live yet another cruel life, doing things you never wanted done to others. But...at least you could do things your way.
Maybe this second chance wouldn't be so bad...
(Reincarnated as Nightmare Sans, but unlike other stories, you have no clue what Undertale even is)
(WE REACHED NUMBER 1 IN THE UNDERTALE TAG YOOOOOOOO) (9/13/25)
All Rights Reserved
#2
undertale
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
Ashes to Ashes (Discontinued)
Cold. Everything was cold. And dark. I was so alone... how could I have wanted this? This couldn't possibly be better than before... the warmth, and the light, and the smiles, however scarce. I cried out. I screamed, but it was muffled. I wanted it back. I wanted everything back. I regretted my decisions, my plans, my dreams. I wanted a second chance. **Reborn as a ??? Sans** !!READ THE FINAL ANNOUNCEMENT IN THE FIRST CHAPTER FOR IMPORTANT INFO BEFORE STARTING PLEASE!!
To Kill A Killer
Nightmare's gang always knew that their job was risky, but they never expected to actually die. Then Killer was killed. Nightmare found a replacement quickly enough, but this new Killer isn't the same as the old one, and the gang are having a hard time adjusting. Inspired by a comic by darkxsoulzyxcaliberx. Something New belongs to rahafwabas. Dusttale belongs to Ask-Dusttale. Dreamtale belongs to Joku. Horrortale belongs to Sour-Apple-Studios. Xtale and Underverse belong to Jakei. Underswap belongs to p0pcornPr1nce/the Undertale AU community. Ink!Sans belongs to Comyet. Any other characters and AUs mentioned belong to their original creators. All art by me. A huge thank you to my partner for beta-reading.
Murderous lovers dust sans x reader
You are a cold killer. Being childhood friends with ink cause you b8th were failed experiments and left with no souls. You killed your parents cause they hated you and you killed everyone in your au and did mutliple genocide routes just stop the human from killing you and your papyrus. But your papyrus stayed in the broken au cause he hated the new you. Then you joined the bad sanses and your work partner is dust sans. At first you didnt like the looks of him but then you reliase that he is the same as you. Did multiple genocide routes just to stop his frisk and now you guys keep on getting closer to the point you guys fell in love with each other and nightmare didnt approve of it at all.Complete![Comfort a little Dream [UNDERTALE]](https://img.wattpad.com/cover/288744733-256-k549350.jpg)
Comfort a little Dream [UNDERTALE]
"Dream hiccupped, trembling, trying to repress those filthy thoughts, those thoughts that terrified him. But he was unable to fight back. Not while Ink was in Error's hands, wounded and unarmed. Not while all the BadSanses surrounded him, ready to react to his every move." === === WARNING = This fanfiction isn't meant to be canonical. The characters and universe used do not belong to me. Please don't refer to this story if you are looking for canonical information.Complete
The One Thing That They Care About (Sans AU x Reader x Papyrus AU)
Y/n L/n. A special human with a special SOUL. Yes, her Soul Trait is something new. But other than her SOUL trait she has another secret. One day, while she was at the surface with Frisk and Sans. 6 skeletons appeared out of nowhere, making raging screams and chaos as maniac laughter filled the air in their wake. Soon they found Classic Sans with Y/n & Frisk. But when they saw Y/n, they were curious of how she can wield magic powers and be brave. Soon they took Y/N with them, to their castle. Will Y/n tame them? Or will Y/n fail and suffer the consequences? Involving a Bad Sanses x Reader x Star Sanses plot. Along with various Alternate Sanses. #1 in badsanses at 17/01/2021 #1 in ausanses at 31/01/2021 #2 (Out of 21.8K) in nightmare at 24/02/2021 #38 (Out of 48.1K) in undertale at 21/05/2021 #3 in (Out of 3.42k) Cross at 18/12/2021 #1 in Dust (Out if 2.15k) at 18/12/2021Complete
Blind Love (Reader X Nightmare Sans)
(Obsessed)Nightmare Sans x Blind Reader Trigger Warning! Abuse! For Mature Audiences ~~~ Y/n has known nothing but darkness her entire life. Blinded by the cruelty of her past, she navigates the world with cautious steps, haunted by the scars of her abusive upbringing. Yet, amidst the shadows that cloud her existence, she discovers a glimmer of hope in the form of a mysterious stranger who watches her from afar. Nightmare Sans is captivated by Y/N's ethereal beauty and resilient spirit. Obsessed with unravelling the mysteries shrouding her life, he becomes entangled in a dangerous game of cat and mouse, risking everything to protect the object of his affection. Wondering who exactly is in control, a lonely boy only desiring love, or a manipulative shadow? As their lives intertwine, Y/n and Nightmare find themselves drawn into a whirlwind of danger and desire, their fates bound by an invisible thread that defies logic and reason. But as secrets are revealed and dark truths come to light, they must confront their deepest fears and confront the shadows of their pasts.
Cold. Everything was cold. And dark. I was so alone... how could I have wanted this? This couldn't possibly be better than before... the warmth, and the light, and the smiles, however scarce. I cried out. I screamed, but it was muffled. I wanted it back. I wanted everything back. I regretted my decisions, my plans, my dreams. I wanted a second chance. **Reborn as a ??? Sans** !!READ THE FINAL ANNOUNCEMENT IN THE FIRST CHAPTER FOR IMPORTANT INFO BEFORE STARTING PLEASE!!
More detailsContent Guidelines