Letters I Never Sent

Letters I Never Sent

  • WpView
    Reads 22
  • WpVote
    Votes 1
  • WpPart
    Parts 5
WpMetadataReadMatureOngoing55m
WpMetadataNoticeLast published Mon, Mar 9, 2026
WpInfo
Fanfic
Supernatural
A Sam Winchester/Original Character Fan Fiction A British beautician from Kansas has locked away her legacy for as long as she can remember, trying to make and keep her slice of The Apple Pie Life her own. But what happens when another living legend comes into town, threatening to burn everything she's built to ash? (Main fic takes place between Seasons 5-9)
All Rights Reserved
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
Illustration

You may also like

  • I Don't Bite [Dean Winchester x Reader]
  • •Illumoria•
  • Supernatural x Male!Reader Season 1
  • Natural Born Sinner: A Dean X Female Reader X Sam Fic
  • Home in the Hunt | Sam Winchester
  • My Demon Dearest (Dean Winchester Fan-Fic)
  • Picture Perfect - Dean Winchester x Reader
  • Sam Winchester's Daughter
  • Twisted Fate - Supernatural Fan Fiction

Y/N L/N had been a monster her entire life. Both her parents had been and had raised her on a strict diet of anything that wasn't human. Now, her parents were gone, leaving her to fend for herself. At twenty-four years old, she was already acutely aware of the danger of hunters. But when a flirtatious Winchester and his bookish younger brother step into her life, she can't help but be swept into their schemes. --- "For a hunter, you're pretty charismatic." "For a monster, you're pretty human." --- "I wasn't sure what you liked, so I got you cherry," he spoke with a hesitant chuckle. I beamed down at the little boxed pie nestled between my hands. "I like cherries," I answered and grinned up at Dean, who breathed a sigh of relief. "Yeah?" "Yeah." "Good." --- "Promise me you won't get hurt." He paused for a moment, green eyes on mine as his mind raced to catch up. "I can't promise I won't get hurt. But I can promise I won't do anything stupid." "Good enough for me." Please note that none of the chapters are edited, unless it says so at the end of the chapter in bold. That being said, I'm sure there are plenty of typos throughout the story, and I will fix them eventually. Highest rankings: #9 in 'monster' (1/12/23) #2 in 'supernatural' (7/19/21) #1 in 'spn' (6/29/22) #2 in 'dean' (09/22/23) #1 in 'winchester' (4/29/21) #1 in 'deanwinchester' (5/4/21) #4 in 'deanwinchesterxreader' (4/28/21) #1 in 'supernaturalxreader' (3/20/21) #1 in 'spnxreader' (3/22/21) #1 in 'winchesterxreader' (09/22/23)

More details
WpActionLinkContent Guidelines