Beneath The Smile
- Reads 78
- Votes 0
- Parts 11
Ongoing18m
Last published Mon, Jun 16, 2025
You never expected your quiet nights to be shattered by a killer's stare-or drawn in by his twisted smile. But when Jeff the Killer steps out of the shadows and into your life, you find yourself pulled into a dangerous dance of curiosity, fear, and something neither of you can explain. You're not afraid of the dark... but maybe you should be.
All Rights Reserved
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
Smile (Jeff the killer X Reader)
A love story between two twisted hearts. As your world falls apart you meet the famous serial killer Jeff. What will happen? *Warning: contains violence and lemon*Complete
Fatal Insanity (Jeff The Killer X Reader)
You and Jeff had been best friends and neighbors since you were both little and basically grew up together, until you almost turned thirteen and moved away to a new town. Crying inside knowing you would never see him again, but that all changed a year later, when you had found out that him and his family were moving into the same town and neighborhood as you. Overall, you were happy that you could hang out with your best friend again, like old times. Though, you never expected to have feelings for him since he was your best friend, but one thing that took a turn for the worst, and the one thing that never left you the same, was that your best friend..... ~turned into a killer~Complete
The one that saved me (Jeff the killer x reader)
You the reader going on a quest to find out who you truly are. meeting Jeff the killer and the creepypasta family, would you want to go back to your original home or would you want to stay. many secrects are revealed as you continue to stay longer, do you belive in the truth or will the truth haunt you. looking at this now, this took me a whole year to make, comments would be greatly appreciatedComplete
Jeff the Killer
Jeff the Killer Origin story !FICTION! !CREEPYPASTA STORY! !NOT ORIGINAL STORY!Complete
"To Kill For" - Jeff the Mafia Killer x Reader
Your normal, boring life takes a turn when you get kidnapped by... JEFF THE KILLER?! Will you uncover the truths behind your connections with the local mafia in order to escape... or will you be trapped in your infatuation with Jeff the Mafia Killer forever?Complete
Can You Feel My Heart {Reboot}
With your parents pushing you out of the door, getting you ready for the real world, you are in for a surprise. Just a few months after college and a house to call your own, you meet with a murderous psychopath who has only one objective....Or does he? When the infamous Jeff The Killer breaks into your home, he finds himself unable to kill you. The journey is rough but he and yourself, find a liking towards each other. What will happen when Jeff's past, catches up with him? When you thought that you were away from danger, you have no idea what's coming for you. Jeff just has one question for you and you only: Can you feel my heart, love?Complete
In Love with a Killer: 1
♡ If Jeff the Killer is your favorite Creepypasta, then this book is for you! ♡ Also, please don't judge a book by its cover and the title ._. You can request some scenarios too!!! Have a boo-tiful day ! ❤️Complete
Jeff the killer x reader
as normal i make it up as i go *shrugs* TW blood, violence Jeff is a psychopath, he will be treated as such. It will be similar to joker and harly quinn sort of (kinda)Complete
A love story between two twisted hearts. As your world falls apart you meet the famous serial killer Jeff. What will happen? *Warning: contains violence and lemon*
More detailsContent Guidelines