I Wish There Was Another Way Out [A Multi-shipping Creepypasta Fanfic] (REPOST) - Your Worst Nightmare - Wattpad

I Wish There Was Another Way Out [A Multi-shipping Creepypasta Fanfic] (REPOST)

Reads 124
Votes 15
Parts 10
Time 2h 45m

Reads 124
Votes 15
Parts 10
Time 2h 45m

Mature

The Creepypastas are living a happy life. Any one of them has a relationship (except Nina cuz no one wants her) and they're living in apartments in Denver. They have everything they need and sometimes they are going out for killing sprees. But one day when Jeff goes out to buy sex toys, paranormal things happen that not only change something in their lives, but also in their relationships.
Will they survive and safe their relationships?

[This is a repost of this fanfic that I wrote in 2020 because Wattpad deleted it for no reason so excuse the grammar mistakes in the first 9 chapters and how stupid they are]



Ships:
Brim (Brian/Hoodie X Tim/Masky)
TicciHomicidal (Ticci Toby X Homicidal Liu)
TheKillerWork (Jane The Killer X Clockwork)
EyelessTheKiller (Eyeless Jack X Jeff The Killer)
LaughingTheToymaker (Laughing Jack X Jason The Toymaker)


Trigger warnings:
- Depression
- Homophobia
- Blood & Gore
- Male Pregnancy
- Sex & Kinky stuff
- Sexual Harassment
- Mentions of Selfharm and Suicide

If you have something against the ships or get triggered by that stuff, read at your own riskAll Rights Reserved

Table of contents

10 parts

Sign up to add I Wish There Was Another Way Out [A Multi-shipping Creepypasta Fanfic] (REPOST) to your library and receive updates

or

Content Guidelines

You may also like

Our Prince (Creepypasta × Male! Reader) by SquishySmithIII

All the stories are true. All of the sightings, the myths, the legends, the encounters. Deep inside the darkest forest, is a mansion full of killers who feast on the blood of the innocent and not so innocent. There really is a man with long arms and hands, whose face is as blank as death. This band of misfits truly considers themselves the last family that have left. Until they met you. Slenderman saw great potential in you when, even on your last beats of strength, managed to take down his Proxies and Jeff the Killer. Slowly, but surely, the Pastas nursed you back to health and sharpened your abilities to their maximum. This was it, you finally had a group of friends you could call family. All was good. Well, in your life, at least. The truth is, you're being hunted. By none other than the most powerful demon that could ever roam this earth, Zalgo, Lord of the Underealm. And, to your uncomfort, your father. Ever since you had fought him and fled his kingdom, he has done everything in his power to torment you into returning home. You vowed to Slenderman that you would never leave and betray the Creeps. You couldn't. After all they had done for you? But how long can your promise last? Will Zalgo manage to break you? And who will be strong enough to stay by your side? Warning: major swearing *cough cough* Jeffrey Woods *cough cough* This is also a Male!Reader × Jane the Killer story. Even though, yes, I know she's lesbian but let a guy dream (even though I'm not a guy)!

I'm Just A Freak (Abandoned) by clear-quartz

||WARNING! THIS BOOK HAS BEEN ABANDONED!|| (Y/N) had always been a seemingly normal guy. Never really causing trouble, had great friends and a loving sister, but he had struggles that little to no one knew about. One day, though, that all changed with a few simple actions done by another. A/N I do not own any of the Creepypastas, art, or videos (unless said otherwise) in this story (sadly). All credit goes to the original creators.

Blank Face (Ticci Toby x Reader) by SarahMKJ

My emotions are trapped inside of me. I try to express them freely. I've tried for years, but I always fail. The kids in my school call me Blank Face. They sing and mock me. They think that I don't care. They think that I am an empty vessel rather than a person, but they are wrong. I am empty only on the outside. They don't understand. They never will. ---- I've watched her walk around in the woods with her friends many times. Emptyness. That's all I see in her face. Plain. That's all I hear in her voice. At first, my intension was to kill her. But then something happened that changed everything. *Strong language* This is my first X Reader fan fiction. So I don't have any experience in this kind of thing. But it will be good to try something new. (I know that Toby twitches/ticks, I'm just too lazy to put in every twitch he makes. He ticks throughout the whole story, it's just not in writing.) Key: Y/N- your name E/C- eye color H/C- hair color F/C- favorite color F/B- favorite book ________- time skip

Creepypasta Files by hostofhorus999

Files on Creepypastas- exactly what it sounds like. My personal headcanons have been incorporated A LOT, so be warned. -None of these characters belong to me- -MY SHIPS. Don't like 'em, don't read. (Ships are: Toby x Masky, Eyeless Jack x Ben Drowned, I'll add more when/if I think of them.)- -Some articles are taken directly from a wiki. Credit to whoever wrote them-

A victim of horrible chance | Creepypasta x youTuber!reader by sleepydragonfly

[Note the description and title and book cover are changed to a more update and to my taste look, but the contents/the fic itself, hasn't been updated, so you'll be getting hit with 2015 humor and the most awful writing from a 12 to 13 year old. I'll get around to actually updating this one day] [reader is gender neutral, no pronouns or gender terms are used for the reader] You are a small youtuber/Streamer who has a special interest in horror and urban legends, the likes of jeff the killer, the rake, Slenderman, But what if you fall victim to those urban legends? what if they take an interest in you after you avoided death from one of them? what if they drag you back to their home, their hunting grounds? you just wanted to entertain people and have a community of individuals with your same interests. you didn't ask to be constantly in danger in your own home and then out in the forest your backyard leads to, you never asked to basically befriend some of them, maybe you'll finally get answers as to why they became the people they are.

Messed up in all the right ways {proxies X reader} by mortuusrising

{C O M P L E T E D} -- An orphan girl, (y/n) (l/n) an abused and bullied girl with depression. Her life changes when she is taken to become the newest proxy, and meets the proxies. Read to find out what happens next! -- Cover by: @OliverTheHoodini -- *contains: mature language, potential triggers, abuse, and depression. (so far)* -- This is a crossover universe/alternate universe where the events of marble hornets did happen but Hoodie never died and instead of Tim (Masky) running away from the law, they both went with The operator. The operator will be Slenderman not a different entity in this story -- I am very aware that Masky and Hoodie aren't creepypasta characters, and that they have never and will never be in anyway connected to creepypasta. -- Masky and hoodie belong to THAC Ticci-Toby belongs to Kastoway (even though Kastoway doesn't care anymore) -- sorry for such a long description. But, enjoy!

¤The Mansion Maid¤ by grrr__idek

《𝑺𝒑𝒐𝒐𝒌𝒚 𝒏𝒐𝒐𝒅𝒍𝒆𝒔》 '𝔾𝕖𝕥 𝕤𝕞𝕒𝕤𝕙𝕖𝕕 𝕎𝕙𝕒𝕥.' After getting hacked, you were invited to some random group chat filled with killers and stuff. You got kidnapped and made to do the house chores. 𝟓𝐔𝐂𝐊𝟓 𝟕𝟎 𝟖𝟑 𝐘𝟎𝐔 𝟏𝟎𝟏. Anyways, they eat some contaminated food and become all weird and you have to deal with their tomfoolery (Female! reader x Creepypastas) (Maybe yandere idk) (A/N) I've been waiting ages to publish this book so it might be shit I'm fine with criticism constructive or not credits for the cover https://www.pinterest.co.uk/pin/737534876496867960/

𝚆𝚑𝚊𝚝 𝚊𝚛𝚎 𝚝𝚑𝚎𝚢? [✔] {Jeff the Killer x Gender Neutral Reader} by Lesbesbean

In order to save your life, Slenderman does what he swore he'd never do - he makes you his proxy. Little did you know how much it would change your life... - - - The reader is kept gender-neutral throughout the whole story and smut chapters always have two versions (one for male and one for female anatomy). Tldr; this is a creepypasta x reader fanfic, let's not take it *too* seriously. Characters here are probably very OOC, I shaped them as I wish to create a fun story ;3

The Horror and Pleasure of Our Love (Jeff The Killer x Eyeless Jack fanfic) by deathscrazedpuppet

Is being in love with a cannibal bad enough? <<containts smut in some Chapters>> YAOI FANFIC

Camp Creepy by Grimfoxgirl

Good evening fellow humans. I am here to tell you that this fanfic I wrote while I was in like 8-9th grade. It's shitty, it's awful, I have no consistency in chapter length, and had litterally no plans for the story. I'm now in college and this is something that keeps me awake at night. I've also just in general abandoned this Wattpad account. :) I'm not sure if you're here to read a story or here to laugh at the story but I will tell you, it will be a ride. I'd suggest going into this with no expectations other than to laugh at it! Now with out further ado the actual description of the story- Camp Creepy the special camp for the special... no it's not one of those camps for the needy teaching them about leadership and kindness. This camp is for the future's serial killers and creepypasta who just need that little push to get them going! Each promising child will be sent a letter from me, the camp director, explaining their situation. So let me delay you no longer and let us begin. sincerely, Camp Creepy's Head Director Mr. Slenderman

You may also like

Slide 1 of 10

Our Prince (Creepypasta × Male! Reader) cover

I'm Just A Freak (Abandoned) cover

Blank Face (Ticci Toby x Reader) cover

Creepypasta Files cover

A victim of horrible chance | Creepypasta x youTuber!reader cover

Messed up in all the right ways {proxies X reader} cover

¤The Mansion Maid¤ cover

𝚆𝚑𝚊𝚝 𝚊𝚛𝚎 𝚝𝚑𝚎𝚢? [✔] {Jeff the Killer x Gender Neutral Reader} cover

The Horror and Pleasure of Our Love (Jeff The Killer x Eyeless Jack fanfic) cover

Camp Creepy cover

Our Prince (Creepypasta × Male! Reader)

All the stories are true. All of the sightings, the myths, the legends, the encounters. Deep inside the darkest forest, is a mansion full of killers who feast on the blood of the innocent and not so innocent. There really is a man with long arms and hands, whose face is as blank as death. This band of misfits truly considers themselves the last family that have left. Until they met you. Slenderman saw great potential in you when, even on your last beats of strength, managed to take down his Proxies and Jeff the Killer. Slowly, but surely, the Pastas nursed you back to health and sharpened your abilities to their maximum. This was it, you finally had a group of friends you could call family. All was good. Well, in your life, at least. The truth is, you're being hunted. By none other than the most powerful demon that could ever roam this earth, Zalgo, Lord of the Underealm. And, to your uncomfort, your father. Ever since you had fought him and fled his kingdom, he has done everything in his power to torment you into returning home. You vowed to Slenderman that you would never leave and betray the Creeps. You couldn't. After all they had done for you? But how long can your promise last? Will Zalgo manage to break you? And who will be strong enough to stay by your side? Warning: major swearing cough cough Jeffrey Woods cough cough This is also a Male!Reader × Jane the Killer story. Even though, yes, I know she's lesbian but let a guy dream (even though I'm not a guy)!