I Shouldn't for Her
- Reads 6,544
- Votes 176
- Parts 17
MatureOngoing2h 37m
Last published Sun, Mar 22, 2026
Ruby and Malia are best friends. Ruby has had a crush on Kylie for a while now, but Malia has also liked Kylie. Ruby always makes an effort to flirt with Kylie to make her crush known. Ruby also has so unresolved feelings for Malia. When it comes to flirting Malia on the other hand keeps it a secret from Ruby and Kylie. Maybe Kylie will figure it out or find feelings for Malia. Maybe Ruby will finally confess her feeling to Malia. Is this is going to end badly for all or going to be a new chapter in there lives, what will Kylie do once she knows who she wants? What will Ruby do?
All Rights Reserved
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
The vamps (kylia)
Malia Baker thought junior year would be chill-hang out with her best friend, pass chemistry, avoid drama. That is, until Kylie Cantrall, Ruby Rose Turner, and Joshua Colley show up out of nowhere. Mysterious, pale, too perfect for real life... and always together. Everyone at school calls them "the Vamps." Malia just calls them suspicious. Especially Kylie-quiet, magnetic, and suddenly interested in Malia in a way that feels... deliberate. What Malia doesn't know? Kylie, Ruby, and Josh aren't just here for school. They're on a mission: choose three humans to turn into vampires before the year ends-or disappear again. It was supposed to be simple. Pick. Befriend. Turn. No feelings. No attachments. But Malia isn't like the others. And Kylie's starting to forget the rules.Complete
you, me & nyc
malia baker has been counting down the days until senior year was over. she thought graduation meant she'd never have to deal with kylie cantrall again - loud, cocky, impossible kylie, who somehow always knew how to get under her skin. but the universe (or at least their school's senior trip) had other plans. now malia's stuck sharing a bus, a room, and way too much time with the girl she's spent years trying to forget. but something about this trip feels... different. kylie still drives her crazy, sure - but in a way that's harder to walk away from this time. and the longer they're stuck together in the city that never sleeps, the harder it is to remember why she hated her in the first place.Complete
OFFSIDE
Kylie and Malia have always been inseparable - co-captains of their high school soccer team, star players, and best friends since forever. Their connection on the field is effortless. Off the field? A little more complicated. When Malia starts dating a guy - charming, athletic, and jealous - Kylie tries to be supportive. But something inside her shifts. The more time Malia spends with him, the more distant she feels. And the more Kylie starts to realize her feelings for Malia might go deeper than friendship. Now, stuck between a secret love, a complicated friendship, and a tense season on the field, Kylie has to decide: does she keep her heart hidden - or risk everything?Complete
out of bounds
ENEMIES TO LOVERSSSSS Kylie's always been the untouchable queen of her high school-confident, chaotic, and completely in control. But behind the sharp comebacks and reckless decisions is a girl who's been raising her little brother while their dad disappears on endless "business trips." Enter Malia: quiet, grounded, and somehow the only person who can make Kylie feel safe. What started as rivalry turned into friendship, and now it's something deeper-something they're not quite ready to name. Between sneaking kisses, surprise birthday parties, late-night drives, and healing old family wounds, Kylie and Malia are learning what it means to let someone in. But with rumors, unresolved feelings, and Kylie's estranged mom suddenly back in the picture, things get messy fast. This isn't just a love story-it's about found family, messy healing, and two girls falling for each other in the middle of everything falling apart.
Back to You: Book 1
malias mom is a traveling nurse. back in the summer before her junior year of high school malia had to move to canada becauee of her moms job. this caused kylie and malia to break up after malia moved. this year (senior year) malia is unexpectedly moving back to LA and returning to school with her friends and kylie. they havent seen or talked to each other in a year... until NOW! or not we'll seeComplete
The Way You Looked at Me Then- Kylia
Malia Baker has always been fiercely loyal, especially to her older sister, Momona. When Kylie Cantrall shattered Momona's heart two years ago, Malia swore she'd never forgive her. She told herself she hated Kylie for the tears she caused, for the way she left, and for how she made herself unforgettable. But life has a cruel sense of irony. Now 20, Malia transfers to a new university, only to find Kylie there, cool, aloof, and still as maddeningly magnetic as ever. The more Malia tries to avoid her, the more their paths cross in group projects, mutual friends, and late-night campus hangouts. As Malia uncovers the truth behind Kylie and Momona's breakup, her hate begins to blur into something she refuses to name. Because what if Kylie never wanted to hurt her sister?Complete
Eventually (kylia)
Kylie's always been the kind of girl who falls too fast and feels too deeply, though ever since a brutal breakup left her traumatized, she's never been the same. Before the breakup, she was all in, a hopeless romantic, loyal to a fault, and crazy in love. She gave everything to someone who promised forever, only to be betrayed. It felt like being kissed on the forehead while a knife was sliding between her ribs. Tender, calculated, and devastatingly personal. The pain wasn't just emotional; it was identity-shattering. This new Kylie's known for two things: wild nights and a heart locked behind sarcasm and tequila. Feelings? Overrated. But everything changes the night her best friend throws a college party and she meets Malia. Malia's a quiet, soft-spoken, clever girl with curly brown hair and eyes that seem to ask all the right questions. That night, they hit it off right away. Maybe it was their chemistry, or maybe it was just the tequila. Though the day after the party goes a bit differently. Kylie does what she always does: flirts, charms, and makes her move. But Malia isn't like the others. She turns Kylie down, gently but firmly, explaining she's not interested in meaningless flings. She wants something real. And the for first time in years, Kylie finds herself wanting to slow down, to dig deeper, and maybe, revert to the old, lover-girl version of herself, or possibly, be the kind of person someone like Malia could fall for. Little does she know, love really does make you crazy. TW: mature language, alcohol, substance abuse, murder, and some other sensitive subjects.Complete
Love You Like a Vampire Would. (SMUT/18+)
2 girls, 2 different lives, fated to meet. Dani lives a normal life with her dad but hides a dark secret. A condition with no name, no cure, that forces her to feast on the blood of other living creatures. Olivia also lives a normal life with her mom and sister. She struggles with a rare type of leukemia that causes an overproduction of blood cells, causing her to have to give blood regularly to maintain a healthy life. They encounter each other randomly one night, drawn to each other by some unseen force. As if they were meant to be together. But can a human and a vampire really work together? Can Dani cope with her condition? Will Olivia survive hers? Only time will tell.
Malia Baker thought junior year would be chill-hang out with her best friend, pass chemistry, avoid drama. That is, until Kylie Cantrall, Ruby Rose Turner, and Joshua Colley show up out of nowhere. Mysterious, pale, too perfect for real life... and always together. Everyone at school calls them "the Vamps." Malia just calls them suspicious. Especially Kylie-quiet, magnetic, and suddenly interested in Malia in a way that feels... deliberate. What Malia doesn't know? Kylie, Ruby, and Josh aren't just here for school. They're on a mission: choose three humans to turn into vampires before the year ends-or disappear again. It was supposed to be simple. Pick. Befriend. Turn. No feelings. No attachments. But Malia isn't like the others. And Kylie's starting to forget the rules.
More detailsContent Guidelines