Between Us Three // Lottie Matthews & Natalie Scatorccio
- Reads 33,506
- Votes 1,488
- Parts 19
You've moved around your whole life. New towns, new schools, new people. You stopped getting attached a long time ago. Wiskayok was just supposed to be just another stop: keep your head down, focus on graduating and disappear like you always do.
But that plan starts to fall apart the moment you catch the attention of two very different girls: one quiet and magnetic and the other with sharp edges and soft warnings like a dare you're not sure you should take.
You quickly realize, staying invisible was never going to last.
-----
PAIRINGS:
• Lottie Matthews x You x Natalie Scatorccio
• Minor mentions of Taivan
• Minor mentions of... other pairings (wink wink)
WARNINGS:
• G!P Reader
• Explicit Language
• Sexual Content (smut)
-----
Story can be found on AO3. I usually update on there first. :)
All Rights Reserved
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
Blaine's Opportunity
TRIGGER WARNING ⚠️ MENTIONS OF Rape, family abuse and suicidal thoughts. Do not read if this may trigger you. The story isn't all depressing but there are certain family situations brought up. It's a good read, enjoy. "It's ok, Blaine. I promise." I whispered into her ear. Her strong arms wrapped me so tightly. I felt so warm and safe... it's weird how calm everything felt in this moment. I hear her sniffle. "I... don't wanna go back." She whispered. I rubbed her back. "You don't have to if you don't want to I promise. You can stay as long as you want." I whispered back. ------ Blaine Jarome was known for the attitude and anger issues. She was considered a problem child in her school, aggressive at work and in and out the hospital for injuries she never explained how she got. She only had two friends who always worried about her and she lived with two drug addicted foster parents that bought drugs from her. She's nineteen trying to finish her second last year of high school. No one dared to even intervene when she was mad... but the new girl? Well let's just say a big heart goes a long way. Sara gives Blaine an opportunity to do better and try harder. She tries to help her see her potential and see that she is great. The only thing is, will Blaine except the opportunity she's been given.Complete
She's Good at Math (GxG) ✔
(GirlxGirl) "'You're so pretty, Casey.' Her hand stops moving along my arm, and I raise my gaze to meet hers. Her eyes are darker than usual, and her expression is intense. The dim lamp lighting illuminates the structure of her face, making her look even more intimidating than she already is. 'What?' I breathe. 'I really like you.'" ----- Casey Winters is the star of the soccer team at her school. She's a gifted player, and her talents have led her team to championships. Her one weakness? School. Casey manages to get by in her other subjects with the help of her friends and online videos, but math is a struggle, and she has given up. But when Hazel offers to tutor her, everything changes. Math becomes easy for Casey, but things are still difficult; for other reasons. ----- Highest Rankings: #1 in sliceoflife (out of 45.2K stories) #1 in gayaf (out of 27.8K stories) #1 in oblivion (out of 1.62K stories) #3 in soccer (out of 16.3K stories) #3 in sports (out of 25.6K stories) #5 in gxglesbianlgbt (out of 7.37K stories) #4 in nonbinary (out of 13K stories) #9 in wlw (out of 52.4K stories) #11 in bisexual (out of 47.6K stories) #12 in insecurity (out of 5.74K stories) #15 in lesbian (out of 150K stories) #lgbtqromance #highschool #teenfictionComplete
Her or the Hunger
lottie matthews x female reader x natalie scatorccio Y/N always kept to the sidelines. As the co-equipment manager for the Yellowjackets, she was the quiet one, the helper, the one who made sure everyone had what they needed-on and off the field. Including her feelings for two girls she never thought would notice her: Lottie Matthews, the dreamy, rich girl with a god-complex in the making, and Natalie Scatorccio, all edge, eyeliner, and bruised knuckles. She had been crushing on both of them since forever. Then the crash happened. Now they're stuck in the wilderness for nineteen months. Starving, unraveling, doing whatever it takes to survive. Lottie becomes a leader of something that's starting to feel like a cult. Natalie's falling apart. And Y/N? She's stuck in the middle. Of their madness. Of their rivalry. Of her feelings. And the worst part? She might still be in love with both of them. Love was complicated enough before they started eating people. Warning(s): you know how Yellowjacket goes, don't be surprised if shit gets crazy 7.14.25 - ranked #1 in "lottiematthews" 8.05.25 ranked #12 in "nataliescatorccio" 9.18.25 - ranked #2 in "yellowjacketsfanfic"
The Sidelines of Love (Intersex - GxG)
Looking from the sidelines watching cheerleaders getting tossed in the air, footballs being thrown, people getting tackled, people shouting and yelling, and coaches tossing their clipboards in the grass. But, I only see you. With your long curly hair, your siren amber eyes, your alluring smile, your laugh. You're popular, the head cheerleader, and you're dating the captain of the football team, and I'm just someone in the background on the sidelines.... a mascot. °☆☆° P.S- I love to read y'alls comments! :3☺️ #2 on Cheerleader - July 6th, 2025 #4 on gxg- September 7th, 2025 #6 on intersex- September 3rd, 2025 #1 on angstwithhappyending- July 7th, 2025 #7 on popular- July 24th, 2025 #1on teens- January 21th, 2026 #1 on awkward- August 9th, 2025 #2 on wlw- August 7th, 2025 #2 on slowburn- August 23th, 2025Complete
The Mentally Ill // N.S. & C.M.
Discontinued Lottie x Lennon - friends w/ benefits Nat x Lennon - frenemies to lovers NatxLen End Game "Hey, Lenny!" "I told you to stop calling me that." ─── ･ ｡ﾟ☆: *.☽ .* :☆ﾟ. ─── "Yeah, Trav. Be a good boy and listen to Coach." I joke quietly. "Yeah, be a good little girl and shoot the gun for Coach." Travis whispers behind me. ─── ･ ｡ﾟ☆: *.☽ .* :☆ﾟ. ─── "Nat." I say, stopping her from following him. "Wow. What happened to blondie?" She jokes. 1k - 7/15/23 2k - 7/27/23 Started: 7/5/23 Ended: tbdComplete
Unintended Consequences
"You just have no idea." His voice was thick with restraint. "W-what," I breathed. His gaze flicked to my lips as his thumb stroked again. The calloused pad against my soft flesh sent goosebumps down my arms. His once warm eyes were dark as they lifted and bared into my soul. "What you do to... men." His husky whisper weakened my knees. I almost fell but his other hand settled on my hip, pulling me closer to him. "What you do to me," he added on a breath. The hand on my jaw shifted. His fingers left trails of tingles as he slipped them back slowly, under my earlobe and into my curls. *************************************************** As a young girl, Charlotte Avery's favourite pass time was daydreaming about her Prince Charming: Archer Johnson. She never stopped to consider that Archer was her brother's best friend.. Or that he always appeared severely creeped out by her attention. On her 16th birthday, Charlotte received a harsh reality check. Realizing just how embarrassing she had been acting, she swore to never make a fool of herself in front of Archer again. The problem? She is about to head to college and unfortunately it's the same school where Archer is currently the star quarterback. Follow Charlotte during her first year at USC as she juggles new experiences, social anxiety, family drama back home, and avoiding Archer. These are the unintended consequences of an embarrassing childhood crush. *************************************************** Top Ranks: #1 - Hot #1 - Collegeromance #1 - Brothersbestfriend #1 - Football #1 - Brooding #1 - Slowburn #1 - Quarterback #1 - Athlete #2 - Newadult #2 - Player #5 - Badboy #73 - Romance ***************************************************Complete
American teenager
"Say what you want, but say it like you mean it, with your fists for once" When the plane went down, they were just girls. By the time they were found, they were something else entirely. Ziggy never meant to fall in love in the wilderness, least of all with Natalie - reckless, magnetic, and just as broken as she was. But survival carves strange paths through the heart. Decades later, Ziggy is a single mother, haunted by what happened out there and what it cost them all. When a postcard brings back old memories and old friends, the past begins to unravel - one secret at a time. Yellowjackets fanfic Natalie ScatorccioXfemale Oc S1-??![Lesson Learned : UNIVERSITY LIFE [COMPLETED]](https://img.wattpad.com/cover/230120646-256-k121136.jpg)
Lesson Learned : UNIVERSITY LIFE [COMPLETED]
This is the story of Natalie Johnson in her University life. She barely enough experience with love, opposite gender, and physical interaction between man and woman. But she will get experience and lesson learned in her new stage of life. The harsh and bitter truth of three of it. The sweet and love of three of it And new bestfriends that she never thought she will have it. ------------ The night cold breeze swept through me when I stepped outside his apartment building. I walked on the pathway with difficulty due to the shoes that I wore. I was still sniffling, tears trailed down on my cheek. I hugged myself to make myself warm due to the cold wind in the middle of the night. My eyes wandered looking for taxi, but it was hopeless because it was already midnight. I walked in quick pace avoiding group of people who was staring at me due to my appearance and the dress that I wore. Please. Please don't come near me. Please I heard footsteps behind me. I turned my head to see it and there were group of men behind me, from the dim light of streetlamp I could see their smirk. My heart started beating faster in panic of their intention. I quickened my pace and continued to walk under the lamp. Please. Please. I chanted quietly. The footsteps became faster and I panicked. I ran while stumbling avoiding gravel and pebble stone. Please. Please. Someone.Complete
TRIGGER WARNING ⚠️ MENTIONS OF Rape, family abuse and suicidal thoughts. Do not read if this may trigger you. The story isn't all depressing but there are certain family situations brought up. It's a good read, enjoy. "It's ok, Blaine. I promise." I whispered into her ear. Her strong arms wrapped me so tightly. I felt so warm and safe... it's weird how calm everything felt in this moment. I hear her sniffle. "I... don't wanna go back." She whispered. I rubbed her back. "You don't have to if you don't want to I promise. You can stay as long as you want." I whispered back. ------ Blaine Jarome was known for the attitude and anger issues. She was considered a problem child in her school, aggressive at work and in and out the hospital for injuries she never explained how she got. She only had two friends who always worried about her and she lived with two drug addicted foster parents that bought drugs from her. She's nineteen trying to finish her second last year of high school. No one dared to even intervene when she was mad... but the new girl? Well let's just say a big heart goes a long way. Sara gives Blaine an opportunity to do better and try harder. She tries to help her see her potential and see that she is great. The only thing is, will Blaine except the opportunity she's been given.
More detailsContent Guidelines