Three seemingly insignificant and irrelevant souls are all touched by the same presence, binding them intricately together. The dyslexic but brilliant foster child. The superstitious, hat-wearing lesbian. The puppy-eyed behind-the-scenes aspergers boy. And the enigmatic girl who everyone thought they knew to the core. When Jamie, Lilah, and Annie encounter each other when Dustin Geller goes missing, their entire worlds are thrown into question. Is Dustin the outgoing, but kind romantic who loves to make her boyfriend smile? Is Dustin a shy, bohemian girl, unaccepted by her conservative parents? Or is she the wild one, who gags at the thought of any significant other, and busies her self with intoxicated sexual escapades and dancing? As soon as the three move past their differences, they realize that a girl is still missing. A girl that nobody truly knew.