Unfinished Business (CM Punk X Reader)

In 2013, a 20-year-old Y/N found herself tangled in a whirlwind connection with CM Punk. Their relationship wasn't conventional-it was built on teasing, playful bickering, and stolen moments in the chaos of WWE. For weeks, they danced around their attraction until they finally gave in, hooking up on and off behind the scenes. It wasn't love, or at least, that's what they both told themselves. But then, Punk started talking about leaving WWE. Y/N didn't want to hear it. She tried to talk him out of it, begged him to stay-not just for WWE, but for her. "Don't leave me," she told him. But in the end, he left anyway. She was heartbroken. Lost. Angry. And in the wake of Punk's departure, she found comfort in Drew McIntyre. What started as friendship turned into something deeper-Drew was there when she needed him, offering support in ways Punk never had. Over the next ten years, Drew became her safe place, her rock. And though she never put a label on it, a part of her knew she had feelings for him. Then, out of nowhere, Punk came back. He walked in like nothing had changed, like the years hadn't passed, like he could just pick up where they left off. And damn it-her feelings for him were still there. The chemistry, the history, the unresolved tension-it all came rushing back. But something was different this time. Drew wasn't just her safe place anymore. He was her home. And when he finally laid his emotions bare, told her how much he loved her, how much he had always loved her, Y/N felt something shift inside her. How had she not seen it before? Now, she's caught between the past and the present. Between the man who left her behind and the man who stood by her through everything. But when all is said and done, CM Punk is endgame. Because despite everything-despite Drew's love, despite the comfort and stability, her heart has always belonged to Punk.