Don't Kill Me, I'm a Fan
- Reads 36
- Votes 0
- Parts 6
Ongoing32m
Last published Wed, Jun 18, 2025
Cover image generated using ChatGPT's image generation feature. Sorry if it's kinda wonky-looking.
Shiloh Warren is a weird person. Like, really weird. They've always known they were different from the people around them, and ever since their father passed away a year ago, they have no reason to pretend to be normal. When they start coming across evidence that Jeff the Killer --the main focus of their true crime obsession since they were a teenager-- may be in their town, they can't resist the opportunity to seek him out.
Jeffrey Woods is a weird person. Like, carves-up-his-own-face-every-couple-of-months-with-a-kitchen-knife weird. But after being basically kidnapped by a "fan" of his serial killing career, he's decided that he's definitely not the weirdest person around.
All Rights Reserved
#2
jeffxoc
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
![[OLD] Sympathy's Downfall (JTK x Reader)](https://img.wattpad.com/cover/253125028-256-k390886.jpg)
[OLD] Sympathy's Downfall (JTK x Reader)
You get caught up in a storm of chaos that involves a particular murderer. This murderer's behavior reminds you of a friend you lost a year ago. So tell me, can you sympathize with a serial killer? (If you know me from Quotev, hello, yes I am the original author)Complete
Have Faith In Me (Jeff the Killer Fan Fiction)
Alyssa Hughes and Jeffery Woods have always been best friends. When Jeff suddenly moves, Alyssa is left alone. A few weeks later, she finds that Jeff's whole family has died a house fire, but Jeff is just missing. 3 years later, a killer that also goes by the name Jeff begins killing everyone around but her. He usually avoids when he is asked why he is doing this. Without knowing, someone else other than Jeff is after her. Sometimes maybe people aren't who they seem to be. ***I don't own the photo used in the cover it belongs to gato-kumn on Deviant Art. Here's the link! Check out their art! It's cool! http://gato-kumn.deviantart.com/ ***Complete
Go To Sleep (Jeff the Killer Origin Write)
Some may wonder what really makes Jeff tick, or how his story came to be. Come on a ride as you read my take on the origin of this infamous creepypasta. ⚠️Warning⚠️ This story contains strong language, violence, mild mentions of abuse and death. If you are young or a sensitive reader, please keep these in mindComplete
Dark Universe: Tell me Jeff
Witness the beginning of a dark universe... Jeff the Killer, the Wisconsin killer, died. No one knows the exact details: rumors say he was unable to bear remorse and was found hanging in a barn; others that a past enemy took revenge on him; the official version given by the authorities is that Police Captain Edmund Hopkins put an end to it with a well-delivered bullet. No one mourned the death of the unbalanced Jeffrey Allen Woods, and all the blood of his story washed away with time. The scars remained, though. Year 2008. Josh and Daniel are scourged by boredom. They are victims of a deep void where the soul should be, and they try to fill it with the answer of existence. The problem is to find out what it is. Or if there is something beyond the flesh that makes them feel complete. The search will tie their lives to the legacy of the serial killer.Complete
Kill Me With Your Love (Jeff the killer story)
Skyleigh just knew about a creepypasta character, Jeff the killer. Skyleigh often appears quiet, caring and sensitive, and may be found listening attentively to someone else's ideas or concerns. She is known to be impulsive, naïve, innocent, and childish, but when necessary, she can be serious and dependable. Unlike Jeff The Killer, he is a murderer, unlike his career. He can be humorous, can be also very mentally unstable at times, but is very overprotective when it comes to Sky. Jeff meets Sky and falls in love with her. Like a love at first sight, but, obviously expected, Jeff knew he was a cold-blooded killer. What if, from all sudden, she becomes the proxy? And has to save the world from serious damage? In a snap of a finger, Sky's world is shattered, leaving her with the people that has been always by her side. (It contains mature content due to the violence, there are no sexual contents on this story.) BTW; I do not own any creepypasta character, only mines, Sky, Gretchen, etc. Thank You! ❤️❤️❤️Complete
Jeff the Killer
Jeff the Killer Origin story !FICTION! !CREEPYPASTA STORY! !NOT ORIGINAL STORY!Complete
Forget Me Not
>Part of the Creepypasta childhood memories series< Thanks to Ben, Jeff is forced to walk down memory lane. He doesn't mind but you on the other hand still hold a grudge -------------------------------------------------- You and Jeff grew up together. In fact, you were actually Jeff's first love and first kiss. Then he went insane...you know the story. What happens when you guys are reunited thanks to a certain link look alike. Will you be able to work past your grudge against the murderer with a killer smile? Will Jeff admit his feelings for you that never died? Or will he just push them aside and let them pass? He did once kill the ones he loved... What will happen in this love like war? ------------------------------ *WARNING* This story contains language that is considering strong and/or offensive. This story will also contain sexual content such as a lemon. Enjoy :)Complete
Forever Alone (Book 1 of the Misguided Killer Series)
Jeff has always felt the weight of being alone. Even with the other Creepypasta, he was the freak; the outcast. They believed he was demented and insane, and maybe he was. Did it matter? Did that insanity, something they all shared, make him undeserving of emotion? He felt. He wasn't cold and emotionless like people believed. He was a person and while he might be demented that didn't mean he couldn't feel. He could laugh, he could cry, he could feel fear. He could feel love. But never in front of others. Never. Despite the hand reaching for him through his darkness, he felt Forever Alone. Could that change? Could someone like him find someone to love?Complete
Killers Can't Love (A Jeff The Killer Romance)
Jeff is a cold-blooded, insane murderer who only feels the urge to kill. But what happens when he meets a girl that couldn't relate to him more? Now Jeff has this strange feeling in his chest that he can't seem to identify. Could it be...love? But his arch rival soon finds out about his love for the girl and uses it against him. What will happen when Jeff has to rescue the love of his life in less than 24 hours?Complete
I Found You {Jeff The Killer X Reader}
『 #8 ɪɴ ᴊᴇғғ ᴛʜᴇ ᴋɪʟʟᴇʀ 』 The blood rushed over my body, heart beating, world spinning. It was a whole new world, I never knew something so bad could feel so good. The blood on my hands, the scream of their voices- I've done it. I've killed my first victims. This was the first murder in 2 years in our small town since Jeffery.. Now I know why he did it. The feeling, eating inside you, craving to get out. I stood there, staring at the bodies. I heard the sirens- growing closer, closer... And that when I saw him. Standing in the back yards corridor. Smiling, eyes not moving from my sight. "Found You." And that's when he grabbed my hand and ran. A new adventure began; [Trigger warnings: Murder; Rape; Prostitution]Complete
You get caught up in a storm of chaos that involves a particular murderer. This murderer's behavior reminds you of a friend you lost a year ago. So tell me, can you sympathize with a serial killer? (If you know me from Quotev, hello, yes I am the original author)
More detailsContent Guidelines