This is an AU! One day, jock Derek Morgan is waltzing around the school like he owns the place. The next, a massive search party has been gathered to search him in the Halsemore Woods. That's when three girls at his school named Cat, Emily and JJ start their own investigation. They hide an evidence board in the maintenance closet, which is conveniently found by Dereks best friend, Spencer Reid. Now Spencer wants in. But he has butted heads with Cat since day one of kindergarten, will their differences be put aside for the greater good? Or, will someone's motives not turn out to be as good as everyone thought?