The Shadow of What Was Lost

On a fateful Halloween night, Voldemort's attack left an indelible scar-not just on the Wizarding World, but on the Potter family itself. Charles Potter, the elder twin, was hailed as the Boy Who Lived, the celebrated savior who vanquished the Dark Lord. Meanwhile, his younger brother, Harry, was cast into the shadows. Branded as tainted by dark magic, neglected by his family, and shunned by the Wizarding community, Harry Potter grew up in isolation, his potential unrecognized, his heart hardened by their indifference.

Everything changes when the Deity of Choices descends upon the Great Hall, summoning students, professors, parents, and Ministry officials alike to reveal a devastating truth: their collective apathy and cruelty have forged a path for Harry to rise-not as a hero, but as the next Dark Lord, a greater threat than Voldemort ever was.

To confront their complicity, the deity unveils glimpses of an alternate reality-a world where Harry, not Charles, was the Boy Who Lived. In this world, Harry's kindness, brilliance, and strength shine brightly, nurtured by love, support, and the unbreakable bond of his best friend, Esmeralda Black, a Slytherin with unmatched loyalty and a sharp mind.

As these glimpses unfold, the gathered audience is forced to confront the stark contrast between the Harry who thrived and the Harry they condemned. Their prejudices, choices, and failures are laid bare, leaving them to question the very foundation of their beliefs. Was Harry ever destined for darkness, or did they create the monster they feared?

This is a tale of regret and redemption, of fate and free will, and of the undeniable power of choices. As the shadows of "what could have been" reveal a brighter, untarnished Harry, the Wizarding World must reckon with the question:

Who is truly to blame for the darkness?

Can they undo the damage before it's too late-or has their indifference already doomed them all?