Stepsiblings Chloe and Aidan have always been getting at each other ever since they were only in third grade and are still going at it during their senior year. However, Aidan begins to fall for her and as for Chloe, she likes him but is trying to ignore that fact by going for the new kid, Dustin. Sooner or later, senior year ends and they go their separate ways. What happens when they meet again in New York City and Chloe's first Broadway show is about to make its first debut?