Given An Unwanted Second Chance
- Reads 67,317
- Votes 4,426
- Parts 62
Ongoing17h 24m
Last published Sun, Mar 29, 2026
(TW: unaliving thoughts and memories at the beginning. It gets better over time, don't worry! Trauma is difficult to overcome...)
You didn't want a second chance.
You didn't want to survive.
You wanted the sweet release of death.
But it seemed like the universe was far too cruel to allow you even that.
It took away your memories, your free will to choose whether you live or die...hell, it took the one thing in life you owned! Your own name!
And now it seemed like you had to live yet another cruel life, doing things you never wanted done to others. But...at least you could do things your way.
Maybe this second chance wouldn't be so bad...
(Reincarnated as Nightmare Sans, but unlike other stories, you have no clue what Undertale even is)
(WE REACHED NUMBER 1 IN THE UNDERTALE TAG YOOOOOOOO) (9/13/25)
All Rights Reserved
#1
undertale
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
Prisoner...? (Bad Sanses x Human!Reader)
Y/N was a human from a brand new AU...which was practically nothing. They were eventually rescued by the Star Sanses...only to be taken prisoner by the Bad Sanses. What will happen? How would they escape...if they willingly want to? This story was originally posted on Quotev! It will always be updated first there, then here. #1 in #sanses 7/1/21 #1 in #badsanses 10/25/21 #3 in #errorsans 5/9/22 #4 in #inksans 5/9/22 #1 in #killersans 6/15/22Complete
"𝗟𝗼𝘃𝗮𝗯𝗹𝗲 𝗖𝗼𝗻𝗳𝗶𝗱𝗮𝗻𝘁𝘀"(ErrorInkMare)
Welp...here it is ꧁•••••꧂ One day...Ink was being reported as a murderer Ink always denying that he didn't killed his two best friends that was Dream and Blue,...or is he actually telling the truth? Well,he was being sent in the Asylum because the others think that he was now being crazy Error and Nightmare was figuring out the truth themselves instead of believing the one who witnessed Ink killing his two bestfriends '3 𝒅𝒂𝒚𝒔 𝒍𝒆𝒇𝒕 𝒃𝒆𝒇𝒐𝒓𝒆 𝑰𝒏𝒌 𝒘𝒊𝒍𝒍 𝒃𝒆 𝒆𝒙𝒆𝒄𝒖𝒕𝒆𝒅...' Also...which one Ink would chose to be with him forever? Is it Error or Nightmare? Maybe both? Let's find out! Story Contains: Swearing/Cursing words Angst Other mature content ♡︎♡︎♡︎♡︎♡︎ Cover by me |Date Started:10/20/21| |Date Ended:12/13/21|Complete
To Kill A Killer
Nightmare's gang always knew that their job was risky, but they never expected to actually die. Then Killer was killed. Nightmare found a replacement quickly enough, but this new Killer isn't the same as the old one, and the gang are having a hard time adjusting. Inspired by a comic by darkxsoulzyxcaliberx. Something New belongs to rahafwabas. Dusttale belongs to Ask-Dusttale. Dreamtale belongs to Joku. Horrortale belongs to Sour-Apple-Studios. Xtale and Underverse belong to Jakei. Underswap belongs to p0pcornPr1nce/the Undertale AU community. Ink!Sans belongs to Comyet. Any other characters and AUs mentioned belong to their original creators. All art by me. A huge thank you to my partner for beta-reading.
Unwanted protection
Everyone knows the Star Sanses: they're the Guardians of the Multiverse, and protect it from Nightmare and his minions, who only want to spread chaos and destruction. They're kind, strong, brave, the good guys! How can you not love them? You can't. They deserve the world. They're perfect and selfless and precious, and must be protected at any (and I do mean ANY) cost. Not that they couldn't protect themselves, of course! It's just, the Multiverse doesn't give them the appreciation and respect they deserve, not really. But Nightmare, Error, Horror, Killer, Dust, Cross... they know how much Dream, Ink and Blue are worth. And they'll keep them safe. Forever. The credit of this story partially belongs to Stargazer_Aldroth, who created a prompt on AO3 and helped me flesh out the story before I started writing. If you're interested, you can check out the comment chain where we discuss ideas for this oneshot and eventual follow-up (for now this story is marked as complete, but I could write other chapters, who knows?) on AO3 from author Stargazer_Nebula "Undertale Writing prompts" (it's the chapter with this same title)Complete
Murderous lovers dust sans x reader
You are a cold killer. Being childhood friends with ink cause you b8th were failed experiments and left with no souls. You killed your parents cause they hated you and you killed everyone in your au and did mutliple genocide routes just stop the human from killing you and your papyrus. But your papyrus stayed in the broken au cause he hated the new you. Then you joined the bad sanses and your work partner is dust sans. At first you didnt like the looks of him but then you reliase that he is the same as you. Did multiple genocide routes just to stop his frisk and now you guys keep on getting closer to the point you guys fell in love with each other and nightmare didnt approve of it at all.Complete![Comfort a little Dream [UNDERTALE]](https://img.wattpad.com/cover/288744733-256-k549350.jpg)
Comfort a little Dream [UNDERTALE]
"Dream hiccupped, trembling, trying to repress those filthy thoughts, those thoughts that terrified him. But he was unable to fight back. Not while Ink was in Error's hands, wounded and unarmed. Not while all the BadSanses surrounded him, ready to react to his every move." === === WARNING = This fanfiction isn't meant to be canonical. The characters and universe used do not belong to me. Please don't refer to this story if you are looking for canonical information.Complete
Blind Love (Reader X Nightmare Sans)
(Obsessed)Nightmare Sans x Blind Reader Trigger Warning! Abuse! For Mature Audiences ~~~ Y/n has known nothing but darkness her entire life. Blinded by the cruelty of her past, she navigates the world with cautious steps, haunted by the scars of her abusive upbringing. Yet, amidst the shadows that cloud her existence, she discovers a glimmer of hope in the form of a mysterious stranger who watches her from afar. Nightmare Sans is captivated by Y/N's ethereal beauty and resilient spirit. Obsessed with unravelling the mysteries shrouding her life, he becomes entangled in a dangerous game of cat and mouse, risking everything to protect the object of his affection. Wondering who exactly is in control, a lonely boy only desiring love, or a manipulative shadow? As their lives intertwine, Y/n and Nightmare find themselves drawn into a whirlwind of danger and desire, their fates bound by an invisible thread that defies logic and reason. But as secrets are revealed and dark truths come to light, they must confront their deepest fears and confront the shadows of their pasts.
The One Thing That They Care About (Sans AU x Reader x Papyrus AU)
Y/n L/n. A special human with a special SOUL. Yes, her Soul Trait is something new. But other than her SOUL trait she has another secret. One day, while she was at the surface with Frisk and Sans. 6 skeletons appeared out of nowhere, making raging screams and chaos as maniac laughter filled the air in their wake. Soon they found Classic Sans with Y/n & Frisk. But when they saw Y/n, they were curious of how she can wield magic powers and be brave. Soon they took Y/N with them, to their castle. Will Y/n tame them? Or will Y/n fail and suffer the consequences? Involving a Bad Sanses x Reader x Star Sanses plot. Along with various Alternate Sanses. #1 in badsanses at 17/01/2021 #1 in ausanses at 31/01/2021 #2 (Out of 21.8K) in nightmare at 24/02/2021 #38 (Out of 48.1K) in undertale at 21/05/2021 #3 in (Out of 3.42k) Cross at 18/12/2021 #1 in Dust (Out if 2.15k) at 18/12/2021Complete
The Multiverse Tyrant
!! STORY COVER IS MINE, CHARACTERS DO NOT BELONG TO ME EXCEPT Y/N !! (ps, heavily inspired by my other books, mainly Multiverse's Unwilling Protector.) (Book is currently in hiatus, will be back soon🫶🏻) - " New life emerges from the past, In every breath, the die is cast. Guided by echoes of lives once known, Hopes reborn where seeds were sown. Through time's embrace, I rise once more, My soul reborn on a distant shore. As shadows fade, I find my way, Reincarnation brings the day. Eternal cycles, never apart- ■¿■??1■■2211?¡? Nightmares end, but souls restart. " Reincarnation - the rebirth of a soul in a new body. #1 in nightmare sans 01/30/23 #1 in killer sans 01/30/23 #1 in dust sans 02/09/23 #1 in fell sans 08/22/24 #1 in action fantasy 08/22/24 #2 in undertale 08/25/24 #1 in omnipotence 09/02/24 #1 in lazar 09/02/24 #1 in inksans 02/02/25 (This is DreamTale if you're wondering. Another day, another book.)
The Boy Who Doesn't Speak (Sans AUs) -- BEING REWRITTEN
For some reason, Ink, the Creator and Protector of the Sans AUs, has decided that some of the Sanses of the Multiverse should go to highschool again. Honestly, no one really liked the idea, especially the Bad Sanses, including Ink's enemy, Error. Prince Nightmare is one of the AUs that must repeat these years of treachery. He basically only finished his actual highschool, and is NOT looking forward to having to do it again. Luckily his brother, Prince Dream, will be coming along the journey beside him. But Nightmare and Dream Are polar opposites, so Nightmare can't really get along with his brother's friends, nor Dream get along with Nightmare's, if he had any. With rules to follow and secrets to keep, Nightmare must go through highschool and not let slip the terrible things that happen at home. But then suddenly the two princes disappear. There's no trace as to who might've taken them, either. The only one that doesn't seem concerned is their own father, the king. King Sun-Beam. What is he hiding underneath all of those jewels and fake smiles? A/N: There is lemon/smut. So all you innocent people out there-- don't worry! Because I warn you at every chapter, and right before it happens. I designed the cover, but did the not the amazing artwork of Nightmare Sans. So credit goes to that person for the art. :D Update!!!!: This story is being rewitten. I'm making another book that'll just be this one but a little different. Once that's posted, I'll make another "chapter" in this one, giving a link to the rewrite. Thank you to everyone who still reads or checks up on this book. <3333Complete
"Bullseye" A Killermare story
Killer is a sans, and so is the rest of his crew. They call themselves "The Bad Sanses." They've all had one goal at some point in time, revenge. However, Killer is a unique specimen. He is an emotionless being. He feels nothing and nothing only. No remorse. No happiness. No mercy. All he knows is "kill," and that's how it's been for long time. However, one day he comes across a new particular type of Sans. A very colorful one. He feels something he hasn't felt for years. Freedom. Once Nightmare finds out, it's not pretty. Killer was his most loyal worker. So he decided he had to end this "friendship." The question Killer asks is, why? "Why do you need me to feel nothing? Why do you want me to be a part of your crew? You always tell me how useless I am. If I'm so useless, why do you need me?" Nightmare couldn't give him an answer. But, maybe, for once in his life, Nightmare feels something for only Killer that isn't so negative. 🎨COVER ART🎨 COVER ART WAS NOT CREATED BY ME, I REPEAT, NOT CREATED BY ME ART WAS CREATED BY pecil(BB) or @mm_loves_pencil ON TWITTER SUPER FREAKING TALENTED CHECK IT OUT!!!! ⚠️Warning⚠️ This fanfic is a little toxic. I tried making everything as canon possible, which is why I'm putting this warning. However, after writing this entire story, I realize some things are more fanon than canon. Nonetheless, serious angst goes down in the fanfic, so be warned. Contains: Heavy language Sensitive topics (such as abuse, trauma, and depression) Angst Smut (maybe, I'm still deciding) Graphic scenes containing gore -if any of the following bother you, I highly suggest not reading this fanfic- |you have been warned, so don't come at me if you don't like it| I promise it all ends on a good note. I can't personally stand depressing endings. So don't worry. But hey, enjoy your overdose on Killermare. 🤷♀️
Ashes to Ashes (Discontinued)
Cold. Everything was cold. And dark. I was so alone... how could I have wanted this? This couldn't possibly be better than before... the warmth, and the light, and the smiles, however scarce. I cried out. I screamed, but it was muffled. I wanted it back. I wanted everything back. I regretted my decisions, my plans, my dreams. I wanted a second chance. **Reborn as a ??? Sans** !!READ THE FINAL ANNOUNCEMENT IN THE FIRST CHAPTER FOR IMPORTANT INFO BEFORE STARTING PLEASE!!![My Villain [Dust Sans x Reader]](https://img.wattpad.com/cover/337651572-256-k593042.jpg)
My Villain [Dust Sans x Reader]
A young woman, left alone after her family sadly passed in a car accident, suffers with PTSD and Anthropophobia (Fear of people.) Her only happiness in this world is the view of the stars from Mount Ebott. But one day, Y/N falls into a large abyss located on top of the mountain. There, she enters the Underground. The rumors of the humans and monsters war are proved true. Fearful of the monsters, she stays hidden. But from what monsters? I made the cover, as in I found the art on google (I'd supply a link to it, but sadly I cannot access the website and I don't know who made the wonderful art :sob:) and edited it. This is a Dust Sans x Reader (who's female because I can't write anything other than that.) ANY ART IN THIS DOESN'T BELONG TO ME UNLESS I SAY SO. I CAN'T DRAW.Complete
The Colorless Guardian
When a loner got reincarnated as Ink! Sans. What could possibly happen? Warning ⚠️ #Error is neutral/ not a part with Nightmare Gang #No romance #Short chapters #I'm a newbie...Complete
I Found You My Dear Inkmare fanfic
When Ink is exploring the au's, he stumbles upon a new au where he meets a new friend named Nightmare. The both of them create a close bond, and Nightmare explains how the villagers mistreats him and how they treasure Dream. Ink knew Dream for awhile, but Dream never mentions Nightmare. One day Nightmare had enough of the villagers and ate the apple of negativity and leaves Dreamtale empty. When Ink comes to visit Nightmare, he sees that everyone is disappeared, and so did Nightmare. Not mention Dreams new and unusual behaviour towards Ink. [All artworks in this story, including the cover, belong to me. I kindly ask that you DO NOT use them, post them, trace/edit them, or claim them as yours. It's rude and highly frowned upon. Thank you.]Complete![Justice (Ink!Sans x Reader) [COMPLETED]](https://img.wattpad.com/cover/206396120-256-k257606.jpg)
Justice (Ink!Sans x Reader) [COMPLETED]
Heya! This book will be a bit of a slow burn, which means that all the ~romance stuff~ won't happen until a little later in the story. ~~~ Twenty year old (Y/N) has sworn her undying loyalty to none other than Nightmare, one of the most feared villains in the multiverse. She's been working with him for years, since she was seventeen, but she's never encountered the infamous Star Sanses. She wishes that she could meet them, she hopes that she'll be able to fight them some day and end their existence. Her ultimate goal is to impress her boss and to prove herself to everyone who told her that she wasn't good enough. Will her wish change when she encounters the Star Sanses? Completed 12/24/2021 ~~~ Pronouns used in this story are she/her Disclaimer: None of the art used belongs to me! If you see your art/know the person who made it, feel free to let me know so I can credit them :) *Cover art belongs to RyuuseiRissu on DeviantArt*Complete
Y/N was a human from a brand new AU...which was practically nothing. They were eventually rescued by the Star Sanses...only to be taken prisoner by the Bad Sanses. What will happen? How would they escape...if they willingly want to? This story was originally posted on Quotev! It will always be updated first there, then here. #1 in #sanses 7/1/21 #1 in #badsanses 10/25/21 #3 in #errorsans 5/9/22 #4 in #inksans 5/9/22 #1 in #killersans 6/15/22
More detailsContent Guidelines