The Night that I regret beneath a moonless sky
- Reads 15
- Votes 0
- Parts 1
Ongoing<5 mins
Last published Sat, Aug 16, 2025
An alternate version of Love Never Dies
What if Christine decided to tell Raoul about the phantom coming to her on the night before her wedding and she was forced to do the deed against her will, she decides to make the child be legitimate with Raoul because she moved on from the past, to protect her child from the phantom, but 10 years later, someone invites Christine and her family to New York, where she has to fight for her child against the man she no longer knows...
All Rights Reserved
#836
phantomoftheopera
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
Come into the Light
"I have realized... it is better to be alone, Meg. The people I love won't get hurt." He whispered to me and then I saw him. The man I know and love; the man torn between wanting to love and scared of it; the man wanting to feel but runs away from everything that makes him feel because he is afraid of losing it. "I learned with Christine that I cannot love, Meg. I cannot love anyone...I only hurt them. And no one can love me. Who could?" "I could." I couldn't believe I just said it. He froze and I just kept talking, afraid the words would stop coming out of my mouth. "That's where you're wrong, Erik. You've always believed that no one could ever love you, all of you, even with your deformity. And yet, I have loved you since I was seventeen years old. You hid yourself behind the "Phantom of the Opera" but I never saw a Phantom. I saw a man desperate to be loved, to be loved not only for his music but for himself. I thought Christine could be the one to finally show you that love since I was so afraid to do so. But not afraid of you but what I know you would say. Christine chose wrong, Erik. I would've chosen you in a heartbeat... I do choose you."Complete
Unconventional
Hello! So I've been working really hard on this story, and the idea came to me back in 2016 when I had my daughter. It is a little out there and I feel sorry for Raoul, but... then there'd be no story! Enough preamble... I do not own any of the characters. Thank you for reading, I hope you enjoy it.Complete
A Girl's Desire (Phantom Of The Opera x Reader)
[COMPLETE] When Y/n signed a risky contract with the Phantom, then agreed to spend six months living in the basement with him, she was clueless about what the future held. Like the dutiful errand girl Y/n is, she follows his commands precisely-until lives tangle in a mess that she's responsible for. After Christine leaves forever, will Y/n build a life from the ashes of ruin, or will her dreams crumble around her? #1 in erikxreader 6/3/23 #1 in raouldechagny 5/28/23Complete
Once upon another time - ENG
What would happen if, after Gustave's birth, Raoul discovered he wasn't his father? With no one to help her, Christine goes to the opera with Gustave. Will she find Erik there? Will their fates intertwine again?
The Music Of A Nights Flame
The Phantom Of The Opera. Erik Destler. And with Christine's older sister, Mavis Daaé, Mavis knew nothing of him. But he knew everything of her. But one day... he shows himself. The two quickly became inseparable from each other, and quickly realized the love blooming in front of them. Until her sister found out, and banned them from ever seeing each other again. They couldn't stand it no. So with the help of Madam Giry, they finally were able to see each other. Where the confessed their love for one another. Not soon after, he stole her once more. For two months. Everyone feared for her. But not Madam Giry. As the time went on, the love grew stronger and near impossible to break. But what would happen if they actually follow his rules for once? Find out.Complete
Waiting in the Wings (Love Never Dies fanfic)
We all know what happened on-stage in the finale of "Love Never Dies"... but things look very different to the characters trapped behind the scenes. Just what is Christine trying to tell Raoul on stage? And whom would Raoul trust to take Gustave back to his mother? Choices made with the best of intentions can have tragically unexpected consequences... 'Missing scenes' for the revised 'Australian version': canon-based.Complete
CONEY ISLAND
10 years ago Christine and Erik parted, now she's married to Raoul and has a child, Gustave. Everything changes once their paths cross again. It seems like everyone is keeping secrets from each other, everyone are a different person than they used to be and soon, drama comes in *story cover not mine* BASICALLY LOVE NEVER DIES BUT WITH A BETTER ENDING AND DIFFERENT PLOT TWISTSComplete
Let Your Fantasies Unwind
What if the Phantom wasn't alone pulling off all those tricks? What if he had an assistant? And what if his assistant knew him? This is the story of Megan Williams, a girl from the future with a passion for Phantom of the Opera, the fictional world that she grew up with... is now her reality. ____________ This will be a 'slow burn' as my friend calls it. Most of the story is building the relationship between Erik and Megan, and then everything comes crashing down. ;-) Sunday, Wednesday, and Friday updates. Completed. Found the image on Google Images. Don't know who's the original artist. ^^;Complete
Her Innocence || Phantom of the Opera
"Christine, I love you." The phantom's voice played a sweet tune in my mind. It was the first time he had confessed his love, but sadly, I couldn't return the favor. He had given me everything, fame, fortune, and a life of excitement and curiosity. Still, he had threatened to hang my beloved Raoul and sentence me to an eternity locked away from the world. My clammy hands shook with emotion as I slid the beautiful, diamond ring off my finger. The disfigured man helplessly gazed into my eyes, transforming my soul. I was the only one to look past his hideous physical appearance, to know how to comfort a creature of darkness; I couldn't bare holding in my emotions any longer. Tears plunged down my pale cheeks and I looked down to take his hand. Making sure not to drop the small item, I closed his rough fingers around the ring. "Goodbye," all sadness echoing through my word. I spun around and dragged my wedding dress through the foggy water to meet Raoul's awaiting boat. *** UPDATE 2020: Hello, all! I realized that this book recently gained traction in the fanfic world of Wattpad, again. Unfortunately, I wrote this back in 2014 and have yet to go through and edit. At one point, I planned on making a sequel to this. I don't expect to do so any time soon, but I appreciate the reads and the comments!Complete
Little Phantom on Adventure
Emma is tired of life in the Phantom's lair. Her father's lair. Erik kept his daughter in the catacombs under the Opera Populaire in fear of losing her, but what if keeping her locked away from the outside world is exactly what makes him lose her. As Emma steps out of the Opera she meets and befriends Eponine and the Barricade boys, Emma fights at the barricade, almost all her friends dying before her, but her love for the infamous (dead) Leader, Enjolras, still grows. And will Christine ever come into her life? And what about Gustave and Raoul? Oh well... Love Never Dies.Complete
"I have realized... it is better to be alone, Meg. The people I love won't get hurt." He whispered to me and then I saw him. The man I know and love; the man torn between wanting to love and scared of it; the man wanting to feel but runs away from everything that makes him feel because he is afraid of losing it. "I learned with Christine that I cannot love, Meg. I cannot love anyone...I only hurt them. And no one can love me. Who could?" "I could." I couldn't believe I just said it. He froze and I just kept talking, afraid the words would stop coming out of my mouth. "That's where you're wrong, Erik. You've always believed that no one could ever love you, all of you, even with your deformity. And yet, I have loved you since I was seventeen years old. You hid yourself behind the "Phantom of the Opera" but I never saw a Phantom. I saw a man desperate to be loved, to be loved not only for his music but for himself. I thought Christine could be the one to finally show you that love since I was so afraid to do so. But not afraid of you but what I know you would say. Christine chose wrong, Erik. I would've chosen you in a heartbeat... I do choose you."
More detailsContent Guidelines