The Liar who wasn't
- Reads 3,405
- Votes 132
- Parts 18
Ongoing1h 11m
Last published Sat, Jul 11, 2026
PSA: yes Johnny is the love interest for Cecilia, yes i'm aware he's a gay character but this book will not be mirroring the show/book in the exact way it was written. some things are changed for the sole purpose that this is a FANfiction. just keep that in mind before you hate, much love!
Two summers ago, Cecilia Monroe Sutton vanished from Beechwood Island.
No explanation. No goodbye. The Sinclairs never spoke of her again - not even the Liars, who once swore she was one of them. Now, the summer after everything burned, Cecilia returns.
She walks back into a world still cracked with grief and secrets. She has memory gaps. Cadence and Mirren watch her like a threat. Gat won't look her in the eyes. And Johnny - Johnny remembers everything, especially the part where he let her go.
But Cecilia didn't come back for closure.
She came back because someone is lying.
And the truth is colder than the water that surrounds Beechwood.
What happened the summer she left?
What really happened the summer they burned?
And who decides who belongs - and who gets erased?
All Rights Reserved
#16
cadencesinclair
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
𝐒𝐄𝐀𝐒𝐎𝐍 𝐎𝐅 𝐓𝐇𝐄 𝐖𝐈𝐓𝐂𝐇 | ˢᵒᵃ | ʲᵃˣ ᵗᵉˡˡᵉʳ
| Jax Teller x OC mini fic - COMPLETED | Charming wasn't Hazel's home anymore, not after she fell in love with her sister's husband. With Jax, she had a wonderful time, a forbidden love, but it had to end before the heartbreak would become too much to bear. He knew her secret, that she was different from others, and with that in mind, she moved back to Redding, CA, to her old apartment, which was ready to move back in after extensive renovations. But Jax couldn't live with that loss, without her. Still stuck in his marriage to Tara, his frustration built up until he couldn't bear it anymore. He needed her, her kindness, her innocence, which was always a light in his dark everyday life- and his boys needed her too. But what his longing to be with her would do, no one had initially anticipated. The drama escalated to the point where only Hazel's abilities could help, and it wasn't pretty. • In honor of the spooky season, OC has witch powers in this short fanfiction. They won't be the focus of the story, but they will be a small part of it. It will also include a chapter from my Halloween One Shots, after some people asked me last year if I could turn it into a story; and here I am! ✨Complete
LITTLE WHITE LIES, 𝗃𝗈𝗁𝗇𝗇𝗒 𝗌𝗂𝗇𝖼𝗅𝖺𝗂𝗋 (ENG)
Audrey Wren has spent every summer of her life on Beechwood, a guest of the Sinclair family. A haven made of warm sand, clear sea, and August nights filled with laughter. Until the fifteenth summer. The one she never lived. The one she left behind - silences, unsent messages, and the weight of a loss no one on the island truly understands. Now, a year later, Audrey returns. She returns to the Liars: Mirren, Cadence, Gat, and Johnny Sinclair, the friend who searched for her everywhere for months, never knowing what her silence concealed. But Beechwood is no longer the same. Beneath the golden surface, secrets smolder like embers under the sand. And there is a truth no one dares to look at for too long. As the days drift by in forced smiles and old routines, Audrey finds herself drawn into a slow, relentless bond with Johnny-a taut thread between friendship, unspoken wounds, and a spark that could set everything ablaze. And while a name lingers in the air like an echo-Lydia Cray-Audrey will discover that some lies are only light in appearance. One summer. One secret. And a truth that burns not only houses, but hearts. cover by @vondutchwpComplete
...
Complete
𝙩𝙝𝙚 𝙡𝙖𝙨𝙩 𝙜𝙧𝙚𝙖𝙩 𝙖𝙢𝙚𝙧𝙞𝙘𝙖𝙣 𝙙𝙮𝙣𝙖𝙨𝙩𝙮, ʲᵒʰⁿⁿʸ ˢⁱⁿᶜˡᵃⁱʳ
» the last great american dynasty by taylor swift « 2:22 ────〇── 3:50 ⇄ ◃◃ ⅠⅠ ▹▹ ↻ Vivienne Whitmore was the first grandchild of the Whitmore dynasty - the perfect heir, the golden child, the living symbol of a family built on power and lies. On the outside, she was flawless. On the inside, she was unraveling. Every summer, she returned to Beechwood Island, the place she loved more than anything - the salt air, the grand houses, the endless ocean. To Vivienne, Beechwood was home, her only safe place. And it was there that she had Johnny Sinclair. He was laughter in the dark, rebellion in a smile, her one forbidden love. The Sinclairs were not the Whitmores - never as untouchable, never as powerful - and for that, she was told she could never have him. But Vivienne had never cared about rules. This summer, Beechwood will not be the paradise it once was. Secrets will rise with the tide. Love will blur into destruction. And the fire waiting beneath their perfect world will burn everything she thought she could keep. johnny sinclair x oc, we were liars cover by @pizzakinsComplete
Gangleader's Lost
He loved me, He loved me not He loved me, but not, in the way I needed him to say. "When you lose someone who use to be your everything it's like if the sun was to collapse or all the oxygen in the air was to run out. You don't think you can live without it and in fact you can't, because you become so immune to it, that there isn't life without it. I guess that's what happened when he left. " -Gangleader's lost, Jinx It had been 4 years since Jinx left the town she grew up in behind her in hopes of a more stable and normal life after she was broken in the best way possible by the Anderson's. But what if a tragedy strikes in the most unexpected way causing her to have to come back? What if the Anderson's are back, the ones who caused her disappearance in the first place? // It's been 4 years since Ace Anderson took his gang and left as far away as they all possibly could, all to protect his younger brother. But what if faith takes its course and gives him another chance to say all the things he couldn't all those years ago, but would Jinx actually believe him or would it just be a Gangleader's Lost? *Book 2 but can be read as a stand alone.* Heads will bump and hearts will collide and who's to say they'll all make it out alive.Complete
Two Truths & One Lie (J.S.)
All Aubrey wanted was one last perfect summer-but with the Sinclairs, perfection always comes at a cost. ***** ***** ***** 𝑆𝓊𝓂𝓂𝑒𝓇 𝒮𝒾𝓍𝓉𝑒𝑒𝓃 𝒸𝒽𝒶𝓃𝑔𝑒𝒹 𝑒𝓋𝑒𝓇𝓎𝓉𝒽𝒾𝓃𝑔. Aubrey Scott was never a Sinclair, but every summer on Beechwood Island made her feel like she was. The lemon trees, the barefoot dinners, the scent of salt on Johnny Sinclair's hoodie - it was more than tradition. It was home. But this summer wasn't like the others. Cracks formed. Truths unraveled. And something in the air-like smoke-warned that nothing gold can stay. Because some summers leave marks you don't see until it's far too late. (We Were Liars, 2025)Complete
Summer to Remember | ✓
It's been five years since the sudden disappearance of Cora Cadigan's mother. Five years since the case was closed before it even began. In the final summer before the end of high school, Cora knows it's her last opportunity to find the answers she so desperately needs. Only her luck has never quite worked out. Until golden-boy, Rhys Laderman, that is. Rhys has the type of connections Cora needs in order to learn the truth. Unfortunately for her, she's despised his rich kid facade and cocky attitude from the moment he was born. Only, if she wants the answers, Rhys holds the key. A dangerous key that could set off a chain reaction. Will Cora move past old town rivalries and the dangerous spark she feels with Rhys to solve the mystery that has haunted her for five years? It's her final summer to find the answers. A summer to remember. Cover designed by Ria AmeliaComplete
Come Back To Me - ✓
[+18]* NOW COMPLETE* Back Series Book 2 Dylan's been a good boy all his life but there's this insurgent flame that has been burning inside him and it's waiting for the right moment to be let out. He doesn't know what or why but he knows that something is missing in his life. That shift happens when he, literally, falls into Luna. Luna's life wasn't easy and living it to the fullest is her best escape. She is a 'bad' girl that is hiding a soft heart on the inside and she catches Dylan's attention from the beginning. But Dylan has always looked up to his parents and their strong love story and the fact that he is also in love with his childhood best friend was all he could wish for. Or wasn't it? All Dylan knows is that things are bound to go down at some point... But it seems that for Luna he doesn't mind turning his world upside down.Complete
Forbidden Arrow
Carmela had the perfect friends, the perfect school, the dream life. She was the girl everyone wanted to be and the girl every guy wanted to have. Until, she changed from popular to avoided--forgotten. But one crazy night seals her fate as she meets someone, someone that is willing to show her things that she has never seen before, opened her eyes to a new world. Someone that filled the hole made her feel like herself again. But, before she even gets his name she is left with alone with half a phone number. When they meet again strange things start happening, mystery notes, creepy voice, eerie walks home, and people threatening her life. Carmela begins to feel unsafe in the neighbourhood she's grown up in. Soon they're both thrown into a life altering situation, which they have rush against the clock to survive. Besides, will she ever get that phone number?Complete
The Gravity of You
He was the boy who left. She was the girl who couldn't forget. One year. 365 days of silence. That's what Aiden gave Emma when he walked out of her life without a trace. Now he's back, with a darkness in his eyes she doesn't recognize and a pull she doesn't remembers being this strong. What do you do when the boy who shattered your world walks back into it a year later, with the same crooked smile and a million secrets in his eyes? When the old, electric pull between them is stronger than ever. Between jealous friends, a toxic ex, and the suffocating weight of the secrets he's still keeping, Emma finds herself pulled towards him all over again. He's determined to win her back, one stolen moment, one possessive touch, and one heartbreaking confession at a time. But rebuilding a love on the ashes of the past is a dangerous game. And this time, the fire might just burn them both to the ground.Complete
𝔹𝕃𝔼𝔼𝔻 𝔽𝕆ℝ 𝕄𝔼
☾☀︎︎☽ 𝔻 𝕒 𝕞 𝕠 𝕟 𝕋 𝕠 𝕣 𝕣 𝕒 𝕟 𝕔 𝕖 ☾☀︎︎☽ ఌ 𝔻𝕖𝕧𝕚𝕝'𝕤 ℕ𝕚𝕘𝕙𝕥, 𝔽𝕒𝕟 𝔽𝕚𝕔𝕥𝕚𝕠𝕟 ఌ ꧁------------------------------------------꧂ ''Tell me, when did it start?'' He begged. I could see his eyes under the mask. His hair was pushed back and even if I knew him better than anyone, he scared me. ''You're so full of yourself'' I said, pissed off he even dared to come here. ''I am fucking serious Lina, when did it start?'' I flinched. He hadn't used that nickname since I came back. I realized this was the first time we genuinely were having a conversation about what happened. And it was about him, not me. ''The summer I left'' ఌ this story happens while they are young and will continue after Damon goes to prison ఌ UNFINISHEDComplete
Skin Of An Angel
• completed • If you notice any errors then please let me know • second book is now published With no mum in the picture Lina's life is turned upside down when her brother and dad are both killed and she is left with no more family. She falls in love and thinks it's going to last forever but one night her 'soul mate' raises his hands to her. After making excuse for him for months she finally gets the courage and leaves town, leaving her friends behind. She moves to another City and after a few weeks she starts to get her life back on track. A job, new flat and freedom. What more could she want? When she meets Tom they get off on the right foot but eventually their paths meet too often for it to not to faith but will she be able to trust another boy again? Everyone has secrets and Tom hides the biggest one of them all and once it comes out the rest of the secrets of her life comes out and she realises she doesn't know who she or anyone in her life is. Will she be able to find herself and follow in her father's footsteps or will she pick her own path?Complete
old money: we were liars // johnny sinclair
charlotte ames came from money. old money. though, that money really never did too much for her. charlotte was born to pure elegance, yet raised until the age of nine by her opioid addicted mother. when everyone has left her behind, only her family's closest friends, the sinclair family, are left. between charlotte ames's golden hair, tall stature, and monumental trust fund, she fits perfectly into the lives of this coastal, cashmere-soft family who spend their summers on their private beechwood island. in fact, she fits in even better with the "liars," cadence, mirren, johnny, and gat. charlotte has spent her years, and especially summers, indulging in sinclair summers, parties, and even skirmish bickerings. she is one of the "american royalty" who live in this perfect, perfect world. well, perfect until you look closer. there was an accident the summer of sixteen. exactly what, charlotte cannot seem to remember, as she does her best to drown herself in pills and flickerings of memories. what she can remember: being desperately in love with johny sinclair; reckless, impossible, and as carved into her as the shoreline. their story has always felt written in salt air and champagne bubbles. but when the lies they've all been telling start to surface, charlotte must untangle the truth from trauma, memory from in-between the pills, and love from legacy. when she returns to the island summer 17, charlotte finds herself in a haunting romance steeped in vintage linen, beach lilies, seashells, and the ache of trying to remember the fire she may have started. charlotte will soon learn beautiful people do terrible things, and old money can't fix burns this deep. season 1 // female oc x johnny sinclair childhood friends to lovers
𝐑𝐢𝐩𝐭𝐢𝐝𝐞 | 𝐖𝐞 𝐖𝐞𝐫𝐞 𝐋𝐢𝐚𝐫𝐬
Riptide | We Were Liars From the tortured life of being a Rothschild, to the calming rippled waves of Beechwood, Blair had received a welcome escape from her everyday life every summer since the age of eight. Beechwood was nothing short of magic to her, and the friends she had made through it were no exception. The Liars ; Cady, Johnny, Mirren, Gat, and Blair were inseparable. The Sinclairs had their secrets and flaws, but Blair was a Rothschild ; surely it couldn't get much worse than it already was, right? [What To Expect] We Were Liars Fem OC x Johnny Sinclair Chapter Format Best Friends Friends to lovers [Highest Rankings] #1 in Johnny Sinclair #1 in Cadence Sinclair #1 in We Were Liars #1 in The Sinclairs #1 in Riptide Started : 25th/June/2025 Finished : 7th/February/2026 Edited : (Unedited) EscapeIntoOblivionComplete
Nefarious (4 Ch. Sample)
The Oak Harbor Massacre. A sweet sixteen party. Eight murdered. Others injured. Among the dead Rylan's parents & twin sister. What started off as a night with family & friends under the stars & twinkle lights endes in a bloody scene of screams & death. For years Rylan led everyone to believe she didn't want to speak of that night. Any part of that night. Magical or horrific. When in truth is Rylan has no memory of the attacks that night. Only what she had seen on tv or the internet over the years. And from the scars that covered her body from the brutal attack on her. Six years later Ryaln returns to her family's summer home to finally say goodbye to the past & put the house on the market. And maybe just maybe jog her memories. Was the face of the killer hidden away somewhere in the recesses of her mind? Would being back in Oak Harbor, back in that house, wake her memories? With plans to only stay a month Rylan gets right to work on the house with no intentions of reconnecting with old friends from that horrific night. But life has other plans for Rylan Somers. Old friendships grow stronger. New relationships get started. Lies are exposed. And the nightmare wakes back up ans this time is has a name... Nefarious. Will Rylan Somers make it out alive again? Or will Nefarious finally have the revenge they seek? I am posting the first four chapters of my book Nefarious here on Wattpad. The full book can be purchased online. I always make sure to disclose that even though I work long and hard hours on all my books they are by no means perfect. There are mistakes from grammar and punctuations. I apologize in advance if you feel you have wasted your time and or money on my works. Thanks.Complete
ʙᴀᴄᴋ ғᴏʀ sᴜᴍᴍᴇʀ
'𝑊𝑒 𝑤𝑒𝑟𝑒 𝐿𝑖𝑎𝑟𝑠' Anastasia , Stassie, Sinclair was the youngest of the liars. The last to join really, once Johnny allowed his younger sister to join. Anastasia was the opposite of her brother, calm, shy and inquisitve. But still held the same boundless energy as Johnny. But this story isn't about family and happy endings. It's about actions and consequences. After summer fifteen, the island wasn't the same again. Clairmont was different. A new modern building scarce of grandma's belongings and grandfather beloved newspaper decorations. The aunts all acted different and when Candence Sinclair comes back to the island on summer 17. Secrets are revealed and the horrific truth of what really happened during Summer fifteen. ᴡᴇ ᴡᴇʀᴇ ʟɪᴀʀs![Secrets cannot stay hidden forever ¹ | S.S ✔️ [EDITED]](https://img.wattpad.com/cover/312624706-256-k903748.jpg)
Secrets cannot stay hidden forever ¹ | S.S ✔️ [EDITED]
[BOOK 1] Katherine was best friends with Scott and stiles but when she turned 9 she had to leave and go back to New Orleans she never came back after a few years and when she came back she has her mothers name to keep herself out of danger and her sister too they were both so special that supernatural creatures came after them that's why Hayley Marshall decided to take them back to beacon hills to live and have a normal life. But was beacon hills will be normal after a tragic night at the sheriff's station everything changed. Katherine has secrets that only she and her family know and stiles will figure out that something weird is going on with her after Katherine will have to reveal her secrets to him. Start at season 2 teen wolf & the originals season 5 (Author notes: this is the first story I did and if some spelling errors it's because I'm not good but hope you like it. I don't own any of the characters only Katherine.) 𝗕𝗢𝗢𝗞 1/6 Started: June 26, 2022 Finished: August 23, 2022 [EDITING]Complete
blessed
On Beechwood Island, it is always summer. The Sinclair family owns the sand, the houses, and the legacy, but Lorelei Bistre has only ever borrowed it. With her brown eyes, brown curls, and poetic heart, she's the outsider the Liars let in. The fifth, the quiet one. The girl who loved Johnny Sinclair when no one was supposed to know. Now it's Summer Sixteen. Lorelei returns to the island, her place at the dinner table secure but delicate. Mirren, her best friend, pulls her into late-night swims and wine-fueled secrets. Gat reads her poetry. Cadence confides in her. And Johnny, Johnny smiles that smile only she gets. Everything feels golden. Too golden. Because something simmers beneath the surface, family tension, inheritance wars, and a reckless plan born out of desperation. And then the fire happens. By Summer Seventeen, Cadence is back-but nothing is right. The island is quieter. The air is heavier. And the Liars, who laugh and drink and walk the beach with her, are keeping a devastating secret. Cadence can't stop asking questions. Lorelei won't give her answers. Because the truth is this: They are all gone. And Cadence is the only one left to remember them. ‼️ I DO NOT OWN THE CHARACTERS (except lorelei) OR ANYTHING TAKEN FROM THE BOOK/SHOW. ALL OF IT BELONGS TO E. LOCKHART ‼️ 8/6/25 - 4 in #mirren 8/11/25 - 4 in #gat 9/25/25 - 1 in #gat
𝐂𝐡𝐚𝐨𝐬 𝐓𝐡𝐞𝐨𝐫𝐲 ▷ Stiles Stilinski¹
𝐄𝐯𝐞𝐧 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐬𝐦𝐚𝐥𝐥𝐞𝐬𝐭 𝐨𝐟 𝐚𝐥𝐭𝐞𝐫𝐚𝐭𝐢𝐨𝐧𝐬 𝐜𝐚𝐧 𝐡𝐚𝐯𝐞 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐠𝐫𝐞𝐚𝐭𝐞𝐬𝐭 𝐜𝐨𝐧𝐬𝐞𝐪𝐮𝐞𝐧𝐜𝐞𝐬 Riley Winters knew nothing good would come from looking for a dead body in the middle of the night with two of her best friends, but that didn't stop her from going anyway. That night set off a domino effect that would change the lives of her and her friends forever. For better or worse? She wasn't sure yet. [Featured in Wattpad Fanfic's 'Web & TV Series FF' Reading List] ---------- •COMPLETED• 05/06/2020 STILES STILINSKI X OC First in the Riley Winters Trilogy xoxo - WrathfulDeity **SEASON 1, 2, 3A, 3B** So this is my new fan fiction, I hope you enjoy it! #2 in 'stiles' (12/20) #2 'scottmccall' (11/2021) #21 in 'dylanobrien' (11/20) #2 in 'crystalreed' (03/21) #1 in 'teenwolffanfic' (07/22) And please don't copyright, even if the story sucks, I would rather it stays mine. COPYRIGHT 2017 ©WrathfulDeityComplete
The Everlasting Love
"In a second, this overwhelming feeling he always had around her crashed through him and it felt like taking a deep breath for the first time in almost two decades. This was what he felt for her. This was the unhealthy obsession that had no ground nor reason but just existed from the moment he first laid eyes on her. His father had called it the Oswald curse, the way the men in the family only loved once and hard." -- June Dylan spent half of her life in prison for a crime she didn't commit. Seventeen years behind bars, a lifetime, her children's whole life. Determined to make up for all the time lost, she moves back to the town that had opened the gate to hell all those years ago. Thomas Oswald is cursed. Cursed to love that woman with every fiber of his being and seventeen years apart didn't change that fact. However she wants nothing to do with him now. Fortunately, they have two children together whom have her entire devotion.Complete
| Jax Teller x OC mini fic - COMPLETED | Charming wasn't Hazel's home anymore, not after she fell in love with her sister's husband. With Jax, she had a wonderful time, a forbidden love, but it had to end before the heartbreak would become too much to bear. He knew her secret, that she was different from others, and with that in mind, she moved back to Redding, CA, to her old apartment, which was ready to move back in after extensive renovations. But Jax couldn't live with that loss, without her. Still stuck in his marriage to Tara, his frustration built up until he couldn't bear it anymore. He needed her, her kindness, her innocence, which was always a light in his dark everyday life- and his boys needed her too. But what his longing to be with her would do, no one had initially anticipated. The drama escalated to the point where only Hazel's abilities could help, and it wasn't pretty. • In honor of the spooky season, OC has witch powers in this short fanfiction. They won't be the focus of the story, but they will be a small part of it. It will also include a chapter from my Halloween One Shots, after some people asked me last year if I could turn it into a story; and here I am! ✨
More detailsContent Guidelines