The Dreaded Mirror

The Dreaded Mirror

Reads 24
Votes 1
Parts 5

MatureOngoing9m

Last published Tue, Sep 9, 2025

Fiction

Horror

Tagsgrimdark horror little mlp my

Mirrors show your inner beauty, no? Well... This one highlights every flaw you have. Watch as Rarity descends into madness, digging deep into her paranoia.

All Rights Reserved

Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.

You may also like

The Unusual Pony (MLP x Male reader)
Yeah I like MLP so what? Here have a story about it!
My Little life
This here is a story about how MLP (AKA my little pony) changed my life. I fall into Equestria unexpectedly, and stumble upon some troubles on my trek to find friendship.
Complete
Rarijack (FINISHED) #Wattys2017
2 ponies that despise each other fall in love. After so bickering, they accept each but new challenges and enemies lie ahead in their path.
Complete
Moon Beam (MLP fanfiction)
Through Thick and Thin. You don't have to be an Element of Harmony to be able to harness the magic of friendship. Story Complete!
Complete
Shadows
I'm so afraid. I haven't been able to sleep for some time now. They keep me awake. Every night they come from out the shadows and speak to me. Every night I can hear their laughter, their whispers. The shadows on the walls twist and churn as what lurks within them moves. Every so often I catch a glimpse of one of their too-wide smiles. The things they say to me are unspeakable. It is so wondrous. They fill my head with things I never thought possible. As I lay awake in bed at night, listening to them, I am afraid to hear them. I'm afraid, because I think I'm beginning to enjoy it more and more. I cannot wait until everyone else can hear them too. Until everyone can feel this bliss.
Complete
Curiosity (The Midnight Series) | My Little Pony: Equestria Girls
My Little Pony: Equestria Girls Fanfiction Friends reunite to a grueling discovery. Midnight Sparkle appears once again, slowly tormenting the Mane 7. When jealousy shatters worlds, only friendship can piece them together. Completed. (24k words 8 Chapters) Genre: Adventure, Drama | Warning: Violence | Originally published: Dec. 11, 2019. Final edition: Dec. 22, 2025.
Complete
The Hollowing - MLP Infection AU
A mysterious fungal sickness spreads across Equestria, leaving infected ponies hollowed and broken versions of themselves. Twilight is convinced it all began with Sweetie Belle and races desperately to find a cure. But Starlight sees things differently-how could a young foal, the supposed source, survive far longer than healthy adults struck down around her? As the Cutie Mark Crusaders wrestle with their own fractured bonds, the Mane Six grapple with hidden fears and secrets, while Celestia and Luna confront growing unrest within their realm. In a world unraveling, alliances will be tested, truths questioned, and hope stretched thin. What comes next could change Equestria forever.
Sweetie's Little Accident
Sweetie Belle starts having something many ponies her age go through: Nightmares. The only problem is, these nightmares are causing something else to happen. Sweetie is wetting the bed. In order to solve this problem, Rarity finds a rather unusual solution to help her little sister. This story contains childish and unusual themes such as: Diapers, their use, toys, plushies, very childlike behavior and a lot of innocence.
Complete
A Cure For Sanity
How far would you go to bring your loved one back from the dead. Journey in to the darkness of the forest to unearth things that should be left untouched. Follow the mane six of the my little pony franchise as they face their biggest challenge yet, for a figure from a tragedy long ago, bares secrets best left untold. Sit in the comfort of the darkness with the light of the campfire to guide you as you plunge your way deeper and deeper down deaths row. Fill your fears with quotes from classic MLP creepypastas such as butterflies, cupcakes, rainbow factory, and more. now sit back, relax , turn off the lights, let your guard down and prepare for your cure...
Complete

The Unusual Pony (MLP x Male reader)

Yeah I like MLP so what? Here have a story about it!

Content Guidelines