Caught Between Bases
- Reads 392
- Votes 3
- Parts 4
Ongoing6m
Last published Tue, Sep 23, 2025
Avery Blake is the Savannah Bananas' Clutch Queen - the only woman on the team, a fierce first baseman, ace pitcher, and the player everyone counts on when the game is on the line. But behind the roar of the crowd and the bright stadium lights, Avery's life is anything but simple.
Between practice, games, and the pressure to prove herself in a male-dominated sport, Avery finds herself caught in a different kind of game - a heart-stopping love triangle with two teammates who both want more than just friendship. Jackson Olson is steady and dependable, a teammate she trusts with every play on the field. Tanner Thomas is fiery and relentless, challenging her in ways no one else ever has.
As the season heats up, Avery must navigate the tricky bases of loyalty, desire, and ambition - all while juggling the weight of being a trailblazer in Banana Ball. In a game where every move counts, can Avery find the courage to follow her heart without striking out?
---
Inspired by Torn by glitterxcrimson_ please go read that story it's amazing
All Rights Reserved
#58
savannahbananas
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
41 Reasons ( Bronson "Bronny" Balholm x Reader ) ✅
Two years ago, Y/N walked away from Noah Fisher after a fight that neither of them fully understood at the time. She thought leaving would heal the pain-but life had other plans. Trapped in a controlling, abusive relationship, Y/N spent nights running from fear and days trying to survive. Now, she's back in Savannah, offered a job as the Party Animals' athletic trainer-and suddenly, she's face-to-face with Noah again. The man she once loved, the man who still stirs something deep in her chest. As past wounds resurface, Y/N must navigate her anxiety, panic attacks, and the shadows of her past, all while working alongside the team and confronting the tension with Noah. Can two people so fiercely tied together find trust again? Or will the mistakes of the past keep them apart, even as their hearts race back toward each other?Complete
9 Innings of Love: A Savannah Banana's and Party Animals Love Story
Olivia Jones is the cousin of the famous Savannah Banana 2nd Baseman Dalton Mauldin. Her and Dalton both get to spend eight months of the year on the Savannah Banana's tour. Olivia loves her job and gets along with everyone, well almost everyone. There's one player that she can't stand to be around. Unfortunately for her, that person is none other than Dalton's best friend and roommate Tanner Thomas. Will her opinion change though after getting to see a different side of Tanner? This story is complete, but if you'd like to read more of my work then make sure to check out my Jackson Olson story as well! :)Complete
Collide ( Noah fisher x Reader ) ✅
Y/N never planned on working for the Party Animals-especially not as the team's new athletic trainer. With a history of anxiety, toxic parents, and an ex who left scars deeper than anyone can see, the last thing she needs is a roster full of cocky ballplayers testing her patience. And then there's Noah Fisher. Number 12. Blonde hair, easy smile, and a talent for getting under her skin. To him, she's too serious. To her, he's too loud, too reckless, too Noah. They clash from day one-arguments in the dugout, sarcastic remarks, and tension thick enough to cut with a bat. But when an unexpected panic attack leaves Y/N vulnerable, Noah is the only one who notices. The only one who stays. Beneath the playful arrogance, she finds someone steady, protective, and impossible to ignore. In a world of found family, chaotic games, and unspoken wounds, enemies become something more. And Y/N must decide if she's ready to let down her guard... and discover that maybe, just maybe, she's finally safe at home.Complete
Torn - J. Olson / T. Thomas
Lilly Pierce grew up next door to Jackson Olson, they are the best of friends, pretty much inseparable actually. She would go to all his games when they were in school and college. His #1 cheer leader, always. Though since he joined a new team, she hasn't really got to see him as much. So when he asks her to join him for his baseball season with the TikTok famous, the Savannah Bananas, how could she say no? A whole season? Yes please! As they spend more time together Jackson tells Lilly his feelings are more than just good friends. Though when Lilly meets Tanner Thomas, it becomes clear there is an instant attraction there as well. What's worse is Tanner belongs to the rival team, the Party Animals. So when Lilly is faced with both boys wanting her affection, she finds herself torn between the boy she loved her whole life, or the new exciting prospect of a man who just happens to look very good in pink!Complete
The Bananas Effect
Olivia never expected her summer internship to be... this chaotic. Tasked with filming the chaos packed Savannah Bananas, she's juggling cameras, dancing baseball players, and an outfielder with a smile that won't leave her mind. KJ Jackson is fun, charming, and utterly impossible to ignore - especially when he's constantly getting in her way, teasing her, or somehow making even the messiest moments feel magical. But Olivia has rules: crushes are forbidden, emotions are dangerous, and work is work. From blender explosions to banana costume disasters, slow-motion swings to Mic'd Up madness, Olivia and KJ's hearts might just collide... whether they're ready or not. Can love survive the chaos of the Savannah Bananas... or will it strike out before it even gets a chance to run home?
Complete Chaos - A Banana Ball Love Story
Alli had one rule: never fall for a baseball player-especially not one who flirts like it's his job and kisses like he invented it. At twenty years old, Alli's the new social media manager for the Savannah Bananas, a viral baseball team best known for their dancing, stunts, and complete disregard for normal. She's smart, sarcastic, and absolutely not here to make friends-especially not the cocky third baseman who makes her heart stutter and her blood boil in equal measure. Enter KJ Jackson. Six-foot-three of tattoos, swagger, and sin, with a roster full of girls and zero interest in commitment. He's Banana Ball's golden boy-cocky, charming, and dangerously hot. Alli's just the new challenge. A pretty face to tease. A no-strings, off-limits distraction. Until suddenly... she's not. What starts as a flirtationship quickly spirals into stolen moments, late-night confessions, accidental intimacy, and a kiss that changes everything. But Alli's hiding something. And KJ? He's never had to chase someone who runs this fast. With team gossip swirling, the internet watching, and their careers on the line, they'll have to decide if their game is worth the risk-or if this was always destined to crash and burn. Filled with slow-burn tension, spicy banter, unhinged teammates, and one wildly chaotic love story-Complete Chaos is a romance that'll make you scream, cry, and maybe fall in love with a baseball player you definitely shouldn't.Complete
Two years ago, Y/N walked away from Noah Fisher after a fight that neither of them fully understood at the time. She thought leaving would heal the pain-but life had other plans. Trapped in a controlling, abusive relationship, Y/N spent nights running from fear and days trying to survive. Now, she's back in Savannah, offered a job as the Party Animals' athletic trainer-and suddenly, she's face-to-face with Noah again. The man she once loved, the man who still stirs something deep in her chest. As past wounds resurface, Y/N must navigate her anxiety, panic attacks, and the shadows of her past, all while working alongside the team and confronting the tension with Noah. Can two people so fiercely tied together find trust again? Or will the mistakes of the past keep them apart, even as their hearts race back toward each other?
More detailsContent Guidelines