I Loved The Wrong One First - JenniferDare - Wattpad

Story cover for I Loved The Wrong One First by jenniferdare

I Loved The Wrong One First

Reads 1,356
Votes 115
Parts 24
Time 1h 42m

Reads 1,356
Votes 115
Parts 24
Time 1h 42m

I was the preacher's daughter.
Meant to be good. Meant to marry the sheriff's son.

Beau Carter was everything I was supposed to want-steady hands, clean boots, a heart full of promises.

But then Weston Clay rode into town.

Older. Wilder. Wanted.
He didn't ask permission. He didn't need saving.
And he sure as hell didn't care who I belonged to.

One of them held my hand in church.
The other pressed me against the barn wall.

Now I'm caught between the life I was raised for...
and the fire I can't put out.

Entered into (TheAmbysAward 2025)

Also if you like this one check out No Longer Carver currently climbing the ranks for Old West🥰All Rights Reserved

Series

Western Romance

24 parts
11 parts
20 parts

Table of contents

24 parts

Sign up to add I Loved The Wrong One First to your library and receive updates

or

Content Guidelines

You may also like

Lessons In Butterflies ｡｡｡ (StudentxTeacher Romance) by 101riaxotunesmxxn

___ "What? Oh, no. No, no, no. We are not playing family," I stammered, glancing quickly at Mr. Caldwell, who was staring wide-eyed at Theo and Leo. Leo, never one to miss an opportunity, immediately started bouncing. "Yeah! You can be our dad! And Shella can be our mum!" I could feel my face heating up, and I shot Mr. Caldwell a panicked look, hoping he'd jump in with some kind of teacherly shutdown, but he just stared at the twins, looking almost as horrified as I felt. "Theo, Leo," I started firmly, "I think maybe you should ask someone else to be-" "But we want you!" Theo whined, putting on his best puppy-dog eyes. Leo followed suit, each of them pulling out every ounce of childlike desperation. "Pleeease? Just for pretend!" I glanced at Mr. Caldwell, silently begging for backup. "Uh, guys, there's a lot of people here who could be... your pretend parents. How about... Ms. Findle from the front desk?" "No!" Leo insisted, shaking his head. "It has to be you two!" "Boys, sometimes... " Leo tugged at my sleeve, pouting, "But... you and Mr. Caldwell look like a real mum and dad. Right, Mr. Caldwell?" Mr. Caldwell turned to me, his face growing redder by the second. "I... um..." he started, his voice almost cracking. He looked back down at Theo and Leo, obviously scrambling for a way out. "Maybe we could... I don't know, play a game where we're superheroes instead?" "Oh, so you don't like Shella?" Theo suddenly asked, tilting his head with a look of pure curiosity that only children could get away with. _______________ Shella is a smart, sarcastic, and somewhat self-conscious girl just trying to navigate the demands o her complicated family life. While she excels in most classes, Mr. Caldwell's subject is her biggest struggle. He's strict, intimidating, and doesn't cut anyone slack. Mr. Caldwell pushes her in ways no one else dares, noticing things others overlook-like the insecurities she tries to hide. __

Under Oath | BWWM by BlairsPen

DISCLAIMER: This book contains explicit content and mature themes intended for readers aged 18 and over. It is not a traditional romance, but rather a deeply complex and dark exploration of a toxic relationship. The characters' dynamics involve intense emotional manipulation, power struggles, and actions that may be triggering to some readers. Please be advised that this story delves into themes that are explicit, emotionally charged, and may not be suitable for all audiences. Proceed with caution. "Tell me again how you don't want me," he whispers, dragging his lips down her neck. "Say it under oath, and I might even believe you." Jasmine Taylor doesn't lose. Not in the courtroom, not in life. At just twenty-six, she's built an ironclad reputation: fierce, brilliant, and unshakably professional. But when she's assigned the biggest case of her career-defending Dimitri Alekseev, a dangerously alluring Russian immigrant accused of murder-her world begins to crack. Dimitri isn't just a suspect. He's a problem. Tall, tattooed, and terrifyingly unreadable, with ties to a powerful family the law doesn't dare touch. The evidence against him is overwhelming. The press wants him buried. And deep down, Jasmine suspects the whispers are true. But the more time she spends with him, the harder it becomes to separate fact from instinct. Because beneath his cold exterior is something intoxicating. Calculated charm. Raw heat. And secrets whispered in the dark. As the trial barrels forward, Jasmine finds herself pulled into his world-one filled with shadows, blood ties, and undeniable temptation. The closer she gets to the truth, the more she risks not just her career, but her safety... and her soul. What happens when the woman who always plays by the rules falls for the man who was born to break them?

𝙐𝙣𝙫𝙚𝙞𝙡𝙚𝙙 𝙋𝙧𝙤𝙢𝙞𝙨𝙚𝙨 - 𝙎𝙝𝙖𝙙𝙤𝙬 𝙊𝙛 𝙑𝙤𝙬𝙨 by Deewanixwriters

AKSHAT SINGHANIA - A literature professor in Singania Institute of Arts and Commerce. He is soft and caring person with a tough exterior, who doesn't believe in love or marriage because of his parent's broken relationship and his ex wife's betrayal. As a professor, he's dedicated to his work, and his no-nonsense attitude masks a softer side. AMRIT TRIPATHI - She is a straightforward but introvert student, embodying simplicity and honesty. While others vie for the attention of their stern professor, Akshat, Amrit remains unnoticed until life takes an unexpected turn. Her future dream is to become an writer and she is starting her PHD. However their fates intervened when Akshat had to marry Amrit for saving her from humiliation. Jump inside to join their journey ✨

Delirious (COMPLETE) by Dreamy627

SHORTER STORY! THERE IS SMUT BUT NOT HEAVY SEX just an fyi Shaina Felton was gorgeous, rich, a star. She was a gem, a worthy actress, incredible. Her demeanor was powerful, demanding. During a red carpet event she is forced to speak to producers, twins actually, who would like to offer a new film proposal for this star. Only she has more chemistry with them than she does with her co-star. They get a bit tangled in the process.

Heer~THE UNWANTED DAUGHTER by saranya_writez

Heer sharma, a smart and intelligent girl who lives with her mother, and has no idea about her father. What will happen when one day , she has to live with her father's family which has her step mother and 6 half brothers, because her own mother had the last stage cancer and cant survive anymore? How will Heer manage to live in that house? TROPES~ High school romance 6 Protective Half brothers Bad boy x good girl Best friend's sisterxBrother's best friend He fell first and harder No bullying 12th x 11th Rom-com Bold girl Backbencherxtopper Family love

The Malhotras by ritikaauthor

This is a story of four brothers. The brothers who are ready to sacrifice their lives for each other in childhood but what will happen when they grow up and find their partners. Will their partners also understand their love for each other or Will they try to create conflict between them? It is a multicouple story. The story will involve brotherhood, bromance and romance at the same time.

Her Royal King by ficuniverse_00

ARVITH RAWALVANSHI is the King of Ranwada, the eldest son of a powerful royal family. Ranwada is a land rich in culture, wealth and everything that makes a kingdom strong. Arvith is cold-hearted by nature but a brilliant ruler. People say he doesn't even have a heart. They believe whoever marries him will be the unluckiest girl alive because he is known as a devil. He has no interest in love or marriage. But what happens when his family arranges his marriage to a girl who has nothing... and no one even knows she exists? Will he accept her or push her away? YASHIKA TRIPATHI is a girl who lives inside four walls not because anyone forces her but because she chooses silence. She speaks only when needed and sometimes not at all. She has no one to share her pain with. She wasn't always like this. Something in her past changed her completely. She doesn't know her purpose in life-until the day her family fixes her marriage with the King of Ranwada, Arvith Rawalvanshi. To Yashika, this feels like the end. How can she survive with a man known as a devil? Will she get the love she always craves? Will he ever accept her? And what turned her into this quiet, broken girl? Step into a world of power, silence and longing-where destiny writes its own story.

Phoebe [BWAM] by elationwish

"Daddy?" "No, he is not your da-" "Well hello, there little baby." ❀❀❀ Phoebe and her daughter Echo were an interesting pair. Always clinging to each other and whatnot. Phoebe couldn't go a day without her little Echo, and Echo couldn't go a day without her tiny mommy. Zameer was a very stern professor. It's always just been him and him alone. He loved the feeling of higher power and the cold demeanor he holds. When Phoebe is put in Zameers psychology class, the attraction cannot be denied between the two. What happens when Zameer finds out about Little Echo? Will he become the father figure that she's been missing in her life, or will he reject both Phoebe and Echo and go back to his sharp demeanor. *NO SMUT* Completed 12/14/2024

🔰ငြိ🔰 by Lynn-95

မင်းရဲ့ဖြစ်တည်မှုကို ငါလက်ခံမယ်.... ပိုကောင်းမွန်တဲ့ ဖြစ်တည်ခြင်းဆီကို လျှောက်လှမ်းနိုင်ဖို့ ငါက အမြဲမင်းနဲ့အတူ ဘေးနားမှာရှိနေပေးမယ်.... အနဂ္ဂဘုန်းမြတ် တစ်ယောက်ယောက်က ငါ့ဖြစ်တည်မှုကို အလေးထားတယ် မြတ်နိုးတန်ဖိုးထားပေးတယ်ဆိုတဲ့ အသိက ငါ့ကို ရူးမတတ်ဖြစ်စေတယ်..... ထိန်လင်းသာ

Bride By Mistake by chocowrts

•|𝐀𝐑𝐑𝐀𝐍𝐆𝐄 𝐌𝐀𝐑𝐑𝐈𝐀𝐆𝐄 (Replaced Bride) 𝐒𝐓𝐎𝐑𝐘|• ✦ RITVIKA KAPOOR ✦ A girl who carries the sun in her smile and storms in her silence. She wasn't raised in riches, but she's richer than most-in love, in softness, in strength. A single mother at 24, her heart beats not just for herself, but for her little girl who calls her "Mumma." 𝙎𝙞𝙡𝙚𝙣𝙘𝙚 is her language and 𝙩𝙤𝙪𝙘𝙝 her comfort-she loves quietly, endures deeply. Every scar has a story, but she chooses not to tell them, only to live past them. She dreams of love, but doesn't expect it. She hopes for a miracle, yet walks through life with calm acceptance. She is a - ❝ Khud se zyada kisi aur ke liye jeene wali ladki. ❞ ━━━━━━━━━━ ✦✧✦ ━━━━━━━━━━ ✦ VIDYUT RAJVANSH ✦ His presence demands silence. A man built from shadows and steel. Cold eyes, sharp suits, and a reputation darker than the night. He's the kind of man who doesn't flinch at loss, and never looks back once he walks away. A CEO, a name whispered in fear, a heart hidden behind layers of pain and pride. Commitments? He avoids them. Emotions? He shuts them out. Children? He doesn't do soft things-until Tara calls him "Dadda." He doesn't believe in second chances, but somehow, Ritvika feels like the home he never had. He is a - ❝ Mohabbat se door bhaagne wala, lekin mohabbat mein doobta hua aadmi. ❞ ━━━━━━━━━━ ✦✧✦ ━━━━━━━━━━ Join the Journey of RITVIKA & VIDYUT 💗

You may also like

Slide 1 of 10

Lessons In Butterflies ｡｡｡ (StudentxTeacher Romance) cover

Under Oath | BWWM cover

𝙐𝙣𝙫��𝙚𝙞𝙡𝙚𝙙 𝙋𝙧𝙤𝙢𝙞𝙨𝙚𝙨 - 𝙎𝙝𝙖𝙙𝙤𝙬 𝙊𝙛 𝙑𝙤𝙬𝙨 cover

Delirious (COMPLETE) cover

Heer~THE UNWANTED DAUGHTER cover

The Malhotras cover

Her Royal King cover

Phoebe [BWAM] cover

Bride By Mistake cover

Lessons In Butterflies ｡｡｡ (StudentxTeacher Romance)

_ "What? Oh, no. No, no, no. We are not playing family," I stammered, glancing quickly at Mr. Caldwell, who was staring wide-eyed at Theo and Leo. Leo, never one to miss an opportunity, immediately started bouncing. "Yeah! You can be our dad! And Shella can be our mum!" I could feel my face heating up, and I shot Mr. Caldwell a panicked look, hoping he'd jump in with some kind of teacherly shutdown, but he just stared at the twins, looking almost as horrified as I felt. "Theo, Leo," I started firmly, "I think maybe you should ask someone else to be-" "But we want you!" Theo whined, putting on his best puppy-dog eyes. Leo followed suit, each of them pulling out every ounce of childlike desperation. "Pleeease? Just for pretend!" I glanced at Mr. Caldwell, silently begging for backup. "Uh, guys, there's a lot of people here who could be... your pretend parents. How about... Ms. Findle from the front desk?" "No!" Leo insisted, shaking his head. "It has to be you two!" "Boys, sometimes... " Leo tugged at my sleeve, pouting, "But... you and Mr. Caldwell look like a real mum and dad. Right, Mr. Caldwell?" Mr. Caldwell turned to me, his face growing redder by the second. "I... um..." he started, his voice almost cracking. He looked back down at Theo and Leo, obviously scrambling for a way out. "Maybe we could... I don't know, play a game where we're superheroes instead?" "Oh, so you don't like Shella?" Theo suddenly asked, tilting his head with a look of pure curiosity that only children could get away with. ___________ Shella is a smart, sarcastic, and somewhat self-conscious girl just trying to navigate the demands o her complicated family life. While she excels in most classes, Mr. Caldwell's subject is her biggest struggle. He's strict, intimidating, and doesn't cut anyone slack. Mr. Caldwell pushes her in ways no one else dares, noticing things others overlook-like the insecurities she tries to hide.