Shadows After Showtime || An SMG4 Circus AU
- Reads 214
- Votes 11
- Parts 2
Ongoing18m
Last published Wed, Nov 12, 2025
A broken promise. A sunken castle. A short-lived, 'Friendship'.
If you gave Three the option to go back in time to fix one of his biggest mistakes, he would choose to save Four. But it was too late for that. His mistake was motivated by fear when seeing the strange astral figure linger over his friend's body. Now, thrown into a spiraling depression caused by guilt, self-hatred, and the slow abandonment of his friends, he feels that the only thing he can do is visit the place where it all went down. Unbeknownst to him, he would be thrown into a colourful hell of enslaved labor, covered up by multicoloured costumes. But hiding within? A possible second chance of the life he ever so desired. If only it were that easy...
All Rights Reserved
#30
puzzlevision
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
It's The Great Pumpkin SMG4 (Marware Halloween Special)
It's halloween and the crew is glad to finally celebrate the spooky season with some trick or treating except Mr Puzzles still feels like the odd one out, considering what he had done in WOTFI 2024. After hearing that Mario isn't going trick or treating and is just going to sit in the pumpkin patch, waiting for this supposed "Great Pumpkin" he joins the Italian for some late night bonding. Based on the classic Halloween movie: It's The Great Pumpkin Charlie Brown by Charles M Schulz I will be changing this story up a little and include some Smg34 moments as well. I added more Marware scenes since Sally and Linus don't get a lot of screen time. I hope this story reminds you of your childhood nostalgia as it did for me.Complete![[OLD] We're Friends Now, Aren't We? (SMG34)](https://img.wattpad.com/cover/352990555-256-k890582.jpg)
[OLD] We're Friends Now, Aren't We? (SMG34)
(Takes place after the IGBP movie) ''Really? You'd do that for me?'' ''Eh, sure. Whatever. I kinda own that Starbucks, you know.'' ''I...I don't know what to say! Thank you so much, Three...'' ''Heh. We're friends now, aren't we? Even I wouldn't want to see you on the streets, Four.'' ~~~ After the IGBP movie, the SMG4 crew is left with a gaping demonic pit where the castle once stood, but ignoring Princess Peach, everyone still has a place to stay. Except Four, of course. SMG4 had originally planned to stay with Mario, but at the last minute he backed out of the offer, not wanting to impose on Luigi. Back to square one, it seemed... until his old rival decided to help him out, just this once. For some weird reason. (Cover art by me) (Also this'll probably be really short but thanks for reading anyway if you do) (Ranked #1 in #SMG34 as of 7/10/23) (Ranked #1 in #SMG4 as of 2/15/24)Complete
Haunted (A smg34 fanfiction)
From nightmares to self-hatred, smg4 seems to have problems with his self-esteem. Lucky for him, he has smg3 but will things end well? (Might change up the description and tags rahhh) ___ First time writing about these two and first time writing from taking a big break so go easy on meComplete![SMG4 in Schmicago [A Marware and SMG34 Fic]](https://img.wattpad.com/cover/376895040-256-k610290.jpg)
SMG4 in Schmicago [A Marware and SMG34 Fic]
After escaping Schmigadoon, SMG4 and SMG3 return to find answers, alongside Mario and unknowingly pursued by Mr. Puzzles. But after a mysterious fog engulfs the four of them, they find themselves trapped in a gritty musical city in the 1920's called Schmicago. Their only hopes of escape? Well, Mr. Puzzles and Mario need to find true love. SMG4 and SMG3 need to make a "happy end," whatever that is. But after a dead body turns up... things start to look to be a lot more difficult than they originally thought. Will they be able to make it out of this strange musical city before they too become victims of a mass murderer?Complete
SMG4: Vengeance
This is a sequel to SMG4: Doomsday The SMG4 Crew has been at rest since the whole incident with Dante six months ago and believe they are finally at peace. But... a new villain seeks his revenge when he learns his old friend is dead... There is a heavy amount of MxM in this story. So caution is advised if you don't like this ship. You've been warned. The cover is not mine. It's just thrown together stuff from the web. I hope you enjoy. :)
SMG4: Doomsday
This is an arc idea I came up with and decided to make into a story format. Tell me what you think. Also, this story contains a good bit of MxM. It focuses on darker and more serious premises than to be an MxM fanfic, but it does have a good bit of that ship in it. You have been warned. Also, the cover is not mine. It's just thrown together stuff from the webComplete
I Need to Save Him
( SMG4 FAN-MADE STORY ) Puzzles has escaped, and he's not alone. After the events of WOTFI 2024, the blue meme guardian, SMG4, and his crew had believed that the TV man would never return ever again. But, they had guessed wrong, and the threat of the most powerful weapon had broken him out of jail. Mr. Puzzles needed a plan to take his revenge on the people who turned his act away, who broke him and his dreams...and he knew one person that was PERFECT for the role. SMG4 doesn't watch his back, and eventually, he was taken away from his home. He came face to face with his nemesis of those two years, Mr. Puzzles. The blue meme guardian had forcefully been mind controlled and changed into the beast he was before back when that perfect video was yearning to be seen. And someone sensed that he was in trouble. SMG3 knew something was off, something was not right. His partner, his friend, he wasn't home. And he knew he needed to save him from whoever took him out of his grasp, ASAP. But it didn't come without a few consequences...Complete
The Treasure Arc (SMG34 RP story)
Join the SMG4 crew on a treasure hunt with wacky adventures! Full of comedy, romance and angst! Me and my friend wrote this together like a role-playing so be kind, it's their first time! SMG34 and a bunch of meme references! 💜💙 I wrote some characters but mostly Smg3 and Smg4 while my friend wrote Meggy and Mario! I hope you guys like it! We're planning to make more stories in the future! ✨️Complete
this day is going to be perfect - smg34
"Married? It's only been three months!" Mario protested, looking rather annoyed. Saiko agreed passively, while Tari and Luigi simply shrugged at the notion. Mario looked back up with a grumpy expression. "Why didn't they come tell us themselves?" "Good point, Red. Kinda messed up," Meggy grumbled out. "I'm sure they're simply busy with planning and all that. You know SMG4, this is exactly how he'd announce a wedding," Luigi dismissed, rolling his eyes as he stood up himself, pocketing the invitation. Everyone agreed with varying degrees of playfulness or annoyance. - Mario and the gang receive an invitation to a very special wedding. However, something is amiss and he's gotta do something about it. !!! READ THE MASQUERADE FIC !!! https://www.wattpad.com/story/339686902-the-masquerade-arc-smg34Complete
SMG4 Movie: PUZZLE-FAN-VISION
THANK YOU FOR CHOOSING TO READ... PUZZLE-FAN-VISION! 📺 WE HAVE REACHED FIVE STARS!!!!! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ TO CELEBRATE... HERE'S THE PUZZLE-FAN-VISION MOVIE!!!!! RATE THE MOVIE... FIVE STARS!!!!! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐Complete
It's halloween and the crew is glad to finally celebrate the spooky season with some trick or treating except Mr Puzzles still feels like the odd one out, considering what he had done in WOTFI 2024. After hearing that Mario isn't going trick or treating and is just going to sit in the pumpkin patch, waiting for this supposed "Great Pumpkin" he joins the Italian for some late night bonding. Based on the classic Halloween movie: It's The Great Pumpkin Charlie Brown by Charles M Schulz I will be changing this story up a little and include some Smg34 moments as well. I added more Marware scenes since Sally and Linus don't get a lot of screen time. I hope this story reminds you of your childhood nostalgia as it did for me.
More detailsContent Guidelines