Split Between the Brothers A Personal Tribute to The Menendez Case By Nor
- Reads 674
- Votes 69
- Parts 38
Ongoing3h 53m
Last published Mon, Aug 11, 2025
Split Between the Brothers
By Nor
Storyline / Summary:
When a young woman stumbles upon a short Instagram reel from Netflix's Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story, she's instantly drawn into a decades-old true crime saga she never expected to care about. What begins as casual curiosity soon becomes an emotional journey-one that splits her heart between two brothers bound by blood, tragedy, and a crime that shook the nation.
As she digs deeper, watching endless clips, testimony videos, and reading books-including the memoir written by Erik's wife-she finds herself becoming emotionally entangled. Erik appears sensitive, vulnerable, and haunted. Lyle, sharp, commanding, and elusive. Social media, YouTube analyses, and courtroom footage blur the lines between guilt and survival, truth and manipulation.
Her admiration for Erik grows as she watches his pain unfold. But Lyle lingers in the back of her mind-a mystery too complex to ignore. He is intelligent, composed, and too quick with his words. She wants to hate him. But she can't. And when she finally reads Private Diary of Lyle Menendez, her world shifts.
Now torn between the tenderness of Erik and the enigma of Lyle, she begins to ask herself: Who were the real victims here? And who were the monsters?
This is not just a story of a crime. It's a deeply personal exploration of obsession, empathy, betrayal-and the psychological unraveling that happens when you start to see infamous faces not as criminals, but as people.
All Rights Reserved
#14
realstories
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
Only Ocean
Meghan Polinsky was excited to see her long distance boyfriend of four years when she took her trip to Brazil. All that hope was squashed as soon as the pilot announced that the plane was about to crash. You know you will die. No one comes out alive from a plane crash right? Not to mention she didn't expect to be stranded on a raft with a undeniably sexy stranger... Throw in a bitter old man, a doe eyed little girl, and a silent little boy, as they try to help one another survive. The endless life changing isolation and trauma they just endured they will never be the same... They need one another as a raft. Not to just float above all the sharks but to make it out alive and keep one another sane. ••• "Lucas's strong hands pulled me up and I sat like a lifeless doll in front of him. He gave me yet another blank stare then turned, once again, to the water as if it was actually entertaining him. I felt frustrated as I huffed loudly to get his attention. He turned to me still with his bone-chilling stare. It was a cold stare but I still found my safety in it oddly enough. I stared at him blankly getting lost, forgetting why I came over here. I sat there as the raft slowly rocked back and forth. "Need anything?" Lucas said seriously. ••• Highest ranking: #1 in raft #1 in surviving #1 in trauma #2 in intense #3 in tearjerker Started: 3-17-19 Finished: 12-30-19 WARNING: MILDLY INAPPROPRIATE LANGUAGE AND THEMESComplete
Ultraviolence - Lyle Menendez
Y/n x Lyle Menendez A Wattpad original, inspired by Monsters on Netflix. She had just moved to LA. He was already living with the guilt. Two worlds collided on a tennis court under the California sun - but what bloomed between them was anything but innocent. Disclaimer: This is a work of fiction. Any similarities to real people, events, or locations are purely coincidental unless otherwise stated. I do not own any real-life brands, songs, or references mentioned - they belong to their rightful owners. a note from the author: this story is mine - please don't repost or steal it. any real names or references belong to their creators. © 2025 [Lobster Lana].Complete
Trauma | Spencer Reid
Victoria Menendez, daughter to Jose and Kitty Menendez, sister to Erik and Lyle Menendez. She was 9, when her brothers killed their parents, leaving her to live with her uncle from her mother's side, changing her last name to Andersen. It's not that she's ashame of her name, but she doesn't want anyone coming up to her and talk about that night and ask her questions. Ever since that day, she lives with trauma. Questioning her brothers, not knowing the reason why they did what they did, till she was old enough to understand. When she gets the time, she visits her brothers in prison, hoping one day they have the opportunity of living a normal life outside. No matter what happened, at the end of the day, that's still her brothers, her family. Even if what they did was horrible. She decided to become a psychology and a sociology teacher, to teach about behavior and what causes one to act a certain way. Also, to understand her brothers more. Spencer Reid, works for the FBI's Behavioral Analysis Unit. He deals with trauma everyday with his career, but at the end of the day, there's a ray of sunshine when he gets home. The pair crosses path at school, where Spencer is a guest speaker for a class. Eventually, they become something more. They share their life story, but Victoria has kept one BIG secret from him. So when one day, Spencer is working on a case that's close to home for her, will she reveal her secret? Will Spencer stay with her, despite her past? Started: 05/20/2021 Published: 06/10/2021 Completed: 06/25/2021 [ HIGHEST RANKS: ] #3 under 'gublernation' (07/18/2021) #1 under 'Kirstenvangsness' (12/06/2021) #2 under 'penelopegarcia' (06/23/2021) #6 under 'drspencerreid' (12/11/2021) #2 under 'Gubler' (08/18/2021) #14 under 'shemarmoore' (07/01/2021) #1 under 'lylemenendez' (09/08/2024) # 2 under 'thomasgibson' (12/16/2021) #12 under 'emilyprentiss' (07/01/2021) #16 under 'matthewgraygubler' (07/01/2021) #1 under 'menendezbrothers' (07/18/2021)Complete
𝓘𝓷𝓷𝓸𝓬𝓮𝓷𝓬𝓮 𝓛𝓸𝓼𝓽 (𝓐 𝓔𝓻𝓲𝓴 𝓪𝓷𝓭 𝓛𝔂𝓵𝓮 𝓕𝓲𝓬)
Marie Vanderwalden had a semi normal life. If you consider living in Beverly Hills normal. For the entirety of her young life, she'd always had the most loving parents a girl could dream of. A lavish home and lifestyle fit for a queen, she knew she was lucky. But, not everyone is as lucky as she is. And meeting Erik and Lyle Menendez? Would show her that.Complete
picture you | monsters: the lyle and erik menendez story.
do you picture me like i picture you? am i in frame from your point of view? do you feel the same? i'm too scared to say half of the things i do when i picture you. (strictly based on the SHOW not the real life menendez brothers. i am also the author of blame it on the rain which is about Erik. this is about Lyle.)Complete
𝘛𝘩𝘦 𝘙𝘦𝘢𝘴𝘰𝘯 (𝘈 𝘓𝘺𝘭𝘦 𝘔𝘦𝘯𝘦𝘯𝘥𝘦𝘻 𝘍𝘪𝘤)
From the outside looking in, you would suspect the Stevenson family to have the picture perfect image. Wealth beyond their wildest dreams, a picture perfect family with absolute power and love. But what most didn't know, was just how deceiving images can be. Marina Stevenson tried her best to stay afloat within the confines of her family home, wanting to make her parents happy more than anything. Simply wanting her to be molded in their image, she did what she felt she had to do to survive. Having two best friends by her side with a very similar home life, Lyle, Erik, and Marina clung to each other in every aspect imaginable. They grow up, they change. But their friendship certainly doesn't. It only grows stronger, igniting feelings they didn't know were there. Throughout the madness they call their life, they find the reason to keep going. Each other.Complete
blame it on the rain | monsters: the lyle and erik menendez story.
gotta blame it on something gotta blame it on something blame it on the rain that was fallin' (this is NOT based off of the real life menendez brothers. this is based off of the show that was inspired by the menendez brothers case. i do not support ryan murphy and what he did to the show. this is STRICTLY about Cooper Koch and Nicholas Chavez. in no way am i referencing the real life case or am i writing about it. please read disclaimers before continuing.)Complete
"THE HURT MAN" (Erik Menendez)
IN WHICH... sam nadia has recently moved to beverly hills highschool. she moved with her mom to get away from her abusive father. she wasn't sure she could trust anyone, let alone a man again, until she met erik menendez. (i know a fan fiction about him seems weird, but there is no sexual content in this book and will NEVER be any. you can read if you want, if you think it's weird, don't.) -TW- •mentions of multiple kinds of abuse •mentions of self harm •mentions of depression •mentions of daddy issues -highest rankings- •4 in #themenendezbrothers •7 in #truecrime •34 in #tw •21 in #menendezbrothers •32 in #erikmenendez •17 in #lylemenendez •75 in #nosmut started: 10/9/24 finished: 12/4/24Complete
The Menendez Secret
Summary: After the brutal murders of José and Kitty Menendez, the world watched as their sons, Erik and Lyle, were tried for parricide. But beneath the headlines, beyond the courtroom, and deep in the shadows of their family's past lies a truth no one saw coming. Jersey is Erik's girlfriend. Lyric is their secret sister. And Camila - the girl long thought forgotten - holds the key to everything. As memories resurface, secret tapes emerge, and supernatural shadows stretch across generations, the truth becomes more terrifying than the lie. Inspired by real events - but twisted into something entirely its own - The Menendez Secret is a dark, emotional, and paranormal exploration of legacy, betrayal, and the cost of silence.Complete
The Alpha's Little Hybrid (Book I)✔
First book in the Hybrid mate series...... His name Joshsan Morgan... Future Alpha of the blood scent pack... He loves running.. And being around people...He has black hair.. Brown eyes and a fit body.... He has A dad .. Mom... And younger sister... He lives his life to the fullest.. Waiting for his mate in the process.... He meets a certain red haired .. Pink eyed girl.. A goddess in his eyes.... He loved her even before he knew her name... His life was great having his mate.. His pack.. His family.. Totally unaware of the evil within his own pack.. He never thought that he would be betrayed by the person so close to his heart... How will he cope with this change......? Her name Jewels Blood Waters.. She loves to dance .. Swim.. Anything red is her style.. She has a mom. Her dad.. Her older twin siblings... She had long red hair.. Weird pink eyes.. And behold the beauty of the earth itself.... Her life was great .. Her secret was safe... Until they had to move to the blood scent pack territory... There she meets a black hair .. Brown eyes boy who would change her life forever... Twist and turns.. Ups and downs... Good time and bad times.. Times of war... Is she prepared for these changes... Can she handle a pack... Can she handle her bestfriend coming back after 3 years only to destroy her....But can she hurt her bestfriend who is her cousin but they grew up like sisters..... Can she handle the evils lurking deep within... Can she be the Alpha's Little hybrid ? This may not be based entirely about mates... It's mostly about two blood bonded bestfriends find their true strength and love for one another... To try and accept that they are the Moon twins... This is my first book of this type... This not edited.. I repeat... This is NOT edited... Read at your own risk.. You have been warned ... Thank you for picking this book.. Hope you like it... ENJOY!!!Complete
Meghan Polinsky was excited to see her long distance boyfriend of four years when she took her trip to Brazil. All that hope was squashed as soon as the pilot announced that the plane was about to crash. You know you will die. No one comes out alive from a plane crash right? Not to mention she didn't expect to be stranded on a raft with a undeniably sexy stranger... Throw in a bitter old man, a doe eyed little girl, and a silent little boy, as they try to help one another survive. The endless life changing isolation and trauma they just endured they will never be the same... They need one another as a raft. Not to just float above all the sharks but to make it out alive and keep one another sane. ••• "Lucas's strong hands pulled me up and I sat like a lifeless doll in front of him. He gave me yet another blank stare then turned, once again, to the water as if it was actually entertaining him. I felt frustrated as I huffed loudly to get his attention. He turned to me still with his bone-chilling stare. It was a cold stare but I still found my safety in it oddly enough. I stared at him blankly getting lost, forgetting why I came over here. I sat there as the raft slowly rocked back and forth. "Need anything?" Lucas said seriously. ••• Highest ranking: #1 in raft #1 in surviving #1 in trauma #2 in intense #3 in tearjerker Started: 3-17-19 Finished: 12-30-19 WARNING: MILDLY INAPPROPRIATE LANGUAGE AND THEMES
More detailsContent Guidelines