The Other Gilmore Girl
- Reads 507
- Votes 7
- Parts 9
MatureOngoing43m
Last published Tue, Mar 10, 2026
Lorelai Gilmore didn't have just one daughter, but twins. She took one and left the other in the foster care system.
Susanna spent her life wondering who her family was, so after her run of bad 'families' she decides to run away to Stars Hollow. There she meets her true family which wasn't the best experience, but she also meets Jess Mariano...
All Rights Reserved
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
Mirrorball
Lorelai will always only love Lorelai. Claire has always known that. In fact she made peace with it and has been building a life that doesn't revolve around the name that brings her pain. But now her twin sister is going to Chilton and trying to be in a world that Claire built without her. Rory always thought that no matter what Claire would always only be her twin, Claire Stassi Gilmore. Claire, has always wished she was more than Rory's twin. There is too much pain that comes with being a Gilmore, Claire will make sure the world remembers her as Claire Stassi Danes.Complete
Echoes of Us (Jess Mariano x male oc)
Elliot Gilmore is Rory's twin brother, a quiet and introspective young man with an eye for art and a knack for getting lost in his sketchbooks. While Rory is the golden child with an ambitious future, Elliot often feels like the shadow in her spotlight. When Jess Mariano arrives in Stars Hollow, Elliot is drawn to the rebellious newcomer in ways he can't quite explain. As their connection deepens, Elliot is faced with the challenge of stepping out of his twin's shadows and finding his own voice - both in life and in love.Complete
the third gilmore girl || a gilmore fanfic
gracie gilmore is the second born daughter. she was born to lorelai gilmore, and her twin sister, rory who is about two minutes and thirty two seconds older, falls for jess mariano.Complete
That's Not My Name ┃Gilmore Girls
Rory Gilmore was raised to dream. Charlotte Hayden was raised to win. Two daughters, two families, two very different worlds. That's Not My Name is a story of identity, legacy, and the spaces between the lives we live and the ones we might have had.
From the Heart | Gilmore Girls
Eleanor is considered the more 'wilder' twin compared to her twin sister, Rory Gilmore. Unlike Rory, she has no plans on going to Chilton or any ivy league college, but due to her grandparents' interference, she ends up going into Chilton alongside Rory. She's not there at Chilton to makes friends or enemies, although there's one boy there that's determined to try and get under her skin... and in her heart.
Her lawyer
Hayden Richard Gilmore Rory Gilmore's older twin brother He's incredibly smart and has already finished high school and is in his last year off law school. What happens when the Mariano twins come to stars hollow and Hayden meets Harley Mariano Season 2 Oc x Oc All rights reserved for Amy Sherman-Palladino and the other writers apart from my oc's they may also be time difference from my book to the original series as to fit my time line
Touch of Hellfire (Original Version)
Heather Gilmore is Rory Gilmore's twin sister, who is one of Stars Hollow's most loved along with her sister. She finds herself intrigued by the new bad boy who rolls into town and finds her life changing at every turn. Jess Mariano x OC (Gilmore Girls S2-7+AYITL) I do not own Gilmore Girls I only own my own characters and the storylines I have created Highest Ranking #1 in gilmoregirls - 26/4/2020Complete
Jess Mariano's Sister
When Jess moves to Stars Hollow he leaves a younger sister in New York. After a series of unfortunate events she is picked up and brought to Stars Hollow to live with with Luke and Jess. Follow the adventures of Willow Danes.Complete
𝐓𝐄𝐄𝐍𝐀𝐆𝐄𝐃𝐈𝐑𝐓𝐁𝐀𝐆|𝐆𝐈𝐋𝐌𝐎𝐑𝐄 𝐆𝐈𝐑𝐋𝐒
Lorelai had twins Rory and Romeo. Obviously one of them was her favourite, the other being their father's favourite. Resulting in both twin's being jealousy of each other. Romeo didn't hate his mother but he also didn't like her. It was more the fact he was like her in so many ways. That was the problem she couldn't love something so like herself.
STOLEN DANCE || GILMORE GIRLS
She was the perfect small town girl. She was smart, kind, and polite to everyone she met. But she had big dreams, dreams that went far beyond the town of Stars Hollow. That's how she and her sister ended up at one of the best high schools in Connecticut, but they didn't realize how much their lives would change when they walked into that school. Cassidy Gilmore would find herself questioning everything she thought she knew. She'd make friends and enemies, and she might even find love. But none of that would matter as long as she had her sister and mother by her side. [OC X Gilmore Girls] [Season 1-]Complete
Lorelai will always only love Lorelai. Claire has always known that. In fact she made peace with it and has been building a life that doesn't revolve around the name that brings her pain. But now her twin sister is going to Chilton and trying to be in a world that Claire built without her. Rory always thought that no matter what Claire would always only be her twin, Claire Stassi Gilmore. Claire, has always wished she was more than Rory's twin. There is too much pain that comes with being a Gilmore, Claire will make sure the world remembers her as Claire Stassi Danes.
More detailsContent Guidelines