Story cover for The choice is hers by Qt_Sarai
The choice is hers
Qt_Sarai
  • WpView
    Reads 17,637
  • WpVote
    Votes 709
  • WpPart
    Parts 17
  • WpHistory
    Time 4h 11m
  • WpView
    Reads 17,637
  • WpVote
    Votes 709
  • WpPart
    Parts 17
  • WpHistory
    Time 4h 11m
Qt_Sarai
Ongoing, First published May 06, 2025
Mature
comingofagedenialemotionalgaylovegaynesshiddenidentityhighschoolintersexkyliakyliekyliexmalialosangeleslovemaliamurderromancesecretsteendramateenfictionwlw
‼️READ THE DESCRIPTION. ‼️

Kylie Cantrall recently dumped her boyfriend, Malachi Barton, after walking in on him and her so called bff, Sofia Wylie. 

At the first game of the season she's looking for revenge. Kylie marches over to the rival team's captain, Malia Baker, and kisses her. As Kylie pulls away to savor the shock on her ex's face, Malia pulls her back. Kylie hears rowdy cheers from one side of the field, and boos from the other. 

But an unexpected twist makes Kylie have to choose between a fake relationship or a real one.
All Rights Reserved
comingofagedenialemotionalgaylovegaynesshiddenidentityhighschoolintersexkyliakyliekyliexmalialosangeleslovemaliamurderromancesecretsteendramateenfictionwlw
Table of contents

17 parts

Sign up to add The choice is hers to your library and receive updates
or
Content Guidelines
You may also like
The Way You Looked at Me Then- Kylia by aspxn_09
38 parts Complete Mature
Malia Baker has always been fiercely loyal, especially to her older sister, Momona. When Kylie Cantrall shattered Momona's heart two years ago, Malia swore she'd never forgive her. She told herself she hated Kylie for the tears she caused, for the way she left, and for how she made herself unforgettable. But life has a cruel sense of irony. Now 20, Malia transfers to a new university, only to find Kylie there, cool, aloof, and still as maddeningly magnetic as ever. The more Malia tries to avoid her, the more their paths cross in group projects, mutual friends, and late-night campus hangouts. As Malia uncovers the truth behind Kylie and Momona's breakup, her hate begins to blur into something she refuses to name. Because what if Kylie never wanted to hurt her sister?
Forbidden from the beginning (kylia) by 1ove1etter16
10 parts Ongoing
A story in which kylie cantrall is secretly a vampire and Malia baker is in love with her. Will Malia find out her darkest secret? Will Kylie realize the painful crush Malia has on her? (There will be mentions of blood and there might be smut!⚠️)
OFFSIDE by descendantsauthor
62 parts Complete
Kylie and Malia have always been inseparable - co-captains of their high school soccer team, star players, and best friends since forever. Their connection on the field is effortless. Off the field? A little more complicated. When Malia starts dating a guy - charming, athletic, and jealous - Kylie tries to be supportive. But something inside her shifts. The more time Malia spends with him, the more distant she feels. And the more Kylie starts to realize her feelings for Malia might go deeper than friendship. Now, stuck between a secret love, a complicated friendship, and a tense season on the field, Kylie has to decide: does she keep her heart hidden - or risk everything?
A Quiet Obsession by choni7779
66 parts Ongoing Mature
Kylie has everything-wealth, beauty, and a reputation as the most popular girl in school. On the surface, her life is perfect. But behind the designer clothes and flawless smile lies a chilling secret: she's hiding a dangerous obsession. Enter Malia-the quiet, introverted new girl who wants nothing more than to stay out of the spotlight. She's everything Kylie isn't... and everything Kylie can't stop thinking about. They hate each other. At least, that's what everyone thinks. What begins as petty insults and icy stares soon spirals into a toxic game of cat and mouse. Kylie doesn't just want to win-she wants control. Of Malia's time, her thoughts... maybe even her life. As the tension between them grows, so does the danger. And when obsession turns deadly. **Rivals. Secrets. Obsession.** This is partially based on the show "you" with a twist. G!P-kylie
Controlled Reactions. by tzotzostoriez
38 parts Ongoing Mature
In high school, chemistry isn't just for the lab. Malia Baker has her entire future mapped out-top grades, championship water polo seasons, and zero distractions. Kylie Cantrall has charm, status, and a sharp tongue that cuts deeper than most rumors about her. When a surprise science competition threatens Kylie's GPA and graduation, she's paired-against all odds-with Malia, the one girl who sees through her games. Malia wants to win. Kylie wants to coast. But neither expected their clashing worlds to spark something more dangerous than rivalry. As late-night study sessions turn to quiet confrontations and secrets slip through guarded glances, the line between hate and something else begins to blur. But with Kylie's friends warning her to stay away, and Malia's family watching her every move, both girls are forced to ask: how far will you go for someone you're not supposed to fall for? - This is a fan-fiction based on Kylie Cantrall and Malia Baker. this is not their real lives whatsoever. Kylie and Malia are full grown adults. This is just a story! The content of this fic will may cause disturbance to some viewers as it may hit sensitive topics and sexual scenes. I will always have a trigger warning before each of these chapters so everyone can be aware of they are going to read. This is an original story and i will NOT be focused on adding people the two girls know irl. A lot of the characters are fictional such as Kylie and Malia. I hope everyone enjoys this story and if you have any ideas about it feel free to dm me on TikTok or instagram!! TikTok: vspjxsq Instagram: vspjxssq Happy reading everyone! 💗
More Than Best Friends by descendantsauthor
30 parts Complete
Kylie Cantrall and Malia Baker have been inseparable for as long as they can remember. From late-night study sessions to endless inside jokes, they share everything... including hugs, cheek kisses, and a closeness that makes everyone else a little envious. But when one of them starts feeling something more than friendship, everything changes. Suddenly, the lines between love and friendship blur, and they're left wondering: is it worth risking the bond they've always relied on? Full of laughter, heartache, and tender moments, More Than Best Friends is a story about discovering that sometimes the person you've always leaned on might just be the one you're meant to love.
THE ONE NIGHT STAND by QT-DINONUGGIE
11 parts Ongoing Mature
Malia Baker, a 19 year old who just went through a break up, she tried to push everything away, but couldn't. so being the dumb teenager she is, well shes very smart but not the point, she puts all her feelings into one cage, the last shattered piece of her heart. locked it and threw it away by drinking, smoking and way more. She decided to go to a bar far from her usual area. she drank until all she could say was "more" as in more damn shots. anyways. until she meets this black haired stunning woman....
Closer Than I Wanted by rustyzonked
109 parts Complete Mature
Two girls. One school. Worlds apart. Kylie Cantrall is the kind of girl everyone notices - effortlessly popular, untouchable, and always in control. Malia Baker is the new girl, quiet, sharp, and wrapped in an aura of mystery. When their paths collide, sparks fly - but not in the way either of them expects. In a slow-burn story of rivalry, tension, and unexpected connections, they'll navigate high school, personal boundaries, and the unexpected ways someone can challenge your world. @greyformarie you asked a while ago but you have recieved now
Between Worlds by Qt_Sarai
73 parts Complete Mature
Kylie has always lived in the shadows of her own secret, keeping her intersex identity hidden from everyone except Ruby, her fiercely loyal best friend. When Malia enters her life, sparks fly in ways Kylie never expected, but fear and self-doubt hold her back. Despite her attempts to suppress her growing feelings, her body and heart seem to have other plans. As the two navigate the delicate line between strangers and lovers, Kylie must decide whether to let Malia into her world or keep her at arm's length forever.
Anyone but you. by thiagothesword
26 parts Ongoing Mature
Kylie Cantrall and Malia Baker used to date back in high school. However, Something ugly happened between the lovebirds, causing both of them to never wish to speak to each other again. Therefore, when they both end up at the same university....in the same dorm...things get a bit out of hand. (Did someone say lovers to enemies to lovers?) -warning signs shown when smut included-
You may also like
Slide 1 of 10
The Way You Looked at Me Then- Kylia cover
Forbidden from the beginning (kylia) cover
OFFSIDE cover
A Quiet Obsession cover
Controlled Reactions. cover
More Than Best Friends cover
THE ONE NIGHT STAND cover
Closer Than I Wanted cover
Between Worlds cover
Anyone but you. cover

The Way You Looked at Me Then- Kylia

38 parts Complete Mature

Malia Baker has always been fiercely loyal, especially to her older sister, Momona. When Kylie Cantrall shattered Momona's heart two years ago, Malia swore she'd never forgive her. She told herself she hated Kylie for the tears she caused, for the way she left, and for how she made herself unforgettable. But life has a cruel sense of irony. Now 20, Malia transfers to a new university, only to find Kylie there, cool, aloof, and still as maddeningly magnetic as ever. The more Malia tries to avoid her, the more their paths cross in group projects, mutual friends, and late-night campus hangouts. As Malia uncovers the truth behind Kylie and Momona's breakup, her hate begins to blur into something she refuses to name. Because what if Kylie never wanted to hurt her sister?

More details