Story cover for One lie too Deep by ceciliagold
One lie too Deep
ceciliagold
  • WpView
    Reads 395
  • WpVote
    Votes 39
  • WpPart
    Parts 10
  • WpHistory
    Time 3h 2m
  • WpView
    Reads 395
  • WpVote
    Votes 39
  • WpPart
    Parts 10
  • WpHistory
    Time 3h 2m
ceciliagold
Ongoing, First published Jun 24, 2025
Mature
alisondilaurentisariamontgomerycalebriversdramaemilyfieldshannamarinjasondilaurentisliarsmonavanderwaalmysterynoelkahnoriginalcharacterpllpllfanficprettylittleliarsromancesecretsspencerhastingstobycavanaugh
One summer. One secret. One lie too deep to bury.
In the shadows of Rosewood's manicured lawns and perfect facades, the disappearance of Alison DiLaurentis leaves more than just silence-it unearths secrets no one was meant to find.

Sterling Whitmore was never supposed to be part of the mystery, but she knows more than she lets on. She's sharp, unshakable, and hiding her own scars. As "A" begins to torment the girls with deadly precision, Sterling must navigate old betrayals, forbidden truths, and the boy who might see through every one of her lies.

Because in a town built on whispers and manipulation, trust is deadly-and the truth? Even deadlier.
All Rights Reserved
alisondilaurentisariamontgomerycalebriversdramaemilyfieldshannamarinjasondilaurentisliarsmonavanderwaalmysterynoelkahnoriginalcharacterpllpllfanficprettylittleliarsromancesecretsspencerhastingstobycavanaugh
Table of contents

10 parts

Sign up to add One lie too Deep to your library and receive updates
or
Content Guidelines
You may also like
GOOD LIAR ━━ pretty little liars by leahsayshiorhey
52 parts Complete
❝ we all tell lies when our hearts are hungry ❞ Halle Brewster made a promise would never tell the secrets of the summer that Alison DiLaurentis went missing. Only now, someone else was doing the telling -- something Alison never got the chance to -- and they were going to make Halle and her friends pay for the very lies that started it all. FRIENDS FOREVER? FRIENDS DON'T KISS THEIR FRIEND'S BROTHER, HALLE. --A. pretty little liars fanfiction oc x jason dilaurentis season one -- two book one Started: 04-04-20 Finished: 14-03-22 Reupload: 24-12-24
Pretty Little Liars by StoriesToTheEnd
37 parts Complete
Two years after her disappearance, Alison DiLaurentis's body is found, sparking a murder investigation in the town of Rosewood. Her group of friends left behind find themselves hearing a message beyond the grave when they start receiving cryptic notes from a dangerous stalker that goes by goes by the alias of "A".
tell me a lie || t. cavanaugh by thehiddenromantic
3 parts Ongoing
Rosewood is a small town where everyone else knows almost everyone's secrets. Almost. Like every town, there's lying and betrayal, but this one also has an unsolved missing persons case. Alison Dilaurentis is missing and her friends are drifted, what happens when one anonymous message brings them all back to the place they started. 5 girls catering to Alison, even when they have no idea where she is.
Liar by chloelovesafi
32 parts Ongoing
Katherine Maybell has lived a life of lying, bullying, and keeping secrets. What happens when Alison is found dead and those secrets start to come to light?
Pretty Little Liars: The Silent Sixth by ArianaBlack07
76 parts Complete
She never left Rosewood. She just faded into the background. Jamie Beckett was always the quiet one-Alison's secret, the Liars' shadow, the girl who saw everything and said nothing. But when A comes back with a vengeance, silence won't protect her anymore. As secrets unravel, lies collapse, and old ghosts return, Jamie is pulled deeper into the Liars' world than ever before. She's not just a witness now. She's a piece of the puzzle. Because in Rosewood, even the quiet ones have something to hide
Pretty Little Liars and The Coven Of Vampires by unrequitedlyali
19 parts Complete Mature
This story takes place in the town of Rosewood. We see the liars after they've graduated. Alison disappeared a week before Graduation and Emily, Hanna, Aria, and Spencer have been looking for her since. But one night the liars are attacked leaving them changed forever. The liars are now immortal and they don't know why they changed, the mystery lies in their mysterious makers. Find out what happens in the twisted, supernatural, story of Rosewood.
Matters of the Heart by ForeverWithoutHim
39 parts Complete Mature
Emily Fields has no plans to return to her hometown of Rosewood, but that changes after she gets a letter from Alison DiLaurentis. Love is a strong enough incentive for her to go back, but things are different now. Emily is harboring secrets that none of her loved ones know about. Starts relatively canon (with a few tweaks) with the plot in season 6B, but has some major twists. Seriously, sign your permission slip for this feels trip. It's a bumpy ride.
Forbidden Love by lovefanfic123a
78 parts Ongoing Mature
Follow the lives of Haley Smith and the 4 other girls Spencer, Hanna, Aria and Emily whose friendship falls apart after the disappearance of their group leader Alison Dilaurentis. One year later Haley returns to Rosewood to see a completely different town , except for its secrets, those remain hidden, waiting to be revealed by an anonymous stalker named 'A' tormenting the 5 girls. As Haley navigates the treacherous waters of betrayal and fear, she must confront her biggest secret when he resurfaces in Rosewood.... Jason Dilaurentis Alison's older brother. Haley was 15 and Jason was 20, everything about their relationship was wrong, it was forbidden. But somehow no matter how much they tried to stop it, they found themselves drawn to each other. She got him and he got her. It was forbidden but it was love. True love. Jason Dilaurentis x OC This story follow the tv show pretty little liars closely
UNSTOPPABLE 🅰️ LUCAS GOTTESMAN [book two] by Unco0rdinated
75 parts Complete Mature
Secrets couldn't stay buried if the dead girl didn't. Now that Alison DiLaurentis was alive and well, it was up to her friends to bring her back to Rosewood and take down 'A' once and for all. But was there another adversary out to get them? Only time would tell. One thing Haley Marin knew for sure though, was that'd she'd go down fighting before she let anyone hurt her and her friends again.
UNSTEADY 🅰️ LUCAS GOTTESMAN [book one] by Unco0rdinated
93 parts Complete Mature
Haley Marin thought her life couldn't get anymore complicated than becoming friends with Rosewood's it-girl Alison DiLaurentis, but when the blonde beauty turns up dead, Haley begins to see that life without Alison was only the beginning. And secrets, no matter how small, never stay buried for long. *REVISED VERSION AVAILABLE* Bury A Friend is an updated version of this story with some changes I'm happier with so check that out!
You may also like
Slide 1 of 10
GOOD LIAR ━━ pretty little liars cover
Pretty Little Liars cover
tell me a lie || t. cavanaugh cover
Liar cover
Pretty Little Liars: The Silent Sixth cover
Pretty Little Liars and The Coven Of Vampires cover
Matters of the Heart cover
Forbidden Love cover
UNSTOPPABLE 🅰️ LUCAS GOTTESMAN [book two] cover
UNSTEADY 🅰️ LUCAS GOTTESMAN [book one] cover

GOOD LIAR ━━ pretty little liars

52 parts Complete

❝ we all tell lies when our hearts are hungry ❞ Halle Brewster made a promise would never tell the secrets of the summer that Alison DiLaurentis went missing. Only now, someone else was doing the telling -- something Alison never got the chance to -- and they were going to make Halle and her friends pay for the very lies that started it all. FRIENDS FOREVER? FRIENDS DON'T KISS THEIR FRIEND'S BROTHER, HALLE. --A. pretty little liars fanfiction oc x jason dilaurentis season one -- two book one Started: 04-04-20 Finished: 14-03-22 Reupload: 24-12-24

More details