Catholic School Romance (Illi McMillin x Warren Pikes)
- Reads 2,815
- Votes 58
- Parts 23
Ongoing55m
Last published Sun, Nov 23, 2025
(Continuing To Update!!)
Illi McMillin HATES boarding school. Despite her romanticizing, the boys are constantly tormenting her, and the girls aren't much better. All she wants is a memorable senior year, but it's starting to seem that way for all the wrong reasons.
Warren Pikes would rather be anywhere else than school right now. He's grown out of his kid-like innocence and is ready for his last year of this shit to be over. While he doesn't care about making memories, it seems like life has other plans
All Rights Reserved
#17
illimcmillin
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
Slut.
Gerard Way is a virgin. A pathetic, gay, red-haired little virgin. But he was okay with that. People in school avoided him, hell, they didn't even know who he was, and that was how it was. Until a good 'friend' of Gerard's started a rumor. A rumor that was bound to destroy everything Gerard had come to know, and even a little more in the process. Nothing good could come out of this situation, or so Gerard thought. But a certain boy with converse and a lip piercing would beg to differ. (Ok I suck at writing intros. The story will be better, I promise...)Complete![Disbelief in Death [Gerard Way x Reader]](https://img.wattpad.com/cover/112555887-256-k950700.jpg)
Disbelief in Death [Gerard Way x Reader]
[abandoned] You find yourself sitting in a high school desk. Wandering off from your body. Until a boy came along. You stood there in shock. He was gone again. But, will you ever find him again?Complete
Petekey //Secret admirers and sweethearts//
Pete has always been a 'bad kid' his parents hated him, the girls loved him, and he had plenty of friends. That all changed when he's sent away to boarding school. He gets his anger out by making fun of people, one boy in particular, and the fact that the boy liked other boys and wore skirts, Mikey way. But Pete gets a weird feeling in his stomach when he sees the boy, and he can't put his finger on what it is. Mikey way just looks a little too pretty in all of those skirts.Complete
Sass Queen ~ Gerard Way x Reader
{*COMPLETED*} A new high school. Great. Just another place for y/n to become an outcast. Y/n didn't really have any friends at her old school, so it was easier to leave the old place behind. A job opportunity that her father couldn't pass up forced him and y/n to move to Belleview, New Jersey. A boy named Frank Iero took y/n under his wing and quickly became friends with her. He even introduced her to some of his friends. They all liked her and invited her to the friend group. Except Gerard. Gerard made it his mission to not like y/n but deep down inside, he just might have feelings for her that hes hiding.Complete
You Should've Raised A Baby Girl
stupid Illi McMillin fanfic because im transgender and sad. warning, this fic contains slurs, depictions of bullying and harassments.Complete
Desolation Row
"Tearing it up on Desolation Row, huh? Ha! God, I fuckin' wish." "Fuckin' hate it here, man." "Hey! Why don't you pussies stop your whining and come have some fun?" Gerard, Mikey, Pete, Frank, and Bob are stuck in their shitty hometown, affectionately nicknamed "Desolation Row." Born there, die there. That's how they think it works. Ray and Patrick have great lives on the other side of the city border, where everyone lives in giant houses and eats plenty every night and gets a chance to do whatever they want. They don't think anything could stop them from hating each other. Then a catastrophic problem at the other end of town causes two different lifestyles to clash together.Complete
I'm Not Okay... (I promise) // Illi Mcmillin x Warren
#1 in gerardway 2/2/2026 #2 in MCR 1/24/26 #1 in illimcmillin 1/24/26 ((updating regularly))High school is hell, but it's worse when you're Illi McMillin - a comic book-obsessed, eyeliner-wearing trans girl trying to survive sophomore year with zero popularity, no lunch table, and a target on her back. Meanwhile, her freshman brother Mikey Way is out here charming everyone with his glasses, D&D stats, and unintentionally magnetic energy. Illi's not bitter. Okay, she is bitter. In a school ruled by jocks, cheerleaders, and fake smiles, Illi's had enough of being a background character. With a camera, a killer playlist, and the quiet rage of a thousand rejected superheroes, she's ready to fight back - one glorious breakdown at a time. Based loosely on the "I'm Not Okay (I Promise)" music video. Angst, eyeliner, awkward sibling bonding, and the slow burn of finding your voice.
You're beautiful to me (Frerard)
Frank is the new kid at school. He has moved with his mother in an attempt to escape his past, and his father. Gerard is the kid no one talks to. But he likes it that way. He likes being alone, prefers it. When Gerard finds Frank in a less the ideal situation, will all the change? TRIGGER WARNING: self harm, substance abuse, abuse, rape, depression, eating disorderComplete
special -joshler-
ohio school for special boys was a school for boys who were either damaged or dangerous. tyler and josh are roommates //trigger warning: self harm, depression, suicide, suicidal thoughts, anxiety, eating disorders.\\ !lowercase intended! started july 11 finished october 24 complete highest rating #20 joshler november 30-#420 on twenty one pilots tag ty for 2k readsComplete
unknown number // petekey
one message from: Unknown Number Unknown Number: help please help oh my god help me (Completed January 2nd, 2017)Complete
Gerard Way is a virgin. A pathetic, gay, red-haired little virgin. But he was okay with that. People in school avoided him, hell, they didn't even know who he was, and that was how it was. Until a good 'friend' of Gerard's started a rumor. A rumor that was bound to destroy everything Gerard had come to know, and even a little more in the process. Nothing good could come out of this situation, or so Gerard thought. But a certain boy with converse and a lip piercing would beg to differ. (Ok I suck at writing intros. The story will be better, I promise...)
More detailsContent Guidelines