Each Time I Chose You
- Reads 16
- Votes 0
- Parts 1
MatureOngoing<5 mins
Last published Fri, Sep 19, 2025
William Afton and Clara Afton. Both 10 and 11 when our story begins. 16 and 17 when our story ends. Back when they were known as William Afton and Clara Schmitz. This is a story about their lives together. This is an extremely long book so please have patience! THIS IS VERY TRIGGERING SO BE AWARE!!! More will be in the introduction!
All Rights Reserved
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
Inside These Walls
This is an alternate universe (AU) story inspired by the Afton family from Five Nights at Freddy's. Please note that this story is not canon and does not follow the events of the original FNaF timeline. In a world where darkness looms over the Afton family, secrets, betrayal, and broken bonds create an unsettling tale. The story delves deep into the lives of William Afton and his family, exploring their tragic flaws, twisted relationships, and the consequences of their choices. But behind the facade of a seemingly normal family lies a web of horrors-both physical and emotional. With themes of abuse, domestic violence, and manipulation, this story is not for the faint of heart. It challenges the characters in ways that will leave readers questioning what they thought they knew about the Afton family. Please be advised that this story contains sensitive content that may be upsetting for some readers. Read at your own discretion. Disclaimer: I do not own Five Nights at Freddy's. All rights to the characters and world belong to Steel Wool Studios and Scott Cawthon. Warning: Mature themes ahead. Wretched Proceed with caution.Complete
His Strange Addiction - Dave Miller X GN!Reader
!!!! THIS IS A SEQUEL OF: A game of cat and mouse (you can find it on my profile) !!!! After ten years or so, William Afton under the name of Dave Miller comes back to Hurricane. He's looking for his prey, (Y/N) (L/N), who has changed a lot after the events that took place years before. (Y/N) will have their life turned upside down once again, but this time they will be alone. No friends, no relatives, no one, this time they will have to face William all alone. ⚠ Pictures used in the cover are not mine, they're drawn by Noisx⚠Complete
The Family Reunion - SimmiVerse AU
This is the story of the Afton Family's escape from their tragedy & how they made it to a new life. This is the Alternative Universe of VioletVerse. This will contain some explicit descriptions that may trigger some sensitive people, you are being warned. I also wrote some things either in a hurry, or just lazily because UM I love writing but it gets hella hard, so like this is guaranteed to be cringe or unhinged. 😭 Also, remember, this is different from the canon verse so do not think this is how the Aftons actually are in FNAF. Please enjoy as this took me so much time to create!! Edit (4/14/26) my AU has changed a lot since then but it's still quite similar!!
Turn the spotlight onto me (William Afton X Reader)
After a year, (Y/n) is back in Hurricane and ends up reuniting with her ex-fiancé William Afton. Will the past come back to the surface? The part 2 of the fanfic Come and see the show tonightComplete
Kidnapped |William Afton x reader|
(THIS BOOK IS A TWO PART STORY!) This book will contain things such as: Gore, Death, Fluff, and Foul language You have recently move to a small town in Hurricane Utah and recently get a job at a local pizzeria called Fredbears Family Diner. Then everything goes downhill from there. Look in the conversations tab under my profile for more updates :)Complete
Come and see the show tonight (William Afton X Reader)
William Afton was a man with a troubled life, problems with his family, especially with his wife, but the situation gets even worse when he meets (Y / n).Complete
"𝓢𝓱𝓱𝓱..." ✔
(OLD) (William Afton x reader) (COMPLETED) •----• Incident after incident, she seems to always go back to him no matter how much her mind to tells her not to. - DISCLAIMERS: •Swearing •Gore •Manipulation •Age gap of 9 years •Possible sexual contentComplete
In my mind - A Henry Emily fanfic
Filled with sorrow after the tragedy in his own restaurant, Henry Emily isn't feeling like himself. Although his buisness partner, William Afton is happier than ever, Henry slowly starts to collapse from the inside out. Though.. that brings the question. What will throw him over the edge? TW: May contain: Cursing, Suicide, Suicidal thoughts, Obsession, Death, etc. Please read at your own risk. -DISCLAIMER: THESE CHARACTERS ARE NOT MINE! ALL CREDIT GOES TO SCOTT FOR THESE CHARACTERS. -THIS WILL NOT BE COMPLETELY CANON TO THE STORY, I am mostly following book lore, so it is highly suggested you read those first! Also, I changed some things to better match with the story, and for plot twists, etc. -No need to fear because Henry is a strong lead (in the beginning, anyway. His mental health is dropping, don't blame him! 🙁) unlike some other fanfics which make him a soft uwu boy, he actually knows how to defend himself 💀💀 -This fanfiction switches POVs, at some points in time. It can be in the middle of a chapter, beginning of a chapter, etc. Also, William's one-sided obsession/worship is canon in this universe, but nothing romantic will happen between Henry or William because I just don't ship it. Althought, William may be feeling some feelings, it'll continue to be one sided.Complete
Across The Fence (William Afton x F! Reader)
As a teenager, you were William Afton's biggest nuisance. Always there. In his house, in his space, babysitting his kids like you belonged. You had a knack for getting under his skin-sarcastic, relentless, always pushing, always prying. And he hated it. Hated how you never seemed to leave him alone. But when things got hard-when you were bullied, when your world came crashing down-he was there. Begrudgingly. With a sigh, with a grumble, with that ever-present irritation in his eyes. But he never turned you away. Never let you break completely. A reluctant protector. A reluctant caretaker. And you? You had a crush. A stupid, reckless, all-consuming crush. You knew it was wrong, knew he was older, knew he'd never see you the way you wanted. But that didn't stop you from looking too long, from lingering in his presence, from holding onto something that was never yours to begin with. He noticed. And then he shattered it. You were just a kid. You needed to grow up, move on, find someone your own age. He wasn't interested. He never would be. So you left. Now, six years later, you're back. Older. Wiser. Ready to leave it all in the past. But William has changed too. His marriage is crumbling, his world is a mess, and for the first time, he looks... tired. Like life has drained something vital from him. And somehow, you end up tangled in his orbit again. But this time, it's a game. A lie. A carefully crafted act meant to fool his wife, to make her think he's fine without her. Fake dating. Pretending. Playing a role. It should be easy. You should be able to keep it separate, keep your heart locked away, because you know exactly how this ends. But the more you act, the more real it starts to feel. The more you catch yourself wanting. Hoping. And you swore you'd never let him hurt you again.
I Will Always Hate You (William Afton X reader)
William Afton X reader «gender neutral» ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Y/N L/N is an intelligent 24 year old who just moved back to their home town Hurricane, Utah, with their mom and younger brother, Max. Y/N just seems like a normal person well maybe... William Afton, co-owner of Fredbears family diner. All the town thinks of him as a nice guy. Key word: thinks... One day, (Y/N), their mom, and Max decide to go back to start fresh. But things start to get a bit crazy with (Y/N), as they get tied up into Williams mess. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Cover of book is not mine credits to NoisX Please read warnings before reading!! This may or may not follow fnaf lore idk stop why is this book so cringe 💀Complete
This is an alternate universe (AU) story inspired by the Afton family from Five Nights at Freddy's. Please note that this story is not canon and does not follow the events of the original FNaF timeline. In a world where darkness looms over the Afton family, secrets, betrayal, and broken bonds create an unsettling tale. The story delves deep into the lives of William Afton and his family, exploring their tragic flaws, twisted relationships, and the consequences of their choices. But behind the facade of a seemingly normal family lies a web of horrors-both physical and emotional. With themes of abuse, domestic violence, and manipulation, this story is not for the faint of heart. It challenges the characters in ways that will leave readers questioning what they thought they knew about the Afton family. Please be advised that this story contains sensitive content that may be upsetting for some readers. Read at your own discretion. Disclaimer: I do not own Five Nights at Freddy's. All rights to the characters and world belong to Steel Wool Studios and Scott Cawthon. Warning: Mature themes ahead. Wretched Proceed with caution.
More detailsContent Guidelines