Folklore For Evermore

Three teenagers in the 1940s, tied together by an invisible string that will intertwine their stories for the foreseeable future. Stories long lost to folklore shall now be told for evermore.
James, the school's biggest dreamboat. His life is perfect. He's handsome, he has a good friend group, and a perfect home life. Every girl wants him, but his eyes are only set on Betty, the love of his life since the first time he saw her. That is, until a new girl comes into his life. She changes everything for him, and he knows he'll have to choose eventually, he can feel August slipping away, only a moment in time. Who will James choose?
Betty, quiet to most, but quite talkative to those she love. Growing up in an abusive home, she is not quick to trust others, having a small but tight-knit friend group. James may have loved her from the moment they met, but Betty loved him ferociously from when she fell. However, when someone new comes into the picture, their relationship is tested. Will James and Betty become another story lost to folklore, or shall they remain together for evermore like they dreamed?
Augustine, the new girl in town. Growing up in upstate New York and having to move to Pennsylvania, she is not thrilled about this new journey, especially when she finds out she'll be enrolled in a Catholic private school instead of the public school in her new town. But when she meets James, her life flips upside down. He may have a girlfriend, but Augustine knows that they were made for each other. James has to choose her, right?