Is it a Lie...or Love?
- Reads 6,796
- Votes 131
- Parts 24
Ongoing1h 53m
Last published Tue, Jun 2, 2026
This is MY au where White lily cookie was kidnapped by Shadow milk to lure Pure vanilla to the spiral and give him back his soul jam... but in the process White lily started to talk to Shadow milk and grow feeling and she didn't know if he felt the same he would make small comments and kiss her cheek but when she asked he would always deny it....So was it love...or a lie? READ TO FIND OUT ALSO SHADOWLILY WARNING!💋
All Rights Reserved
#58
onesidedlove
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
"It all Started with a Bet..." / ShadowNilla PureMilk / PhantomPlayz140
A bet Shadow Milk lost to led him to 'rethink' his relationship with his counterpart. Shenanigans ensue! ▼Cover Art by PhantomPlayz140 (Reference used!) ▼Characters belong to Cookie Run Kingdom, DevSisters ▼Notice: If there is a story similar to mine in Archive Of Our Own under the name experimental_recluse, that's me! This is just an advanced notice in case there are claims it was stolen off of Wattpad or AO3. ▼ Started: April 02, 2025 ▼ Ended: May 15, 2025Complete
Epístolas de Medianoche / Purelily NSFW/ Cookie Run Kingdom / CRK /
Cartas de amor... que se tornan eróticas. (Nsfw)Complete
⋆˚｡⋆୨୧˚ 𝘍𝘳𝘢𝘤𝘵𝘶𝘳𝘦𝘥 𝘗𝘳𝘰𝘮𝘪𝘴𝘦𝘴 ✧˖°.‧₊⋅˚✮ {ShadowVanilla}
⋆｡‧˚ʚ♡ɞ˚‧｡⋆ ShadowVanilla highschool au!! ;3333 ₊✩‧₊˚౨ৎ˚₊✩‧₊ 🪼 Top student and popular boy Pure Vanilla desperately wants to understand Shadow Milk. Pure Vanilla seems perfect on the outside, completely normal and usual, though no one- not even his best friend, White Lily know about his possibly unrequited affection he felt towards Shadow Milk. Shadow Milk and Pure Vanilla's relationship progresses, slowly, encountering many struggles along the way. ✮ ⋆ ˚｡𖦹 ⋆｡°✩ TRIGGER WARNINGS: ⚠️ Hints at an eating disorder, internalized homophobia, slight homophobia from others, bullying, angst, somewhat detailed making out scenes- all of these are in light amounts, however the book is directed to be angsty and a bit sad (With a lot of fluff, however, it's very romantic), so if this triggers you, maybe skip this book and read another story! ദ്ദി(˵ •̀ ᴗ - ˵ ) ✧ ✮ ⋆ ˚｡𖦹 ⋆｡°✩ HEADCANNONS (My personal headcannons that will appear in the story) Pure Vanilla is bisexual (Male pref) Shadow Milk is gay There's, once again, no smut, but Pure Vanilla is the more authorative guy in the relationship (I'm sorry guys ❤️) Freaknilla (Freaky Pure Vanilla) is a thing in ts (I'm sorry again ❤️) Shadow Milk is kinda a femboy Pure Vanilla is very nerdy and he dresses very preppy and proper Burning Spice is very rude to them White Lily is a borderline stalker ⋆｡‧˚ʚ♡ɞ˚‧｡⋆ Cover art by (Pria Zolayvar) on Facebook! ⏔⏔⏔ ꒰ ᧔ෆ᧓ ꒱ ⏔⏔⏔ ENJOYYYYY!! (˶ᵔ ᵕ ᵔ˶)
"Loneliness is Interpreted in Different People." / ShadowNilla / PhantomPlayz140
Pure Vanilla thinks he's overthinking his recent observation on his husband Shadow Milk, until he wasn't. Someone's feeling a little unfaithful lately... ▼Cover Art by PhantomPlayz140 (No reference used. /srs) ▼Characters belong to Cookie Run Kingdom; DevSisters ▼Notice: I have a similar story in AO3 under the name @ experimental_recluse ! If there's any other copies from different sites and user, they do not belong to me unless otherwise! Report if you must. Thank you! ▼ Started: July 02, 2025 ▼ Ended: July 11, 2025Complete
You Promised // CRK/DISCONTINUED/PROCESS OF REMAKING
An AU where White Lily, HollyBerry, Golden Cheese, and Dark Cacao Broke their FriendShip with Pure Vanilla.Complete
A Heart that Screams
It had been a year since the world had been touched into deceit. The sky, covered in blue and yellow eyes, stared down at the cookies in amusement as they fought and argued about what was true, if there was any truth in the world anymore. White Lily Cookie stared into the sky, her brows curled in thought. Her friends had all been struggling for the past year to protect their kingdoms. That is, almost all of them. Pure Vanilla Cookie had been missing for the entirety of the year. White Lily Cookie couldn't stop herself from feeling guilty. If she had just stayed with him before he entered that spire, he might be here to fight against the deceit, or even better, it might not of even gotten this bad. ~ Or; The ancient cookies go on a quest to beast-yeast after a year of deceit taking over the world to put and end to it all-and hopefully find their dear friend Pure Vanilla Cookie along the way.
Crossing Borders
Not being able to shift can really take its toll on someone. But for Lily, she's gotten used to it. Of course she craves to be a werewolf and run along with the pack instead of jumping from tree to tree like a squirrel but what can you do? Get kidnapped sounds like a good idea. "I mean, you're a human who kind of belongs to my pack now. Since you know, you crossed" he said, still advancing towards me. "But... but by crossing the boundary wouldn't you belong... belong to ours then?" I said as he reached. His heavy body rested on mine, letting me feel his heartbeat. His was slow and steady. Mine was probably going on like a bee who had gotten his honey stolen. "You're observant. But it only counts if I was caught" "But you were caught" I said as his hand twirled a strand of my hair once again. "By who?" he said, putting the strand behind my ear. "M-me" I said, trying to sound brave. I never sounded brave. Not even when I was. "Yet, you're not going to be able to tell anyone" he smiled. "Why... why not?" "Because you're mine now" Posted on 17 June 2017Complete
Illusion
SHADOWVANILLA STORY!! Shadow Milk Cookie plans to deceive Pure Vanilla Cookie, In order to keep the soul jam for himself. But what will happen if he ends up falling for his own tricks? What if his illusion isn't thick enough?
A bet Shadow Milk lost to led him to 'rethink' his relationship with his counterpart. Shenanigans ensue! ▼Cover Art by PhantomPlayz140 (Reference used!) ▼Characters belong to Cookie Run Kingdom, DevSisters ▼Notice: If there is a story similar to mine in Archive Of Our Own under the name experimental_recluse, that's me! This is just an advanced notice in case there are claims it was stolen off of Wattpad or AO3. ▼ Started: April 02, 2025 ▼ Ended: May 15, 2025
More detailsContent Guidelines