She Loved Me Anyway - Lena Luthor x Reader
- Reads 17,030
- Votes 843
- Parts 41
Ongoing17h 5m
Last published Wed, Apr 15, 2026
Lena Luthor x Female Reader
When Lena Luthor hires her new assistant, she vows to keep her distance. After all, trust is not something she gives easily-especially not since Eve's betrayal at Lex's hands. But Y/N, her sharp, determined, and quietly compassionate assistant, slowly begins to chip away at Lena's carefully built walls.
As days turn into nights at L-Corp, Lena finds herself caught off guard by the way Y/N sees her-not as a Luthor, not as a CEO, but simply as Lena. With Alex, Kara, and Sam firmly by her side, Lena's circle of chosen family watches her take a leap she never thought possible: falling in love.
But happiness rarely comes without a price. Just as Lena begins to believe in a future with Y/N, danger finds its way into her life-threatening not only her heart, but the fragile trust they've built.
Can Lena hold onto this love, or will the past tear them apart before it's even begun?
All Rights Reserved
#1
melissabenoist
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
Lena Luthor A Love Story Book 1 (Raw not edited)
Supergirl AU; But you'll notice this is Lena's story from her perspective. A new look at how Lena and Kara meet and fall for each other. Later on, Maggie gets a ton of love! Note: Ok So I am done with the story, but Edits will come next and I might add some extras in as I go. So be on the lookout... Oh, and there may be a sequel in the works... who am I lying to here... yes there will be more to come! Book two: Lena Luthor Neverending Love StoryComplete
Coming Home || SuperCorp (On Hold)
Lena Luthor returns back home to National City after moving to Midvale for four years. But, she's coming back with a secret. *This story takes place four years after Season 6.* !!!!WARNING!!!! This story features an intersex Kara Danvers! If that's not your cup of tea, feel free to turn back now :) Enjoy!
Radioactive Love: A Supercorp Story
Lena Luthor has success in many areas of her life, however love is not one of them. She has the ultimate crush on her best friend of ten years Kara Danvers, the budding journalist. After a life threatening incident in Lena's lab will she finally admit how she really feels for Kara, or keep on living a lie? (This is an AU story so Kara has no powers in this story, and the Luthors aren't a notorious evil, alien killing dynasty)Complete
Switching the positions
After Lena finds out the truth about Kara, She wants that Kara feels the same pain what she felt. They said a lot of things in the Fortress of Solitude. Maybe they never will talk to each other again. Maybe they will find a way how can they make the thing between them better. Can they love each other again, like the old times? This is beginning after Lena find out Kara is Supergirl. After their argument(5x07) pS.: Alex and Maggie are still togetherComplete
Hope Rekindled (a Supercorp S5 AU)
Kara didn't exactly take from her wish what Mxy had hoped she would... so now the imp has one last chance to rescue his only friend from surrendering her hope... he needs to coax Lena Luthor into facing many truths she has buried behind her wall of emotional suffocation before Kara's inner flame is extinguished forever. Following a dark fate flash forward, the story picks up right after Kara leaves Lena's penthouse at the end of "It's a Super Life". Mxy visits Lena in Obsidian VR, using his powers and the virtual world he reveals the fundamental flaw of Non Nocere and gives a future version of Brainy (from later in Lena's darker timeline) the opportunity to help Lena finally truly understand Kara's journey from Krypton to the present in hopes that it brings her true feelings to the surface before their darker destiny becomes a reality even 5th Dimensional magic cannot repair. Note: major character deaths in chapters 1 and 3 are temporary. A huge thanks to my amazing beta reader, @luthordamvers, and incredible artist, @unnaturalceilings. All major characters and some story elements owned by DC and the CW. Rights to original story elements belong to the author.Complete
I'M KARA DANVERS
Supergirl. She was brave, selfless, kind, beautiful, and more powerful than any human could ever dream of being. Lena Luthor had always had a weakness for powerful women. Falling for Supergirl was all too easy, and the fact that she'd saved her life certainly didn't help. But what to do about Kara Danvers? The reporter seemed to have an unfortunate crush on the CEO of L-Corp, yet Lena's eyes were stubbornly fixed skywards. Add in the fact that Lena's brother was intent to kill her from behind bars, and life was about to get a whole lot more complicated for a Luthor and a Super.Complete
Reality
Katie has always acted as herself on and off the screen. Except for whenever Melissa was around. She often felt the chemistry between Supergirl and Lena Luthor, but reality always smacked her right back in the face. Katie wants desperately to save their friendship, but what happens when a fall out pushes them apart? Will the great Katie McGrath be able to be as strong as her fictional character counterpart? Or will she let the Girl of Steel defeat the Luthor? Credit to FANDOMSUN1TE for the plot idea! I dont own the characters. They belong to CW.Complete
Paparazzi
Kara Danvers and Lena Luthor have been secretly dating for the past 6 months and so far it has stayed a secret. One day a picture of Lena and a "mysterious" woman gets leaked and everyone goes crazy. Although not as crazy as when they find out who this other woman really is. Ex lovers get jealous. Ex lovers get desperate. Ex lovers get mad. ....... 'Kara stepped out of the lift on the way to her desk that was in the middle of the main floor of the Catco building. She set her stuff down and checked the time. "I'm going to be late." She ran over to Miss Grants office where all the other main reporters and editors were. Once she was there she looked at the various tv screens; her face went into shock. "Crap." ..... Warning ⚠️ : This story includes abuse of a significant other. (past and present) 50k words (Manip on cover not mine)Complete
Lena Kieran Luthor | SuperCorp
Lena Luthor is done with secrets. 6 months after discovering that her best friend Kara Danvers is Supergirl-thanks to a final parting gift from her brother Lex-Lena is rebuilding her life. Her walls are higher, her heart heavier, and her ambition sharper than ever. But secrets have a way of unravelling. As Lena steps into her birthright-one tied not to Luthor blood but to the powerful & secretive Kavanaghs-she finds herself at the heart of a storm she never saw coming. B/w shady ex-boyfriends with hidden motives, corporate warfare over a cancer cure, and shadows from her past refusing to stay buried... Lena's world is on the brink. And Kara? Kara is still there-hopeful, hurting, and unwilling to let their story end in betrayal. As they fight to rebuild what was broken, an onslaught of old enemies and new monsters threatens everything they hold dear. When the multiverse collides, doppelgängers appear, children from other Earths wreak adorable havoc, and allies turn into enemies. But love-real, resilient, painful, earned-might be the most dangerous force of all. This isn't just about forgiveness. It's about survival. And Lena Luthor has never played by the rules.
Home
Lena Luthor gets in trouble and injured. She is saved by Supergirl, who looks out for her while she is resting, trying to figure out how to defeat the new villain. Supercorp will rise. I do not own Supergirl or any of the characters, they are property of the CW. English is not my mother tongue so sorry for my bad english. I hope you like it.Complete
Supergirl - Kara Authentic - Volume 2 - Obsession
Kara and Lena are in love! After years of dancing around their feelings and ignoring the obvious... the two people most destined for one another have acknowledged the truth of their hearts and are building a new life together, but as this new day dawns challenging days lay ahead. A 20 year old journalism major, Dana Dearden, has landed her dream internship... 12 weeks working at CatCo for her idol, Kara Danvers Zor-El. Dana is a bright, energetic, driven young lady laser focused on achieving her dreams, but also hyper focused on trying to be just like her hero. Is it possible she's more than just focused? Is it possible she has an uncontrollable obsession that, when combined with a dangerous new drug from her hometown of Smallville, could drive her down a path of self-destruction? And could her obsession lead to unwelcome trouble for National City's newest couple? All major characters owned by DC and the CW. Rights to original story elements belong to the author.Complete
JUSTICE Alex X Reader (Female) (Third Book - Faked, Truth, Justice) (Supergirl)
You are a friend of Kara Danvers. A lover of Alex Danvers. This is an X Reader, with a bit of a twist. You are an alien, but not in the same way as Supergirl, you are an immigrant from England. (think of Imra's accent and you kind of get the gist) You are tall with fair skin and dark blue eyes. Your love of action and danger was a big part of falling in love with Alex, it's also what brings you to your inevitable fate. If you haven't read the others, it doesn't really matter because the first chapter will outline of a bit what you missed in Faked and Truth but I recommend reading them before getting stuck into this book. Oh, and... Y/N - Your Name As per usual I don't own the characters (just their development and relationships), also the plot and the way it thickensComplete
SuperCorp//Based off of CW's hit series, Supergirl!
"Who ever thought, a Super and a Luthor working together?". That was just the beginning of a brand new friendship, and maybe even more than one as Lena Luthor, CEO of L-Corp falls helplessly in love with the reporter from CatCo- Kara Danvers. But as the two figure out they love each other, can they maintain a healthy relationship with one another, or will they be torn apart due to Kara being a Super, and Lena being a Luthor. Read to find out!Complete
Be my hero - Supercorp Fanfiction
Never before she felt like this, felt safe in someone's arms. She didn't understand what these feelings meant for her. What it meant for them. Lena Luthor. Kara Danvers. Best friends, or not? What are they? And what are these feelings? Should Kara tell her about her secret? Even her friends don't know about it, just her sister Alex knows. Is it worth the risk? Trusting a Luthor? Dealing with her traumatic past Lena tries to be "normal". Act normal and be strong. But still, the blond woman confuses her emotions. Can she trust her best friend enough to tell her what happend? Let the real fight for Lenas soul begin! (slow burn)Complete
T h e B e a s t
O primeiro trabalho de Kara está longe de ser o dos seus sonhos, lutou com unhas e dentes para conseguir ingressar na faculdade de medicina, em vez disso Kara irá trabalhar de governanta, para ninguém menos que Lena Luthor uma das mulheres mais cobiçadas do país, mas todo o sacrifício o válido para ajudar quem ela ama. Lena Kieran Luthor, nasceu em berço de ouro, uma grande apreciadora de bebidas e mulheres, vantagens de ser herdeira do grande império Luthor é CEO da grande companhia L.CORP, porém por de trás de seu sorriso galanteador e status, encontra-se alguém com um temperamento forte e cheia de segredos. fanfic (AU) Lena (G!P)Complete
Blood and Bond - Lena Luthor x Sister Reader
Lena Luthor's world shatters when she discovers a 13-year-old sister-kidnapped and experimented on by Lex and Lillian. Desperate to save Y/N, Lena turns to the one person she swore she'd never trust again: Kara Danvers. Kara doesn't hesitate. Together, with the Superfriends, they'll protect Y/N at all costs. But as danger closes in and old wounds resurface, unspoken feelings between Lena and Kara grow harder to ignore. Can they keep Y/N safe-and finally admit what's in their hearts-before it's too late?
Supergirl AU; But you'll notice this is Lena's story from her perspective. A new look at how Lena and Kara meet and fall for each other. Later on, Maggie gets a ton of love! Note: Ok So I am done with the story, but Edits will come next and I might add some extras in as I go. So be on the lookout... Oh, and there may be a sequel in the works... who am I lying to here... yes there will be more to come! Book two: Lena Luthor Neverending Love Story
More detailsContent Guidelines