Like him (Dark!Toby x reader) - anto💿 - Wattpad

Story cover for Like him (Dark!Toby x reader) by antoimne

Like him (Dark!Toby x reader)

Reads 6
Votes 0
Parts 2
Time 11m

Reads 6
Votes 0
Parts 2
Time 11m

Mature

angst creepypasta creepypastafanfiction readerxcharacter slenderman ticcitoby ticcitobyxreader tobyrogers triggerwarning xreader

"You loved him - messy, complicated, heartbreakingly and beautifully fragile. You really thought you could hold him together. Assemble his pieces one by one, shard by shard. But in the end, those same pieces became sharper and sharper. They'd started to cut you, deeper and deeper, until there was nothing left to bleed."

(Relationship AU, note that a lot of stuff from canon might've been modified to adapt the story).
Art by @shatteredanklesAll Rights Reserved

angst creepypasta creepypastafanfiction readerxcharacter slenderman ticcitoby ticcitobyxreader tobyrogers triggerwarning xreader

Table of contents

2 parts

Sign up to add Like him (Dark!Toby x reader) to your library and receive updates

or

Content Guidelines

You may also like

Bullet To Another Life [Retry Series] by tockrocked

You try your best to provide for yourself, in a small apartment, taking random odd jobs. You normally babysit this pair of kids, up until something happens that changes your life, for the better or worse. Ticci Toby x Female Reader PLEASE STOP READING THIS ITS SO CRINGE OH LORD

Childhood (Ticci Toby x Reader) by Miss_Megaheart

A little girl. No older than 3. Abandoned in the forest and left to die by her parents. The only thing she had was her family scrapbook and a stuffed animal. Befriended the beast called The Rake that day. She ate some poisonous berries by accident and almost died. Her new friend hollered to the being known as Slenderman. They saved her life and brought to their mansion, where she met more funny, weird, and creepy friends called "creepypastas." 13 years later, a new creepypasta comes by and they become the best of friends. His name is Toby Rogers. Otherwise known as Ticci Toby. Together, Toby helps find her find birth parents to get payback. After that, she starts developing a crush on the twitching boy. Why is this all so important to you? You are that girl.

Remember Me 2 by RoseQuartz_1x

Sequel to 'Remember Me'. He was finally captured, and she was saved. Everything is okay now, right? Think again... (Ticci Toby x OC Book)

You're A Dream ⋆ Toby Rogers X Reader ⋆ Sequel by LovingMe232

A lot changed after the fire. You never forgot about Toby. Toby on the other hand was a different story. He moved in with a girl, and changed his life, for, what seems, the better. Will Toby be able to remember you, and his true feelings? ⋆ You're A Nightmare Part 2 ⋆ Toby Rogers X Reader

You're a Nightmare ⋆ Ticci Toby X Reader by LovingMe232

Unfortunately Tobias Rogers needs help, and your the only one who can help him. But that doesn't mean either of you will enjoy your time spent together. Will you be able to get over your dislike and realize your true feelings? Ticci Toby X Reader

Love Is Blind (Eyeless Jack x Reader) by DarkRaven2994

(Y/n) was just your average, everyday young adult who loved to read books, take walks, and enjoy the beautiful scenery that the woods just beyond her backyard had to offer. Life without the daily struggle of completing schoolwork was long gone and liberating. However, true freedom was not so easily obtained when you lived under the rule of abusive parents. (Y/n) is determined to make it through another year of mistreatment, but once newfound tragedies occur, hope in withstanding the circumstances starts to falter . . . That is, until a newfound stranger enters her life. There's something off about him at first, but as time passes, she slowly regains her optimism as well as some other new-felt feelings. A new life seems to be forming before her eyes, but is this new life something that she can handle?

A Forgotten Friend Ticci Toby X Reader [COMPLETE] [EDITING] by VCReading1098

Cover By: mrsagustd93 Y/N L/N-Age 19 She had a friend from her past disappear. People say he's dead. Others say he's alive and killing. She wish both of these remarks aren't true and he's just at a vacation for a long time... Tobias Rodgers Aka. Ticci Toby- Age 19 One of the proxies of Slenderman. Doesn't really remember some of his past from a little bit of amnesia. Can't feel pain from one of his disorders. Has Tourette's Syndrome. What happens if they meet again? ⚠️CONTAINS GORE, BAD LANGUAGE⚠️

Bloody Flowers [TicciJack] by MaskedmenMaruaders

⚠︎There will be mental health struggles, suicide, attempted suicide, death, abuse, violence, and other triggering topics. If any of this is a trigger, please do not read this fan fiction.⚠︎ [insert description] I did not come up with Ticci Toby or Eyeless Jack, they aren't my ocs. Credit to their creators (Azelf500 & Kastoway) 💪 The art isn't mine either 😞 (Yasmim.Killer_UwU) #1 in Marble Hornets - Nov. 8th 2025 #1 in ticcitobyxeyelessjack - Dec. 12th 2025

Under Control (Ticci Toby X Reader) by ScarlettHasSinned

(May contain sensitive topics) Things never went as plan as (Y/n) hoped. Her family had dissipated, leaving her with her solemn aunt. There, she was alone and liked it that way. When she had developed bad habits of drinking, she was falling into her crumbling world. When someone pops up in her home, her world flips and tumbles and makes this very perplexed situation. Toby, his name is, popped into her messy life and rearranged everything. As things go, she would be a side-kick almost. Despite his deeds, she felt herself gaining unwanted feelings. *Original cover picture, not mine!* Highest rank: Creepypasta #8 (I hella screamed when i saw that btw)

You may also like

Slide 1 of 9

Bullet To Another Life [Retry Series] cover

Childhood (Ticci Toby x Reader) cover

Remember Me 2 cover

You're A Dream ⋆ Toby Rogers X Reader ⋆ Sequel cover

You're a Nightmare ⋆ Ticci Toby X Reader cover

Love Is Blind (Eyeless Jack x Reader) cover

A Forgotten Friend Ticci Toby X Reader [COMPLETE] [EDITING] cover

Bloody Flowers [TicciJack] cover

Under Control (Ticci Toby X Reader) cover

Bullet To Another Life [Retry Series]

You try your best to provide for yourself, in a small apartment, taking random odd jobs. You normally babysit this pair of kids, up until something happens that changes your life, for the better or worse. Ticci Toby x Female Reader PLEASE STOP READING THIS ITS SO CRINGE OH LORD