Her or the Hunger

lottie matthews x female reader x natalie scatorccio

Y/N always kept to the sidelines. As the co-equipment manager for the Yellowjackets, she was the quiet one, the helper, the one who made sure everyone had what they needed-on and off the field. Including her feelings for two girls she never thought would notice her: Lottie Matthews, the dreamy, rich girl with a god-complex in the making, and Natalie Scatorccio, all edge, eyeliner, and bruised knuckles.

She had been crushing on both of them since forever.
Then the crash happened.

Now they're stuck in the wilderness for nineteen months. Starving, unraveling, doing whatever it takes to survive. Lottie becomes a leader of something that's starting to feel like a cult. Natalie's falling apart. And Y/N? She's stuck in the middle. Of their madness. Of their rivalry. Of her feelings.

And the worst part? She might still be in love with both of them.

Love was complicated enough before they started eating people.

Warning(s): you know how Yellowjacket goes, don't be surprised if shit gets crazy

7.14.25 - ranked #1 in "lottiematthews"
8.05.25 ranked #12 in "nataliescatorccio"
9.18.25 - ranked #2 in "yellowjacketsfanfic"