As they wait in line at a Panic! at the Disco concert, three friends find a guy with a lip ring that they all instantly fall in love with. During the concert, they become friends with him. After the concert, the struggle for romance begins. Aislyn, Tanner and Juliette must figure out which one of them gets the guy and who makes the first move. In this story, they become tangled in a love triangle (square?) that could potentially tear their friendship apart. But it all comes down to the guy with the lip ring.