Unrequited

Reads 706
Votes 28
Parts 7

Ongoing2h 20m

Last published Thu, May 15, 2025

bensler benson chrismeloni elliot elliotstabler

When a dangerous perpetrator fixates on Lieutenant Olivia Benson, the NYPD brings in consultant Elliot Stabler, a former Marine turned private investigator, to assist on the case. Known for his swagger and charm, Elliot is warned that Olivia's reputation as a hard-nosed, brilliant workaholic means she won't be easily impressed-or amused by his usual tactics. AU

#38

chrismeloni

Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.

You and I [A Bensler Fanfiction]
They were high school sweethearts, but broke up when he wanted to pursue his dreams. Yet every year they grew up without each other and started families of their own, they never forgot each other.
Complete
Love from Benson and Stabler [ A Bensler Fan Fic]
On the surface all is calm, and inside a storm brews. He'd returned only to become a ghost. Could her letter reel him in and make him realise it's always been her, or will it destroy their worlds to try something that was once forbidden?
Complete
The Affair
Elliot and Olivia have been partners for over ten years. Elliot has a secret not even he knows. When a case brings certain things to light, will Elliot and Olivia be okay? My first Bensler fan fiction. I'm mostly a Harry Potter writer. Not even that great at writing descriptions.
Complete
Forever Changed
Summary: Olivia continues to support Elliot and his children in the loss of their mother a year on from her death. When she continues to deny her feelings for Elliot, Olivia Benson begins a relationship with an old friend, and this causes Elliot to realise a few things. Set a year post SVU 22x09. Mentions of William Lewis in chapters (6-9) when a case puts Olivia in danger and forces OC and SVU to work together. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Ps~ this is not my fic I want to give a big shout out to ThatstheT on Archive of your own, She wrote this amazing fanfic and I hope it's okay if I share your amazing work on here.
Complete
Suds In The Bucket [A Bensler Fan Fic]
At 18, they left Manhattan to be together. Between Olivia's parents disapproving of Elliot and them finding them doing the deed in a treehouse, Olivia and Elliot would never be together if they stayed put. So they made a plan and left. Now, ten years later Olivia returns to see if her parents want to be apart of the life she made with Elliot. If they wanted to meet their grandsons. But Serena and Frank's arms aren't as open as expected.
Complete
I Need Saving [A Bensler FanFic- Editing]
Olivia leaves after Kathy and her got into the car accident, and Olivia saved her life, but her demons were real. But when Olivia comes back, she carries a dark secret, and somethings that will be a little more surprising. Will Elliot save her like his has every time before? Or will he abandon her like the man who had caused her to run back?
Complete
Semper Fi
Set during current time frame. Elliot and Olivia haven't seen each other since his abrupt resignation over four years ago. A twist of fate with a current case brings them back in each other's lives and everything they have been holding back for years is brought back to the surface. What will happen when they confront their feelings for each other?
Complete
Forever Hold Your Peace
Olivia is planning a wedding to Trevor Langan and Elliot's can't seem to get rid of some lingering feelings, will he stop the wedding? Or will he let Olivia marry another man?
Complete
Love, Your Baby Girl (SVU Fanfic)
In this story, Olivia is the product of rape still, but her mother ended up loving her and cherishing her. But when Serena is raped again, she can't find a way to cope. She now sees Olivia as a burden and starts abusing Olivia. When the SVU finds out, she's taken to the precinct where she meets one detective's son. His name? Elliot Stabler. Even though they shouldn't, they grow close to each other. ~BENSLER~
Complete
A Dance With the Devil.
Olivia Benson is a 1st-grade Detective for the 16th precinct, which is the Special Victims Unit. It takes one day, one case for SVU to get the biggest demented sociopath ever. Now in the sights of the mystery park flasher who has no identity. What's going to happen when the beloved detective is targeted? What if Elliot left but kept in contact? After a very traumatic ordeal, how will the relationship move forward?
Complete

You and I [A Bensler Fanfiction]

They were high school sweethearts, but broke up when he wanted to pursue his dreams. Yet every year they grew up without each other and started families of their own, they never forgot each other.

More details

Content Guidelines

Unrequited

You may also like

You and I [A Bensler Fanfiction]

Love from Benson and Stabler [ A Bensler Fan Fic]

The Affair

Forever Changed

Suds In The Bucket [A Bensler Fan Fic]

I Need Saving [A Bensler FanFic- Editing]

Semper Fi

Forever Hold Your Peace

Love, Your Baby Girl (SVU Fanfic)

A Dance With the Devil.