Easy Come, Easy Go
- Reads 93
- Votes 0
- Parts 7
MatureOngoing1h 22m
Last published Wed, Sep 17, 2025
A young man named Jay Merrick is forced to navigate a double life as a paperboy and an underground bartender. Strange things start happening after a strange man delivers an ominous message. Murders, disappearances, coincidences..
And it all leads back to one man.
Warning! Contains:
Period accurate racism, homophobia, and sexism.
Murder.
Abuse.
Cover art by Antlergrave on Insta and Tumblr
All Rights Reserved
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
The Girl in the Attic | Creepypasta x Reader
Abandoned by your parents as a child, you have lived the last nine years of your life in solitude, fending for yourself. In an attempt to protect yourself, you did something irreversible that put you right in Slenderman's path. This is the official rewrite of my most popular fanfiction, Living With the Creepypastas.
Slender Man Vs Jeff The Killer : Origins of StitchFace
What once was a normal boy is left a mindless killing machine who has both nothing to live for and nothing to lose. A town long terrorised before by a strange tall man in a dark suit who most believe to be the product of mindless tales told to scare children. As a series of homicides and mysterious disappearances lead to a group of twelve college students all rilled up and wanting answers, but finding only horrible death. This endless war on untold enemies sets the stage for two of the most ruthless and famous creepypastas to go head to head in the struggle for both ego and bloodlust. Please read the origins and back stories on both of the icons in this story before reading so that you can get the best experience possible. Enjoy :)Complete
What Is Pain? ~Jeff The Killer Fanfic~
This story is about a young girl who's father died when she was still at a young age and her mother abuses her. One night she gets a visit from a person who is destined to kill her, but instead, falls in love with her. THIS STORY IS FOR ENTERTAINMENT PURPOSES ONLY! PLEASE DO NOT COPY OR TRY ANYTHING IN THIS STORY! THIS STORY CAN ALSO BE VERY GRAPHIC. I WARNED YOU.Complete
acting skills (yandere masky x reader x yandere hoodie)
What time is it?Complete
The Static In Your Eyes - Tim Wright x Reader
A reader insert, gender neutral, involving the character Tim from Marble Hornets. The contents in this story will very loosely follow the entries of the series. That being said, there will most likely be spoilers and events that did not canonically happen. The story, from the perspective of the reader, who was involved in Alex Kralie's movie making, is pulled into a spiral of dark events by none other than Jay. The reader encounters Tim, who eventually joins Jay and The Reader to record their horror themed journey to figure out the mysteries of The Operator, Alex, and the tapes. Slow Burn Story
Pose for the Encyclopedia (Creepypasta fanfic)
Another creepy pasta story by 666Underworld666, edited by darkangel6021 (cover created by darkangel6021) This one takes place BEFORE Slenderman Household.Complete
Everything is Fine - Reader x Tim Wright
(Y/n) is concerned one night after her co-worker Tim goes missing. After she decides to visit his home her life takes an interesting turn. Will it be for the better or the worse? - This story takes place after the events of Entry #61 and contains spoilers for the entirety of Marble Hornets. Cover Art Credit - @Nala_felComplete
Marble Hornets Your POV
For these past few years Y/N (You) struggles with a certain thing and person following them. It was quiet for a while. But than on one day, it all starts to go wrong again. That day you met people who are willing to help you solve the problem that is going on. Looks like they have been going though the same things as you are. I made this story myself. This is a your own POV story. The POV is for all genders. In the story you will find the They/Them pronounce. Also Y/N will be in there, this means Your/Name. (Disclaimer: There are reverences of different slenderverses used in here. Like Marble Hornets, Tribe Twelve and Everymanhybrid. Just to make the story different yet with the same intentions of the series.) Have fun reading:)
⨂ ~ * M a r b l e H o r n e t s O n e s h o t s * ~ ⨂
This story is a bunch of random oneshots ranging from one AU to the next. I will do any ships, but I am strictly against X Readers. If you only like X Reader stories, this isn't for you. So settle down with a brain full of the whole series, and all of Marble Hornets explained. ⨂⨂⨂⨂⨂⨂⨂⨂⨂⨂⨂⨂⨂⨂⨂⨂⨂⨂⨂⨂⨂⨂⨂Complete
Unknown Destination (A Marble Hornets Story)Part 1
(AU Directly following Entry #79) Jay Merrick has spent the past few years of his life with ever increasing danger. One day, it finally caught up with him. However, due to a mysterious being known as "Firebrand", he got what do many before craved: A second chance. But life came with conditions that will take him and his new friends into a danger unlike any they've encountered before on a strange quest that takes him further and further from Tim Wright, the only person he can trust.Complete
Abandoned by your parents as a child, you have lived the last nine years of your life in solitude, fending for yourself. In an attempt to protect yourself, you did something irreversible that put you right in Slenderman's path. This is the official rewrite of my most popular fanfiction, Living With the Creepypastas.
More detailsContent Guidelines