Fearfully Yours, Enigmatically Mine
- Reads 14
- Votes 1
- Parts 3
MatureOngoing14m
Last published Thu, Jul 24, 2025
doctor x patient Au,
Edward Nygma is new to Arkham Asylum. At least, that's what the staff thinks. They don't know that under the polite, twitchy demeanor and nervously charming smile lies the Riddler-Gotham's self-declared genius and prince of puzzles. He's biding his time, quietly sowing chaos. Leaving riddles on napkins, in staff files, scratched into walls only the observant would notice. Everyone's a potential player in his game-but none worthy of being a rival.
Except one.
Dr. Jonathan Crane, cold and clinical, is assigned to Edward's case. On paper, he's the perfect therapist. In reality, he's using Arkham's patients to refine his fear toxin. But Edward's mind-layered with riddles and insecurities, vanity and shame-isn't like the others. Crane wants to crack him open. Understand him. Break him.
All Rights Reserved
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
Crimson X
Shar Channing, the new psychiatrist at Arkham Asylum, is in charge of the patient Edward Nigma, AKA The Riddler. Professor Strange confronts Doctor Channing about her unconventional ways of treating her patients. Flustered, she tries to leave the asylum, but gets lost on her way out. She sees something she shouldn't, which will drive her to become Crimson X. Will she be a vigilante or just another criminal? Riddler X OCComplete
The Joker's Princess (Joker X Reader)
Best Rankings Ever: #1 Joker #1 Batman #2 dc #2 BruceWayne #2 soulmates #6 fanfiction You've always wanted to know who your soulmate was. But while at work, you never thought it would be the bank robber wearing the scary Clown Mask. And you deffinetly didn't think it would be Gotham's new head criminal; The Joker. What are you to do when the lines to what is wrong and right are blurred. You discover that Gotham holds a darker secret. Who really is the bad guy? With your heart and mind battling against each other, you just might end up being crazy as he is. "You're mine, and mine alone. I will burn this city to the ground to have you. And anyone, especially that flying rat, will die for keeping you away from me." JokerXReaderComplete
𝙴𝚐𝚘'𝚜 𝚁𝚎𝚏𝚕𝚎𝚌𝚝𝚒𝚘𝚗 | Jonathan Crane
𝙄𝙢 𝙚𝙫𝙚𝙧𝙮 𝙗𝙞𝙩 𝙩𝙬𝙞𝙨𝙩𝙚𝙙 𝙖𝙨 𝙮𝙤𝙪 𝙖𝙧𝙚. 𝙉𝙤, 𝙮𝙤𝙪𝙧 𝙬𝙤𝙧𝙨𝙚. Dr. Y/N Ashford, the genius everyone envies and no one truly understands, never had to fight for control. I took what I wanted and crushed those who stood in my way. But when I walked into Arkham, something shifted. Jonathan Crane-intelligent, calculating, and utterly obsessed with fear-appeared to be the only one who could challenge me. He sees through my perfect façade, and frankly, it thrills me. The line between adversary and something more is thin, and I'm ready to push it. But as we play this dangerous game, one question remains: who will break first? - Jonathan Crane x Fem Reader- ⚠Narssistic Personality Disorder, Gore, Violence ⚠ - Slight Enemies to Lovers - ----------------------------------------------- Link to the chapter updating playlist: https://open.spotify.com/playlist/2oxSCMc2Wh8nGrh25T9KL5?si=20702925038d49c9Complete![A Night in Hell | J. Crane [i] ✔️](https://img.wattpad.com/cover/79103471-256-k367256.jpg)
A Night in Hell | J. Crane [i] ✔️
Being a psychiatrist at Arkham means dealing with some of the most dangerous criminals in Gotham. Doctor Lilith Matthews was very aware of this, but took the job anyway. She was supposed to be his substitute doctor, until his recovered. Instead she was changed to his full on doctor. What Lilith had no idea, was that all of these criminals would break out of their cells and take over the island, along with Batman to try and stop it. Will Lilith survive a night in Hell? Or fall prey at the hands of her patient... The Scarecrow. BOOK ONE OF THE PANIK: ARKHAM TRILOGY CHECK OUT THE SEQUEL: Nowhere to Hide © 2016 | CatherineComplete
Stitches || Scarecrow
A story can start with the most unusual beginning. And this one begins with a patient losing her mind and fighting to stay sane as she undergoes treatments ran by Dr. Jonathan Crane, a doctor with another identity. And then the twist begins when a prison break occurs and the broken woman escapes, but somehow winds up back again with the man she once despised. For he is her cure to insanity. (Made in 2014)Complete
Professor Fear (Jonathan Crane x OC)
Professor Jonathan Crane of Gotham University takes an interest in a peculiar student as his latest tester of his fear toxin. He finds himself unexpectedly challenged by her. Through trying to prove herself, Daria finds herself falling headfirst into a dangerous world of tumultuous terrors where she finds herself at the mercy of needle-pricks, graded papers and a Scarecrow. Professor Fear II and III are published at available via author profile.Complete
Crazy Love
Your school bus gets high jacked on the way back from a field trip by none other than the Clown Prince of Crime. You volunteer to go with him to Gotham to save your classmates. Eventually the police catch joker and take him to Arkham Asylum. Meanwhile, you are sent to the hospital where you meet Dr. Jonathan Crane and immediately hit it off. Find out what happens next in Crazy Love!Complete
Mad Love & Mayhem
Felix believed he could study madness without falling into it. He was wrong. As an intern at Arkham Asylum, he was expected to investigate Gotham's most dangerous minds, not become one of them. Then he met Hyunjin. The Joker. A walking enigma with a blood-red smile and a desire for anarchy. Felix persuaded himself he was merely doing research. It's just fascination. It's just curiosity. Until it was not. The city now whispers their names out of fear. The boundary between love and obsession has blurred beyond recognition, and Felix is too far gone to notice. He belonged to Hyunjin. And Hyunjin? He also belonged to Felix. But Gotham is unyielding, and even love forged from blood and ruin has limitations. When the Bat comes knocking, Felix is forced to choose between running deeper into the lunacy and losing the only thing that has ever felt completely real. Whatever happens, something will burn.Complete
The Doctor Is In
Dr. K is the new psychiatrist at Arkham Asylum with a slippery past and a mastery of analyzing people, especially super criminals. While she enjoys the thrill of interviewing the patients, her past soon comes back to track her down and drag her back into the dirt. Hey, it takes one to know one, right? Author's Acknowledgement: My first real introduction to Batman was a cartoon called "Batman: The Brave and the Bold", which showed both A and D-list villains that I enjoyed equally. After showing interest in the franchise, my father showed me the '89 movie and episodes of the '60s show, on which he'd grown up on. Now older, and having been exposed to the more darker elements of Batman, I enjoy both the modern depiction of Batman while still hold respect for his roots and alternate variations. I hope fans of both sides will find something to enjoy in "The Doctor Is In".Complete
by reason of insanity (JOKER X READER) ❌
You're a mostly sane patient at Arkham Asylum. He's the Clown Prince of Crime, and now your new cellmate. If you want to survive the asylum, you'll have to survive him first. Featuring far too many uses of the word "fuck", weird face touching, a couple Twilight references, and very bad bedtime stories, this almost looks like a love story. 𝐒𝐓𝐀𝐑𝐓𝐄𝐃: 01/20/23 𝐅𝐈𝐍𝐈𝐒𝐇𝐄𝐃: tbd 𝐇𝐈𝐆𝐇𝐄𝐒𝐓 𝐑𝐀𝐍𝐊 𝐒: #2 in #jaredletofanfiction #2 in #jokerxreader #1 in #suicidesquad #1 in #joker #1 in #crazylove *i do not own anything but the plotline and various ocs. everything else belongs to dc.* Jokerxreader
Shar Channing, the new psychiatrist at Arkham Asylum, is in charge of the patient Edward Nigma, AKA The Riddler. Professor Strange confronts Doctor Channing about her unconventional ways of treating her patients. Flustered, she tries to leave the asylum, but gets lost on her way out. She sees something she shouldn't, which will drive her to become Crimson X. Will she be a vigilante or just another criminal? Riddler X OC
More detailsContent Guidelines