The Blind Eye

"We'll make a cocktail but add extra ingredients to add... kick to it. Simple. Safe. He might not even realize we did anything after the fact."
-Direct quote from Jimmy, in Mouthwashing.

She wasn't Jimmy's first victim.

Back in high school, there arose an "incident". Jimmy was spiralling, and his best friend, Curly, had to do something. Anything. He, in his loyalty, turned a blind eye to the accusations.
It was his responsibility to deal with the mess.